Abstract:Aim: During the COVID-19 pandemic, the absence of in-person teaching was partially compensated for through videoconferencing. However, lecturers complain that students do not participate actively in video-based online seminars. One reason cited for this is Zoom fatigue. Conferences in virtual reality (VR), accessible with and without head-mounted display, represent one potential remedy to this issue. The research to date does not shed any light on the (1.) teaching experience, (2.) student demand, (3.) learning experience (including participation and social presence), and (4.) learning performance (declarative and spatial) associated with VR conferences. The present work will compare these aspects for videoconferencing, independent study, and - in the case of teaching experience - with in-person teaching. Methods: A compulsory seminar in General Physiology was offered during the 2020/21 winter semester and the 2021 summer semester as part of the Human Medicine program at the Faculty of Medicine at Ulm University. The seminars were offered in three different formats with identical content: (a) VR conference, (b) video conference, and (c) independent study, with students selecting the format of their choice. In the VR conferences, the lecturer taught using a head-mounted display while students participated via PC, laptop, or tablet. The learning experience and learning performance were assessed using questionnaires and a knowledge test. A semi-structured interview was conducted to assess the VR teaching experience. Results: The lecturer's teaching experience in the VR conferences was similar to in-person teaching. Students predominantly chose independent study and videoconferencing. The latter resulted in worse outcomes with regard to learning experience (including participation and social presence) and spatial learning performance than the VR conferences. Declarative learning performance differed only slightly between teaching formats. Conclusions: VR conferencing offers lecturers new didactic opportunities and a teaching experience similar to that of in-person teaching. Students prefer time-efficient videoconferencing and independent study, but rate participation and social presence, among other things, higher in VR conferencing. If faculty and students are open to the technology, VR conferencing can promote interactive exchange in online seminars. This subjective assessment is not associated with better declarative learning performance.

Optimizing the Educational Potential of Virtual Reality: The Effects of Virtual Reality and Pop Quizzes on Spatial Presence and Efficacy Perceptions

The Auxiliary Role of Virtual Reality in Enhancing the Effects of Disaster News on Empathy and Fear: The Mediating Role of Presence

EXPERIMENTAL STUDY TO COMPARE FACTORS INFLUENCING EXIT CHOICE BEHAVIOUR IN EMERGENCY EVACUATION SITUATIONS USING VIRTUAL REALITY TECHNIQUES

An Immersive Multi-User Virtual Reality for Emergency Simulation Training: Usability Study

Virtual reality against Zoom fatigue? A field study on the teaching and learning experience in interactive video and VR conferencing

An Immersive Multi-User Virtual Reality for Emergency Simulation Training: Usability Study (Preprint)

Positioning virtual reality as means of clinical experience in mental health nursing education: A quasi-experimental study

Using VR for Science Communication: Presence, Message Perception, and Pro-Environmental Effects

An Examination of the Effects of Virtual Reality Training on Spatial Visualization and Transfer of Learning

Assessing User Experiences in Virtual Reality Learning Environments

Exploring the Perception of the Effect of Three-Dimensional Interaction Feedback Types on Immersive Virtual Reality Education

Human interaction with virtual reality: investigating pre-evacuation efficiency in building emergency

Impact of Immersive Virtual Reality Content Using 360-degree Videos in Undergraduate Education

Direct comparison of virtual reality and 2D delivery on sense of presence, emotional and physiological outcome measures

Use of immersive virtual reality-based experiments to study tactical decision-making during emergency evacuation

Teachers Perceptions on Early Childhood’s Traffic and Life Safety Education Program Using VR

Virtual Environment, Real Impacts: A Self-determination Perspective on the use of Virtual Reality for Pro-environmental Behavior Interventions

The Effects of Virtual Reality Learning Environment on Student Cognitive and Linguistic Development

Examining the Perceptions Among Undergraduate Nursing Students Using Virtual Reality in a Community Course: A Mixed-Methods Explanatory Study

Effects of VR Instructional Approaches and Textual Cues on Performance, Cognitive Load, and Learning Experience

Effects of Immersive Virtual Reality Technology on Online Learning Outcomes