Abstract:Multivariate pattern analysis is a powerful technique; however, a significant theoretical limitation in neuroscience is the ambiguity in interpreting the source of decodable information used by classifiers. This is exemplified by the continued controversy over the source of orientation decoding from fMRI responses in human V1. Recently Carlson (2014) identified a potential source of decodable information by modeling voxel responses based on the Hubel and Wiesel (1972) ice-cube model of visual cortex. The model revealed that activity associated with the edges of gratings covaries with orientation and could potentially be used to discriminate orientation. Here we empirically evaluate whether "edge-related activity" underlies orientation decoding from patterns of BOLD response in human V1. First, we systematically mapped classifier performance as a function of stimulus location using population receptive field modeling to isolate each voxel's overlap with a large annular grating stimulus. Orientation was decodable across the stimulus; however, peak decoding performance occurred for voxels with receptive fields closer to the fovea and overlapping with the inner edge. Critically, we did not observe the expected second peak in decoding performance at the outer stimulus edge as predicted by the edge account. Second, we evaluated whether voxels that contribute most to classifier performance have receptive fields that cluster in cortical regions corresponding to the retinotopic location of the stimulus edge. Instead, we find the distribution of highly weighted voxels to be approximately random, with a modest bias toward more foveal voxels. Our results demonstrate that edge-related activity is likely not necessary for orientation decoding. Significance statement: A significant theoretical limitation of multivariate pattern analysis in neuroscience is the ambiguity in interpreting the source of decodable information used by classifiers. For example, orientation can be decoded from BOLD activation patterns in human V1, even though orientation columns are at a finer spatial scale than 3T fMRI. Consequently, the source of decodable information remains controversial. Here we test the proposal that information related to the stimulus edges underlies orientation decoding. We map voxel population receptive fields in V1 and evaluate orientation decoding performance as a function of stimulus location in retinotopic cortex. We find orientation is decodable from voxels whose receptive fields do not overlap with the stimulus edges, suggesting edge-related activity does not substantially drive orientation decoding.

Predicting the orientation of invisible stimuli from activity in human primary visual cortex

Edge-Related Activity Is Not Necessary to Explain Orientation Decoding in Human Visual Cortex

Natural scene sampling reveals reliable coarse-scale orientation tuning in human V1

Relationship between BOLD amplitude and pattern classification of orientation-selective activity in the human visual cortex

High-field fMRI unveils orientation columns in humans

Demonstration of tuning to stimulus orientation in the human visual cortex: a high-resolution fMRI study with a novel continuous and periodic stimulation paradigm

Local opposite orientation preferences in V1: fMRI sensitivity to fine-grained pattern information

Orientation decoding in human visual cortex: new insights from an unbiased perspective

Inferring Population Responses in Human Visual Cortex with Classification Analysis

Spatial scale and distribution of neurovascular signals underlying decoding of orientation and eye of origin from fMRI data

Feasibility of functional magnetic resonance imaging of ocular dominance and orientation preference in primary visual cortex

Automatic Detection of Orientation Contrast Occurs at Early but Not Earliest Stages of Visual Cortical Processing in Humans

Orientation-selective adaptation to first- and second-order patterns in human visual cortex

Attention Alters the Orientation Tuning for Multiple-Stimulus Displays in Human Extrastriate Visual Areas

Attention Influence Response in the Human Visual Area V1 for Ebbinghaus Illusion

Discretized representations in V1 predict suboptimal orientation discrimination

Latent encoding of movement in primary visual cortex

Comparison of orientation encoding across layers within single columns of primate V1 revealed by high-density recordings

Functional ultrasound imaging reveals 3D structure of orientation domains in ferret primary visual cortex

Feedforward mechanisms of cross-orientation interactions in mouse V1

Voluntary orienting is dissociated from target detection in human posterior parietal cortex