Erik Dietrich,Harold J. W. Zandvliet,Detlef Lohse,James R. T. Seddon
Abstract:The exceptionally long lifetime of surface nanobubbles remains one of the biggest questions in the field. One of the proposed mechanisms for the stability is the \emph{dynamic equilibrium} model, which describes a constant flux of gas in and out of the bubble. Here, we describe results from particle tracking experiments to measure this flow. The results are analysed by measuring the Voronoï cell size distribution, the diffusion, and speed of the tracer particles. We show that there is no detectable difference in the movement of particles above nanobubble-laden surfaces, as compared to nanobubble-free surfaces.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the stability mechanism of surface nanobubbles, especially their abnormally long lifetimes. According to classical theory, due to the small curvature radius and high surface tension of nanobubbles, there should be high pressure inside the bubbles, which should quickly drive the gas into the solution, causing the bubbles to disappear. However, experimental observations show that these nanobubbles can remain stable for a long time, which is contrary to classical theory.
To explore this phenomenon, the authors proposed a dynamic equilibrium model, which assumes that there is a constant flux of gas molecules in and out of the bubbles, thus maintaining the stability of the bubbles. To verify this model, the author conducted particle - tracking experiments to measure the flow around the bubbles. Specifically, they analyzed the Voronoi cell size distribution, the diffusion coefficient, and the velocity of tracer particles to explore whether there is a recirculation flow.
### Main research questions:
1. **Is there a recirculation flow?**
- The author measured whether there is a recirculation flow of liquid around the nanobubbles through particle - tracking experiments. If there is a recirculation flow, the motion pattern of particles will be affected, for example, being pushed towards the areas between the bubbles or being trapped in certain specific areas.
2. **Does the existence of nanobubbles affect the diffusion behavior of particles?**
- The author compared the diffusion behavior of particles with and without nanobubbles to determine whether nanobubbles change the diffusion coefficient of particles.
### Experimental methods:
- **Particle tracking**: Polystyrene particles with a diameter of 1 micrometer were used as tracers, and the motion trajectories of the particles were recorded by a microscope and a CCD camera.
- **Data analysis**: Statistical quantities such as Voronoi cell size distribution, mean - squared displacement (MSD), and image correlation were calculated to analyze the motion characteristics of the particles.
### Main conclusions:
- The research results show that on the surface where nanobubbles exist, the motion of particles has no significant difference compared with the surface without nanobubbles. No obvious signs of recirculation flow were found, whether from the analysis of Voronoi cell size distribution, diffusion coefficient, or local velocity.
Therefore, the main purpose of this paper is to verify the existence of recirculation flow around nanobubbles through particle - tracking experiments and explore the stability mechanism of nanobubbles. Eventually, the author concludes that within the experimental error range, the recirculation flow around nanobubbles cannot be detected, which is different from some previous research results and requires further research to explain this difference.