A Search for Solar Energetic Particle Events with CME-less Flares

N. Vilmer,K. Klein,G. Trottet
Abstract:Solar energetic particle (SEP) events are associated both with flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs). There have been many attempts to identify the origin of SEP through statistical correlations. But correlations of peak SEP intensities with CME speed or soft X-ray flare intensity are in general quite noisy. This motivates the research for SEPs that accompany ‘pure’ events, either CMEs or flares. We searched for SEP signatures of CME-less flares. Wang and Zhang (2007, ApJ 665, 1428) showed that about 10% of GOES X-class flares between 1996 and 2004 had no accompanying CME. Four occurred in the western solar hemisphere. We find that although they were accompanied by signatures of electron acceleration to relativistic energies in the corona (microwaves, hard X-rays), none displayed radio signatures of particle escape to interplanetary space (metric-to-kilometric type III bursts), and none produced an SEP event seen by GOES. This suggests that the accelerated particles remained confined in closed coronal magnetic structures.
Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?