Supporting use, learning, and education

S. Draper

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/311147.311152

1999-05-01

Abstract:Guzdial's paper reports some successful trials in supporting users in educational contexts who had to master new software simultaneously with pursuing their educational learning goals for which the software was only a means to that end. He calls this "supporting learners as users," and his main techniques involve providing large collections of examples and other help materials which to a large extent are provided by other learners in that community. The fundamental starting point for Guzdial is that users and learners typically have a big goal stack: they have high level, long range aims to do with their work domain, each subdivided many times and ultimately resting on a large number of small actions (such as moving the mouse, picking a menu command, etc.). If the small actions are automatic, fully learned ones, then the theoretical existence of the goal stack is of little consequence. However if those small actions are themselves problems requiring conscious attention and a search for information, as they may well be for users new to the software, then the whole activity becomes liable to breakdown and failure. Guzdial points out that learners, particularly learners in the education system, will have particularly large goal hierarchies because their top level goals are to do with passing a course and learning concepts, and even the highest goals to do with the software are already a significant distance down the stack; and furthermore in many cases the software as well as the educational goals will be new to the learner, adding to the simultaneous learning burden. Learning, doing, and software