Marcus J. Hamilton,Jose Lobo,Eric Rupley,Hyejin Youn,Geoffrey B. West
Abstract:Residential mobility is deeply entangled with all aspects of hunter-gatherer life ways, and is therefore an issue of central importance in hunter-gatherer studies. Hunter-gatherers vary widely in annual rates of residential mobility, and understanding the sources of this variation has long been of interest to anthropologists and archaeologists. Since mobility is, to a large extent, driven by the need for a continuous supply of food, a natural framework for addressing this question is provided by the metabolic theory of ecology. This provides a powerful framework for formulating formal testable hypotheses concerning evolutionary and ecological constraints on the scale and variation of hunter-gatherer residential mobility. We evaluate these predictions using extant data and show strong support for the hypotheses. We show that the overall scale of hunter-gatherer residential mobility is predicted by average human body size, and the limited capacity of mobile hunter-gatherers to store energy internally. We then show that the majority of variation in residential mobility observed across cultures is predicted by energy availability in local ecosystems. Our results demonstrate that large-scale evolutionary and ecological processes, common to all plants and animals, constrain hunter-gatherers in predictable ways as they move through territories to effectively exploit resources over the course of a year. Moreover, our results extend the scope of the metabolic theory of ecology by showing how it successfully predicts variation in the behavioral ecology of populations within a species.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to predict the changes in residential mobility of hunter - gatherers? Specifically, the authors explored the residential movement patterns of hunter - gatherers, that is, the movements between camps during a year in order to effectively utilize the environment to meet their nutritional, material and social needs. They focused on whether the scale and changes of this mobility can be predicted by ecological and evolutionary energy theories.
### Background of the paper
In the lifestyle of hunter - gatherers, residential mobility is a key aspect because it is closely related to the foraging economy. The annual residential movement rates of different hunter - gatherer groups vary greatly, and understanding the sources of these differences has always been an issue of interest to anthropologists and archaeologists. Hunter - gatherers usually move their camps multiple times a year because local foraging areas gradually become depleted, and food, materials and social resources are unevenly distributed in time and space. Even in resource - rich and predictable coastal areas, hunter - gatherers may become relatively sedentary, but even in this case, how to maintain a viable foraging economy while reducing residential movement remains a core issue.
### Research methods
The authors used three data sets:
1. **Mammalian migration data**: Data from Hein et al., which contains the average body size and annual migration distance of 33 mammalian species.
2. **Annual travel distance data of hunter - gatherers**: Data from Kelly, which contains the total annual travel distance of 47 hunter - gatherer groups.
3. **Spatial ecological data of hunter - gatherers**: Data from Binford, which contains seven variables of 314 hunter - gatherer groups, such as territorial area, population size, annual travel distance, annual number of movements, annual average temperature, annual precipitation and net primary productivity (NPP).
### Theoretical framework
The authors proposed hypotheses based on the Metabolic Theory of Ecology (MTE). The Metabolic Theory of Ecology believes that energy supply and utilization are the basis of all biological and ecological processes, and the metabolic rate has a power - law relationship with the mass of organisms:
\[ B = B_0 M^\alpha \]
where \( B \) is the basal metabolic rate, \( M \) is the mass of the organism, \( B_0 \) is a constant for a specific taxon, and \( \alpha\approx\frac{3}{4} \).
In addition, the metabolic rate (R) of an ecosystem can be expressed as the sum of the metabolic rates of all individuals:
\[ R=\sum_i B_i \]
Taking into account the effects of environmental temperature and precipitation, the metabolic rate of an ecosystem can be further expressed as:
\[ R\propto P^\theta e^{-\frac{E}{kT}} \]
where \( P \) is the annual precipitation, \( T \) is the environmental temperature, \( E \) is the average activation energy of biochemical reactions, \( k \) is the Boltzmann constant, and \( \theta \) is the response index of precipitation to the change in resource supply rate.
### Hypotheses and predictions
1. **The influence of human body size on the annual residential movement distance**: The authors hypothesized that the annual residential movement distance of hunter - gatherers is related to their body size, similar to other mammals. Specifically, the relationship between the annual movement distance \( D \) and body mass \( M \) is:
\[ D = d_0 M^{\frac{1}{3}} \]
2. **The influence of ecosystem energy availability on the residential movement rate**: The authors hypothesized that the residential movement rate of hunter - gatherers is affected by the energy availability of the ecosystem, especially temperature and precipitation. Specifically, the annual average movement distance \( D \) can be expressed as:
\[ D\propto P^\theta e^{-\frac{E}{kT}} N^{-\frac{1}{16}} \]
### Results
By analyzing the above data sets, the authors found that:
- The annual average movement distance of hunter - gatherers is very close to the expected migration distance of 60 - kilogram mammals, which indicates that the scale of human residential movement is restricted by evolutionary biomechanics and bioenergetics.
- The average distance per movement is significantly correlated with temperature and precipitation, which is consistent with the changes in ecosystem energy flow.
- The residential movement rate of hunter - gatherers increases as...