Seed population in large Solar Energetic Particle events and the twin-CME scenario

Liu-Guan Ding,Gang Li,Gui-Ming Le,Bin Gu,Xin-Xin Cao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/812/2/171
2016-04-20
Abstract:It has been recently suggested that large solar energetic particle (SEP) events are often caused by twin CMEs. In the twin-CME scenario, the preceding CME is to provide both an enhanced turbulence level and enhanced seed population at the main CME-driven shock. In this work, we study the effect of the preceding CMEs on the seed population. We examine event-integrated abundance of iron to oxygen ratio (Fe/O) at energies above 25 MeV/nuc for large SEP events in solar cycle 23. We find that the Fe/O ratio (normalized to the reference coronal value of $0.134$) $\leq2.0$ for almost all single-CME events and these events tend to have smaller peak intensities. In comparison, the Fe/O ratio of twin-CME events scatters in a larger range, reaching as high as $8$, suggesting the presence of flare material from perhaps preceding flares. For extremely large SEP events with peak intensity above $1000$ pfu, the Fe/O drop below $2$, indicating that in these extreme events the seed particles are dominated by coronal material than flare material. The Fe/O ratios of Ground level enhancement (GLE) events, all being twin-CME events, scatter in a broad range. For a given Fe/O ratio, GLE events tend to have larger peak intensities than non-GLE events. Using velocity dispersion analysis (VDA), we find that GLE events have lower solar particle release (SPR) heights than non-GLE events, \red{agreeing with earlier results by Reames 2009b.
Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the source of seed particles and their impact on the intensity of large Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) events. Specifically, the paper explores how the leading Coronal Mass Ejection (CME) in a twin-CME scenario affects the quantity and composition of seed particles, thereby influencing the particle acceleration process in the primary CME-driven shock. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Source of Seed Particles**: The paper investigates the source of seed particles in large SEP events, particularly whether these seed particles originate from the leading CME or solar flares. 2. **Impact of Seed Particles on Event Intensity**: The paper analyzes how the quantity and composition of seed particles affect the peak intensity of large SEP events. 3. **Effectiveness of the Twin-CME Scenario**: The paper validates whether the twin-CME scenario can explain the characteristics of large SEP events, especially those with extremely high peak intensities. ### Research Methods: - **Data Selection**: The paper uses data from large SEP events between 1997 and 2006, focusing on events during solar cycle 23. - **Fe/O Ratio Analysis**: By analyzing the Fe/O ratio of event integrals (normalized to 0.134), the study examines the composition of seed particles. - **Statistical Analysis**: The paper compares the Fe/O ratios and peak intensities of single-CME events and twin-CME events to explore the impact of seed particles on event intensity. ### Main Findings: 1. **Fe/O Ratio and Event Source**: Events with high Fe/O ratios (>2.0) almost always originate from the western side of the Sun, and most are twin-CME events. This suggests that the leading CME may provide more seed particles. 2. **Composition of Seed Particles**: The Fe/O ratio scatter range is larger for twin-CME events, with many events having Fe/O ratios exceeding 2.0, indicating the presence of seed particles from the leading flare. 3. **Event Intensity**: The peak intensity distribution of twin-CME events is broader, with many events having peak intensities exceeding 1000 pfu. In contrast, the peak intensity of single-CME events is usually below 100 pfu. 4. **Extreme Events**: For extreme events with peak intensities exceeding 1000 pfu, the Fe/O ratio is usually less than 2.0, indicating that seed particles mainly come from the leading CME rather than the leading flare. ### Conclusion: By analyzing the Fe/O ratio and event intensity, the paper validates the effectiveness of the twin-CME scenario. The leading CME not only increases the quantity of seed particles but also enhances the turbulence level near the shock, thereby promoting the particle acceleration process in the primary CME-driven shock. This finding helps to better understand the physical mechanisms of large SEP events.