Fluctuating neutron star magnetosphere: braking indices of eight pulsars, frequency second derivatives of 222 pulsars and 15 magnetars

Z. W. Ou,H. Tong,F. F. Kou,G. Q. Ding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw227

2016-01-26

Abstract:Eight pulsars have low braking indices, which challenge the magnetic dipole braking of pulsars. 222 pulsars and 15 magnetars have abnormal distribution of frequency second derivatives, which also make contradiction with classical understanding. How neutron star magnetospheric activities affect these two phenomena are investigated by using the wind braking model of pulsars. It is based on the observational evidence that pulsar timing is correlated with emission and both aspects reflect the magnetospheric activities. Fluctuations are unavoidable for a physical neutron star magnetosphere. Young pulsars have meaningful braking indices, while old pulsars' and magnetars' fluctuation item dominates their frequency second derivatives. It can explain both the braking index and frequency second derivative of pulsars uniformly. The braking indices of eight pulsars are the combined effect of magnetic dipole radiation and particle wind. During the life time of a pulsar, its braking index will evolve from three to one. Pulsars with low braking index may put strong constraint on the particle acceleration process in the neutron star magnetosphere. The effect of pulsar death should be considered during the long term rotational evolution of pulsars. An equation like the Langevin equation for Brownian motion was derived for pulsar spin-down. The fluctuation in the neutron star magnetosphere can be either periodic or random, which result in anomalous frequency second derivative and they have similar results. The magnetospheric activities of magnetars are always stronger than those of normal pulsars.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects:

1. **Pulsars with low braking indices**: The paper mentions that there are eight pulsars whose braking indices are lower than the value of 3 predicted by the classical theory. These observational results pose a challenge to the pulsar braking model based on magnetic dipole radiation. Specifically, the braking indices of these eight pulsars are as follows:
- PSR B1509−58: \( n = 2.839 \pm 0.003 \)
- PSR J1119−6127: \( n = 2.684 \pm 0.002 \)
- PSR J1846−0258: \( n = 2.65 \pm 0.01 \)
- PSR B0531+21 (Crab Nebula pulsar): \( n = 2.51 \pm 0.01 \)
- PSR B0540−69: \( n = 2.14 \pm 0.009 \)
- PSR J1833−1034: \( n = 1.857 \pm 0.001 \)
- PSR B0833−45 (Vela pulsar): \( n = 1.4 \pm 0.2 \)
- PSR J1734−3333: \( n = 0.9 \pm 0.2 \)

2. **Abnormal distribution of the second - order derivative of frequency**: Timing observations of more than 300 pulsars have found that the distribution of their second - order derivative of frequency (\(\ddot{\nu}\)) is abnormal. In addition, timing observations of 15 magnetars have also found similar abnormal phenomena. These abnormal second - order derivatives of frequency are inconsistent with the predictions of the classical theory, further challenging the existing pulsar braking models.

### Solutions

To address the above problems, the paper adopts the wind braking model to explain these phenomena. Specifically:

1. **Wind braking model**: This model believes that the braking of pulsars is affected not only by magnetic dipole radiation but also by particle winds. The rotational energy loss rate in the model is:
\[
\dot{E} = \frac{2\mu^2 \Omega^4}{3c^3} \eta
\]
where \(\eta\) is a dimensionless function that depends on the magnetic field inclination angle \(\alpha\), the particle number density \(\kappa\), and the particle acceleration potential difference \(\Delta \phi\).

2. **Calculation of braking index**: In the wind braking model, the braking index \(n\) can be expressed as:
\[
n = 3 + \frac{\Omega}{\eta} \frac{d\eta}{d\Omega}
\]
Magnetic dipole radiation will lead to \(n = 3\), while particle winds will lead to \(n \approx 1\). Therefore, in the wind braking model, the expected range of the braking index is \(1 \leq n \leq 3\).

3. **Long - term rotational evolution**: By calculating the long - term rotational evolution of eight pulsars, the paper explores the change of their braking indices over time. The results show that the braking indices of young pulsars are mainly affected by magnetic dipole radiation, while those of old pulsars and magnetars are more affected by particle winds.

4. **Pulsar death effect**: Considering the pulsar death effect, the paper also discusses the rotational evolution of pulsars after they stop radio emission. When the rotation period of a pulsar approaches the death period, its rotational deceleration will again be mainly dominated by magnetic dipole radiation.

Through these analyses, the paper aims to provide a unified framework to explain the phenomena of low braking indices and abnormal second - order derivatives of frequency in pulsars.