Abstract:Purpose: We investigated and compared the outcomes from two standardized, norm-referenced screening assessments of language (i.e., Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals Preschool–Second Edition [CELFP-2], Diagnostic Evaluation of Language Variation–Screening Test [DELV-ST]) with African American preschoolers whose spoken dialect differed from that of General American English (GAE). We (a) described preschoolers' performance on the CELFP-2 Core Language Index (CLI) and its subtests with consideration of degree of dialect variation (DVAR) observed, (b) investigated how the application of dialect-sensitive scoring modifications to the expressive morphology and syntax Word Structure (WS) subtest affected CELFP-2 CLI scores, and (c) evaluated the screening classification agreement rates between the DELV-ST and the CELFP-2 CLI. Method: African American preschoolers ( N = 284) completed the CELFP-2 CLI subtests (i.e., Sentence Structure, WS, Expressive Vocabulary) and the DELV-ST. Density of spoken dialect use was estimated with the DELV-ST Part I Language Variation Status, and percentage of DVAR was calculated. The CELFP-2 WS subtest was scored with and without dialect-sensitive scoring modifications. Results: Planned comparisons of CELFP-2 CLI performance indicated statistically significant differences in performance based on DELV-ST–determined degree of language variation groupings. Scoring modifications applied to the WS subtest increased subtest scaled scores and CLI composite standard scores. However, preschoolers who demonstrated strong variation from GAE continued to demonstrate significantly lower performance than preschoolers who demonstrated little to no language variation. Affected-status agreement rates between assessments (modified and unmodified CELFP-2 CLI scores and DELV-ST Part II Diagnostic Risk Status) were extremely low. Conclusions: The application of dialect-specific scoring modifications to standardized, norm-referenced assessments of language must be simultaneously viewed through the lenses of equity, practicality, and psychometry. The results of our multistage study reiterate the need for reliable methods of identifying risk for developmental language disorder within children who speak American English dialects other than GAE. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.26017978

Oral language expectations for African American children in grades 1 through 5

African American Preschoolers' Performance on Norm-Referenced Language Assessments: Examining the Effect of Dialect Density and the Use of Scoring Modifications

What Predicts Oral Narrative Competence Among African American Children? Exploring the Role of Linguistic and Cognitive Skills

Using Kindergarten Language, Dialect Variation, and Child Behavior to Predict Second Grade Reading Ability in African American Children

African American and Caucasian preschoolers' use of decontextualized language: literate language features in oral narratives

African American English and Early Literacy: A Comparison of Approaches to Quantifying Nonmainstream Dialect Use

Sharing Stories Versus Explaining Facts: Comparing African American Children's Microstructure Performance Across Fictional Narrative, Informational, and Procedural Discourse

The Growth of Complex Syntax in School-Age African American Children Who Speak African American English

Evaluating Different Scoring Systems for a Picture Description Task Among Preschool Children Who Speak African American English.

Linguistic illusions and misconceptions: The role of language variation in language development across three varieties of American English

Profiles of Problem Behavior in Children With Varying Language Ability

Measurement Issues: Assessing language skills in young children

MIDDLE-CLASS AFRICAN AMERICANS: REACTIONS AND ATTITUDES TOWARD AFRICAN AMERICAN ENGLISH

Using language sample analyses across English dialects: A case-based approach for preschoolers

Examining Adolescent Language Performance in Discourse Production Across Four Elicitation Tasks

Becoming fictional storytellers: African American children's oral narrative development in early elementary school

Volume and Verve: Understanding Correction/Behavioral Warnings in Teacher-Child Classroom Interactions Involving an African American Kindergarten Student

Filling in the Blank: The Development of a Writing Screener for Elementary School Students Who Speak African American English

Interpretation and Use of Standardized Language Assessments for Diverse School-Age Individuals

Linguistic Feature Development Across Grades and Genre in Elementary Writing

Dialect and mathematics performance in African American children who use AAE: Insights from explanatory IRT and error analysis