Abstract:Given a finite connected multigraph $G=(V,E)$, the all-terminal reliability function $R(G,p)$ is the probability that $G$ remains connected under percolation with parameter $p$. We develop new results concerning the question of which (multi)graphs~$G$ maximize $R(G,p)$ for a given number of vertices $n$, edges $m$ and a given parameter $p$ -- such graphs are called optimally reliable graphs -- paying particular attention to uniqueness and to whether the answer depends upon $p$. We generalize the concept of a distillation, and build a framework which we use to identify all optimally reliable graphs for which $m-n\in\{1,2,3\}$. These graphs are uniformly optimal in $p$. Many of them have been previously identified, but there are serious problems with these treatments, especially for the case $m-n=3$. We also obtain some partial results for $m-n\in\{4,5\}$. For $m-n=3$, the optimal graphs were incorrectly identified by Wang in 1994, in the infinite number of cases where $m\equiv 5 \pmod{9}$ and $m\geq 14$. This erroneous result, which concerns subdivisions of $K_{3,3}$, has been cited extensively and the mistake has not been detected. Furthermore, while the optimal graphs were correctly identified for other values of $m$, the proof is incorrect, as it also uses a claim for which we give a counterexample. Our proof of the rectified statement is self-contained. Regarding $m-n=4$, it was recently shown by Romero and Safe that the optimal graph depends upon $p$ for infinitely many $m$. We find a new such set of $m$-values, which gives a different perspective on why this phenomenon occurs. This leads us to conjecture that there are only finitely many $m$ for which there are uniformly optimal graphs when $m-n=4$, but that, for $m-n=5$, there are again infinitely many uniformly optimal graphs. We hope that our general results and methods will be useful for continued investigations.

On the roots of the node reliability polynomial

Node Reliability: Approximation, Upper Bounds, and Applications to Network Robustness

Existence of Optimally-Greatest Digraphs for Strongly Connected Node Reliability

On the Split Reliability of Graphs

The Reliability of a Class of Two-Layer Networks with Unreliable Edges

Exact two-terminal reliability of some directed networks

New approximations for network reliability

On Locally Most Reliable Three-Terminal Graphs of Sparse Graphs

Hypergraph Unreliability in Quasi-Polynomial Time

On trees with real rooted independence polynomial

Nonexistence of Uniformly Most Reliable Two-Terminal Graphs.

Uniformly Optimal Digraphs for Strongly Connected Reliability

A new framework for identifying most reliable graphs and a correction to the $K_{3,3}$-theorem

On the Wiener-like root-indices of graphs

On the roots of the subtree polynomial

Almost unimodal and real-rooted graph polynomials

A novel view: edge isoperimetric methods and reliability evaluation of several kinds of conditional edge-connectivity of interconnection networks

Total positivity of some polynomial matrices that enumerate labeled trees and forests. II. Rooted labeled trees and partial functional digraphs

Unimodality of independence polynomials of rooted products of graphs

How many roots of a random polynomial system on a Lie group are real?

The independence polynomial on recursive sequences of graphs