J. W. F. Venderbos
Abstract:We study hexagonal spin-channel ("triplet") density waves with commensurate $M$-point propagation vectors. We first show that the three $Q=M$ components of the singlet charge density and charge-current density waves can be mapped to multi-component $Q=0$ nonzero angular momentum order in three dimensions ($3D$) with cubic crystal symmetry. This one-to-one correspondence is exploited to define a symmetry classification for triplet $M$-point density waves using the standard classification of spin-orbit coupled electronic liquid crystal phases of a cubic crystal. Through this classification we naturally identify a set of non-coplanar spin density and spin-current density waves: the chiral spin density wave and its time-reversal invariant analog. These can be thought of as $3D$ $L=2$ and $L=4$ spin-orbit coupled isotropic $\beta$-phase orders. In contrast, uniaxial spin density waves are shown to correspond to $\alpha$-phases. The non-coplanar triple-$M$ spin-current density wave realizes a novel $2D$ semimetal state with three flavors of four-component spin-momentum locked Dirac cones, protected by a crystal symmetry akin to non-symmorphic symmetry, and sits at the boundary between a trivial and topological insulator. In addition, we point out that a special class of classical spin states, defined as classical spin states respecting all lattice symmetries up to global spin rotation, are naturally obtained from the symmetry classification of electronic triplet density waves. These symmetric classical spin states are the classical long-range ordered limits of chiral spin liquids.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects:
1. **Multicomponent spin - density waves and dynamically - generated spin - orbit coupling**:
- The paper studied the spin - channel (i.e., "triplet") density waves with hexagonal symmetry, and the propagation vectors of these density waves match the M - point in the Brillouin zone. The author first showed that the three Q = M components of the singlet charge - density wave and the charge - current - density wave can be mapped to the multicomponent Q = 0 state of the non - zero angular - momentum order parameter with cubic - crystal symmetry in three - dimensional (3D). Through this one - to - one correspondence, the author defined a symmetry - classification method for triplet M - point density waves based on the standard cubic - crystal electron - liquid - crystal - phase classification.
2. **Time - reversal - invariant chiral spin - density waves**:
- Through the above - mentioned classification method, the author naturally identified a set of non - coplanar spin - density waves and spin - current - density waves, namely, chiral spin - density waves and their time - reversal - invariant analogues. These waves can be regarded as the isotropic β - phase order parameters of 3D L = 2 and 4 spin - orbit couplings. In contrast, the uniaxial spin - density wave corresponds to the α - phase. In particular, the author pointed out a special class of classical spin states, which maintain all lattice symmetries under global spin rotation and can be naturally obtained from the symmetry classification of electron - triplet - density waves. These symmetric classical spin states are the long - range - ordered limit of chiral spin liquids.
### Overview of main results
1. **Mapping and classification**:
- The author showed that multicomponent density waves with non - zero (commensurate) wave vectors in two - dimensional can be mapped and classified as particle - hole - pair condensations with non - zero angular momentum in three - dimensional. For the triplet case, this establishes the connection between the phenomenology of multicomponent spin - density - wave states and the α and β liquid - crystal phases of spin - orbit coupling.
2. **Chiral spin - density waves and time - reversal - invariant triplet d - waves**:
- The author identified two different spin - orbit - coupling cubic - crystal β - phases, which correspond to the so - called scalar M - point - density - wave order parameters. The first one is derived from the charge - density wave or s - wave, corresponding to a spin - density - wave state that completely breaks the spin - rotation symmetry, namely, the chiral spin - density wave, and its mean - field ground state is a Chern insulator. The second one is a time - reversal - invariant triplet d - wave or spin - current state, which only breaks the spin - rotation symmetry. The author showed that the mean - field ground state of this state is a 2D Dirac semimetal protected by symmetry closely related to the non - symmetric lattice symmetry, located at the boundary between the trivial and topological insulators.
3. **Derivation of symmetric spin states**:
- Through symmetry classification, the author provided a direct and constructive method to derive the symmetric spin states of a given (hexagonal) lattice. These symmetric spin states are of great significance in magnetic materials and materials in which itinerant carriers are coupled with (large) local spins.
### Conclusion
By introducing the extended point - group symmetry and the dynamically - generated spin - orbit coupling, the paper systematically studied the symmetry classification of triplet M - point density waves with hexagonal symmetry. This classification not only reveals the properties of chiral spin - density waves and time - reversal - invariant triplet d - waves but also provides a new perspective for understanding the low - energy electron degrees of freedom of these states. In addition, the author also explored the connection between these density - wave states and classical spin - liquid states.