On the (in)validity of the NLS-KdV system in the study of water waves

Chuangye Liu,Nghiem V. Nguyen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1604.08559

2016-04-29

Abstract:It is universally accepted that the cubic, nonlinear Schrodinger equation (NLS) models the dynamics of narrow-bandwidth wave packets consisting of short dispersive waves, while the Kortewegde Vries equation (KdV) models the propagation of long waves in dispersive media. A system that couples the two equations seems attractive to model the interaction of long and short waves and such a system has been studied over the last few decades. However, questions about the validity of the system in the study of water waves were raised in our previous work where we presented our analysis using the fifth-order KdV as the starting point. In this paper, these questions are settled unequivocally as we show that the NLS-KdV system or even the linear Schrodinger-KdV system cannot be resulted from the full Euler equations formulated in the study of water waves.

Mathematical Physics,Analysis of PDEs

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the validity of the NLS - KdV system in the study of water waves. Specifically:

- **Background**: It is generally believed that the cubic nonlinear Schrödinger equation (NLS) describes the dynamics of narrow - bandwidth wave packets composed of short dispersive waves, while the Korteweg - de Vries equation (KdV) describes the propagation of long waves in a dispersive medium. Therefore, the system coupling these two equations seems to be able to be used to model the interaction between long waves and short waves and has been widely studied in the past few decades.

- **Core of the problem**: However, in their previous work, the authors raised doubts about the validity of this system. They pointed out that starting from the complete Euler equations, it is impossible to derive the NLS - KdV system or even the linear Schrödinger - KdV system to describe water waves. This is mainly because:
- Only the system in which the linear Schrödinger equation is coupled with the KdV equation has been derived.
- Different time scales appear in the two coupled equations.
- The analysis starting from the fifth - order KdV equation shows that it is impossible to derive the NLS - KdV system from any physical system that describes the interaction between long waves and short waves in a dispersive medium.

- **Research purpose**: This paper aims to thoroughly verify these doubts by starting from the complete Euler equations and clearly point out that the NLS - KdV system or the linear Schrödinger - KdV system cannot be consistently derived from the Euler equations for studying water waves.

Through detailed mathematical analysis, the authors hope to clarify the applicability and validity of this system in the study of water waves, thereby providing a more accurate theoretical basis for research in related fields.