E. Khestanova,F. Guinea,L. Fumagalli,A. K. Geim,I. V. Grigorieva
Abstract:Trapped substances between a 2D crystal, such as graphene, and an atomically flat substrate, for example, hexagonal boron nitride, give rise to the formation of bubbles. We show that the size, shape and internal pressure inside these bubbles are determined by the competition between van der Waals attraction of a 2D crystal to the substrate and the elastic energy needed to deform the atomically thin layer. This presents opportunities to use bubbles to study the elasticity of 2D materials as well as the conditions of confinement, yet none of these have been explored so far, either theoretically or experimentally. We have created a variety of bubbles formed by monolayers of graphene, hBN and MoS2 mechanically exfoliated onto hBN, graphite and MoS2 substrates. Their shapes, analyzed using atomic force microscopy, are found to exhibit universal scaling with well-defined aspect ratios, in agreement with theoretical analysis based on general properties of membranes. We also measured the pressure induced by the confinement, which increased with decreasing bubble's size and reached tens on MPa inside submicron bubbles. This agrees with our theory estimates and suggests that for bubbles with radii < 10 nm hydrostatic pressures can reach close to 1 GPa, which may modify the properties of a trapped material.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the size, shape, and internal pressure of bubbles formed between two - dimensional crystals (such as graphene, hexagonal boron nitride (hBN), and molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂)) and atomically flat substrates (for example, hexagonal boron nitride, graphite, or molybdenum disulfide substrates). Specifically, the research aims to explore whether the formation of these bubbles is determined by the competition between the van der Waals force (vdW) - induced interaction between the two - dimensional crystal and the substrate and the elastic energy required to deform the atomic - thin layer.
### Research Background
When two - dimensional materials (such as graphene) come into contact with atomically flat substrates, minute contaminants (such as water or hydrocarbons) between them will be squeezed into tiny bubbles. The existence of these bubbles provides an opportunity to study the elastic properties of two - dimensional materials and the behavior of substances under nanoscale confinement conditions. However, so far, the research on these bubbles has mainly focused on verifying the good adhesion between layers in two - dimensional heterostructures and the interface cleanliness, without in - depth exploration of their physical properties.
### Main Problems
1. **Shape and Size of Bubbles**: Researchers want to know whether the shape and size of these bubbles are consistent and whether this consistency can be explained by theoretical models.
2. **Internal Pressure**: How does the internal pressure of the bubble change with the change of the bubble size? Especially in sub - micrometer - sized bubbles, the internal pressure can reach tens of MPa or even higher, which may change the properties of the trapped substances.
3. **Elastic Properties**: Can the elastic properties of two - dimensional materials be inferred by analyzing the shape and size of the bubbles?
4. **Application Prospects**: Can these bubbles be used as tools to study the mechanical properties of two - dimensional materials and the behavior of substances under nanoscale confinement conditions?
### Solutions
The author solves the above problems by combining experimental and theoretical analysis methods:
- **Experimental Part**: Single - layer graphene, hBN, and MoS₂ are transferred to different substrates by mechanical exfoliation to form a large number of bubbles, and the shape and size of these bubbles are measured using atomic force microscopy (AFM).
- **Theoretical Analysis**: Based on membrane theory and elasticity mechanics, a theoretical model is established to describe the shape and internal pressure of the bubbles. This model takes into account the competition between van der Waals attraction and elastic energy and predicts the general shape and proportional relationship of the bubbles.
### Conclusions
The study found that all types of bubbles (circular and triangular) exhibit a consistent proportional relationship, which depends only on the elastic properties of the two - dimensional materials and the van der Waals attraction between them and the substrate. In addition, the experimentally measured internal pressure of the bubbles is consistent with the theoretical prediction, indicating that in sub - micrometer - sized bubbles, the internal pressure can be very high, even approaching 1 GPa. This finding not only helps to understand the elastic properties of two - dimensional materials but also provides a new approach for studying the behavior of substances under nanoscale confinement conditions.
### Formula Summary
1. **Van der Waals Energy**:
\[
E_{\text{vdW}}=\pi\gamma R^{2}
\]
where \(\gamma = \gamma_{GS}-\gamma_{Gb}-\gamma_{Sb}\), and \(\gamma_{GS}\), \(\gamma_{Gb}\), and \(\gamma_{Sb}\) are the adhesion energies between graphene and the substrate, graphene and the substances inside the bubble, and the substrate and the substances inside the bubble, respectively.
2. **Proportional Relationship between Bubble Height and Radius (without External Strain)**:
\[
\frac{h_{\text{max}}}{R}=\left(\frac{\pi\gamma}{5c_{1}Y}\right)^{1/4}
\]
3. **Internal Pressure of the Bubble**:
\[
P = \frac{4\pi\gamma}{5c_{V}h_{\text{max}}}
\]
These formulas reveal the quantitative relationships between the shape, size, and internal pressure of the bubbles, providing a theoretical basis for further research on the mechanical properties of two - dimensional materials.