Unraveling the dominant phonon scattering mechanism in thermoelectric compound ZrNiSn

Ankita Katre,Jesús Carrete,Natalio Mingo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/C6TA05868J
2016-07-13
Abstract:Determining defect types and concentrations remains a big challenge of semiconductor materials science. By using ab-initio thermal conductivity calculations we reveal that Ni/vacancy antisites, and not the previously claimed Sn/Zr antisites, are the dominant defects affecting thermal transport in half-Heusler compound ZrNiSn. Our calculations correctly predict the thermal conductivity dependence with temperature and concentration, in quantitative agreement with published experimental results. Furthermore, we find a characteristic proportionality between phonon-antisite scattering rates and the sixth power of phonon frequency, for which we provide an analytic derivation. These results suggest that thermal conductivity measurements in combination with ab-initio calculations can be used to quantitatively assess defect types and concentrations in semiconductors.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine which antisite defects have the greatest impact on heat transport in the thermoelectric compound ZrNiSn. Specifically, through first - principles calculations, the authors revealed that Ni/vacancy antisites, rather than the previously claimed Sn/Zr antisites, are the main defects affecting thermal conductivity. ### Summary of main problems: 1. **Determine the dominant type of antisite defects**: In ZrNiSn, which antisite defect (Sn/Zr or Ni/vacancy) is the main scattering source? 2. **Evaluate the scattering intensity**: What is the scattering intensity of each antisite defect? How do they affect the thermal conductivity of ZrNiSn? 3. **Explain the contradictions in experimental results**: Why are the results obtained by different experimental groups regarding the influence of antisite defects on thermal conductivity inconsistent? ### Key findings of the paper: - **Main scattering mechanism**: Through calculations, the authors found that Ni/vacancy antisite defects have a greater impact on thermal conductivity than Sn/Zr antisite defects. - **Frequency dependence**: The phonon scattering rate of antisite defects is proportional to the sixth power of the phonon frequency (\(\omega^6\)), which is different from the fourth - power dependence (\(\omega^4\)) of traditional point defects. - **Experimental consistency**: The calculation results are in very good agreement with the experimental data of Xie et al., further verifying that Ni/vacancy antisite defects are the main scattering source. ### Conclusion: By combining first - principles calculations and thermal conductivity measurements, the authors successfully revealed the dominant scattering behavior of antisite defects in ZrNiSn and provided a theoretical basis for adjusting the thermal conductivity of ZrNiSn. This research not only resolves the contradictions in existing experimental results but also provides a new method for determining defect concentrations in other materials.