Abstract:That water expands when freezing is a well-known fact, and it is at the basis of an experiment that is often involuntary performed with beer bottles in freezers. But why does the water behave this way? And, more difficult, how can one illustrate this phenomenon in simple terms?
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explain the phenomenon of volume expansion when water freezes by analyzing a scene in the "Donald Duck" comic. Specifically, in the story, Scrooge McDuck (Uncle Scrooge), in order to protect his money box from being stolen by the Beagle Boys, followed Donald Duck's advice and filled the money box with water. However, on an extremely cold night, the water expanded in volume after freezing, causing the walls of the money box to break, and huge ice cubes and banknotes slid down the hill and finally reached the yard of the Beagle Boys.
The core issue of the paper is to explore why water expands when it freezes and how to explain this phenomenon to non - professionals in a simple way. The author elaborates in the following aspects:
1. **The relationship between temperature and molecular kinetic energy**: Temperature is related to the kinetic energy of molecules. Usually, molecules tend to stay in the state with the lowest energy. For most substances, the molecular arrangement is more compact at low temperatures, but water is an exception.
2. **The unique structure of water molecules**: The shape of a water molecule is similar to the head of Mickey Mouse (see Figure 1). Two hydrogen atoms are located on both sides of the oxygen atom like ears. This unique structure makes water molecules form a relatively loose structure through hydrogen bonds when forming ice crystals, resulting in the density of ice being lower than that of liquid water (see Figure 3).
3. **Energy change and phase change**: In order to change water from liquid to solid (i.e., freezing), it is necessary to first reduce the kinetic energy of water molecules (which is related to the specific heat capacity of water), and then it is also necessary to remove the energy difference generated by the transformation from van der Waals force to hydrogen bond (i.e., latent heat of fusion). The specific values involved in these processes are:
- The specific heat capacity of water \(C = 4.187 \, \text{kJ/kg K}\)
- The latent heat of fusion \(I = 334 \, \text{kJ/kg}\)
- The specific heat capacity of ice \(C_{\text{ice}}= 2.108 \, \text{kJ/kg K}\)
4. **Scrooge's money box problem**: The paper also discusses what would happen if Scrooge's money box was really filled with water and the water froze. Suppose the area of each side of the money box is about 4,000 square meters, the side length is about 60 meters, and the total volume is about 200,000 cubic meters. Through experimental determination, the packing density of coins is about 0.55, so the mass of water is about \(9\times 10^{7}\) kilograms. If the initial temperature is 10°C, to completely freeze the water into ice at 0°C, the total heat to be removed is \(3.4\times 10^{13}\) joules. If this process is completed within 5 hours, the required cooling power is as high as 113 gigawatts.
5. **Extended problem**: Finally, the paper poses a challenging question: What is the temperature at the bottom of the deep sea? By analyzing the properties of fresh water and salt water, the author points out that the temperature at the bottom of the deep sea is approximately 3°C.
Through these analyses, the paper not only explains the reason for the volume expansion of water when it freezes but also provides an interesting application example, showing the practical application of physical principles in daily life.