Abstract:A distorted black hole radiates gravitational waves in order to settle down in a smoother geometry. During that relaxation phase, a characteristic damped ringing is generated. It can be theoretically constructed from both the black hole quasinormal frequencies (which govern its oscillating behavior and its decay) and the associated excitation factors (which determine intrinsically its amplitude) by carefully taking into account the source of the distortion. In the framework of massive gravity, the excitation factors of the Schwarzschild black hole have an unexpected strong resonant behavior which, theoretically, could lead to giant and slowly decaying ringings. If massive gravity is relevant to physics, one can hope to observe these extraordinary ringings by using the next generations of gravitational wave detectors. Indeed, they could be generated by supermassive black holes if the graviton mass is not too small. In fact, by focusing on the odd-parity $\ell=1$ mode of the Fierz-Pauli field, we shall show here that such ringings are neutralized in waveforms due to (i) the excitation of the quasibound states of the black hole and (ii) the evanescent nature of the particular partial modes which could excite the concerned quasinormal modes. Despite this, with observational consequences in mind, it is interesting to note that the waveform amplitude is nevertheless rather pronounced and slowly decaying (this effect is now due to the long-lived quasibound states). It is worth noting also that, for very low values of the graviton mass (corresponding to the weak instability regime for the black hole), the waveform is now very clean and dominated by an ordinary ringing which could be used as a signature of massive gravity.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is, in the theory of massive gravity, the characteristics of gravitational wave waveforms generated by black holes after perturbation, especially whether the huge, slowly - decaying ringing phenomenon can be detected in actual observations. Specifically, the paper focuses on the process in which a Schwarzschild black hole releases energy through gravitational waves to reach a smoother geometric state after perturbation. Due to the excitation factors of quasi - normal modes (QNMs) in the theory of massive gravity showing strong resonant behavior, it may theoretically lead to a huge and slowly - decaying ringing phenomenon. However, the paper further explores whether these huge ringing phenomena will be suppressed or cancelled by other effects in the actual waveform, such as the excitation of quasi - bound states (QBSs) and the attenuation properties of specific partial modes.
The main findings of the paper include:
1. **Resonant behavior of quasi - normal modes (QNMs)**: In the theory of massive gravity, the excitation factors of the quasi - normal modes of the Schwarzschild black hole show strong resonant behavior near certain critical values, which may lead to huge, slowly - decaying ringing phenomena.
2. **Excitation of quasi - bound states (QBSs)**: The resonant behavior of the quasi - normal modes is not obvious in the waveform because the excitation of the quasi - bound states will blur the contribution of the quasi - normal modes, and in some cases, the excitation of the quasi - bound states becomes the main contributor to the waveform.
3. **Attenuation properties of specific partial modes**: When the mass parameter is close to the critical value, the real - part frequency of the quasi - normal mode is less than the mass parameter and is located within the cut of the retarded Green's function, resulting in this part of the mode having attenuation properties, thereby significantly reducing the ringing amplitude.
Overall, through numerical simulation and theoretical analysis, the paper shows that in the theory of massive gravity, although the excitation factors of the quasi - normal modes show strong resonant behavior, due to the excitation of the quasi - bound states and the attenuation properties of specific partial modes, the huge, slowly - decaying ringing phenomenon is significantly suppressed in the actual waveform. This result is of great significance for future gravitational wave detectors in detecting signals of the theory of massive gravity.