No hair theorems for analogue black holes
Florent Michel,Renaud Parentani,Robin Zegers
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.93.065039
2016-04-11
Abstract:We show that transonic one dimensional flows which are analogous to black holes obey no-hair theorems both at the level of linear perturbations and in non-linear regimes. Considering solutions of the Gross-Pitaevskii (or Korteweg-de Vries) equation, we show that stationary flows which are asymptotically uniform on both sides of the horizon are stable and act as attractors. Using Whitham's modulation theory, we analytically characterize the emitted waves when starting from uniform perturbations. Numerical simulations confirm the validity of this approximation and extend the results to more general perturbations and to the (non-integrable) cubic-quintic Gross-Pitaevskii equation. When considering time reversed flows that correspond to white holes, the asymptotically uniform flows are unstable to sufficiently large perturbations and emit either a macroscopic undulation in the supersonic side, or a non-linear superposition of soliton trains.
Quantum Gases,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Pattern Formation and Solitons,Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether analogue black holes follow no - hair theorems, especially when considering linear perturbations and nonlinear effects. Specifically, the author studied the behavior of one - dimensional supersonic flows (which can be analogized as black holes) after being perturbed, and analyzed the stability and attractor characteristics of these flows. By studying the solutions of the Gross - Pitaevskii equation and the Korteweg - de Vries equation, the author showed whether these analogue black holes can return to a stable, asymptotically homogeneous (AH) state when perturbed, and whether these states are unique.
### Main problems:
1. **Verification of the no - hair theorem**: Can analogue black holes return to a unique, stable asymptotically homogeneous state after being perturbed?
2. **Linear stability**: Are analogue black holes stable when subjected to linear perturbations?
3. **Nonlinear effects**: How do analogue black holes behave when nonlinear effects are considered? Do these nonlinear effects affect the validity of the no - hair theorem?
### Specific research contents:
- **Asymptotically homogeneous supersonic flows**: Study asymptotically homogeneous supersonic flows in one - dimensional fluids, which can be analogized as black holes.
- **Linear stability analysis**: Through numerical simulation and analytical methods, study the behavior of these flows after being subjected to linear perturbations and verify whether they are stable.
- **Nonlinear stability analysis**: Consider nonlinear effects and study the long - term behavior of these flows after being subjected to large perturbations.
- **Comparison with white holes**: Study the behavior of time - reversed flows (i.e., white holes) when perturbed, especially their instability.
### Research methods:
- **Gross - Pitaevskii equation**: A wave equation used to describe Bose - Einstein condensates (BEC).
- **Korteweg - de Vries equation**: A nonlinear wave equation used to describe shallow water waves.
- **Whitham modulation theory**: Used to analyze the propagation and evolution of nonlinear waves.
- **Numerical simulation**: Verify analytical results and extend to more general perturbation cases.
### Main findings:
- **Linear stability**: After being subjected to linear perturbations, the perturbations of analogue black holes will decay over time and finally return to an asymptotically homogeneous stable state.
- **Nonlinear stability**: Even under nonlinear effects, analogue black holes with most initial configurations will also evolve into an asymptotically homogeneous stable state.
- **Instability of white holes**: Time - reversed flows (white holes) are unstable when subjected to sufficiently large perturbations and will produce macroscopic fluctuations or soliton trains.
### Conclusion:
Through detailed analysis and numerical simulation, this paper verifies that analogue black holes do follow the no - hair theorem when perturbed, that is, they will return to a unique, stable asymptotically homogeneous state. This result not only echoes the black hole no - hair theorem in general relativity theoretically, but also provides important theoretical support for the study of analogue black holes experimentally.