Are there Helium-like Protonic States of Individual Water Molecules in Liquid H2O?

Ulrich Mueller-Herold

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1512.05342

2015-12-16

Abstract:Are there indications that individual H2O molecules in liquid water can loose their bent structure, i.e. that the protons give up their rigid angular correlation and behave largely uncorrelated, similar to electrons in the ground-state of helium? In agreement with the two-state picture of liquid water this would allow for the thermal coexistence of tetraedrically coordinated and spherical water molecules in the liquid. In the Hooke-Calogero model of a confined triatomic of XY2-type it is shown that energetically low-lying zero orbital-momentum states, which are bent if unconfined can change to helium-like shape under increasing confinement strength f. For the respective states this occurs at different values for f. It turns out that at f = 2.79 a bent and a helium-like state can thermally coexist. In order to characterize more precisely 'helium-like' angular correlation a maximum entropy estimate for the marginal correlation of electrons in the helium ground state is given. KEY WORDS: Liquid water, molecular structure, noble gases, confinement, two-state theories, non-Born-Oppenheimer wave functions

Chemical Physics,Other Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Can a single water molecule in liquid water lose its bent structure, that is, can the proton give up its rigid angular correlation and exhibit an almost uncorrelated behavior similar to the ground - state electron of a helium atom? Specifically, the paper explores whether there are proton - like helium - atom states in liquid water and studies how these states coexist with traditional tetrahedrally - coordinated water molecules.

### Problem Background

1. **Structure of Water Molecules**
- A water molecule (H₂O) usually has a bent structure, and the two hydrogen atoms form a bond angle of about 104.5° with the oxygen atom.

2. **Two - State Theory**
- According to the two - state theory of liquid water, there may be two types of water molecules in liquid water: one is the tetrahedrally - coordinated water molecule, and the other is the spherical or disordered water molecule. This spherical structure may be similar to the structure of some noble gases (such as helium).

3. **Change in Proton Behavior**
- The paper explores whether, under specific conditions, the protons in a water molecule can lose their rigid angular correlation and exhibit behavior similar to the ground - state electron of a helium atom. This would mean that the angular correlation between protons becomes loose, similar to the independent movement of the two electrons in a helium atom.

### Research Methods

To study this problem, the authors used the Hooke - Calogero model to simulate a confined tri - atomic system (XY₂ type), where X represents an oxygen atom and Y represents a hydrogen atom. By changing the confinement strength \( f \), the researchers observed that at different confinement strengths, the lowest - energy state of the system changes from a bent structure to a helium - atom - like structure.

### Key Findings

- At a specific confinement strength \( f = 2.79 \), the bent structure and the helium - atom - like structure can coexist thermodynamically.
- Through maximum - entropy estimation, the researchers further characterized the "helium - like angular correlation" to more precisely describe the behavior of protons in this state.

### Conclusion

This study shows that in liquid water, a single water molecule can indeed lose its bent structure under certain conditions, and the protons exhibit behavior similar to the ground - state electron of a helium atom. This finding provides a new perspective for understanding the microscopic structure of liquid water and its two - state theory.