Abstract:Many well-known logical identities are naturally written as equivalences between contextual formulas. A simple example is the Boole-Shannon expansion $c[p] \equiv (p \wedge c[\mathrm{true}] ) \vee (\neg\, p \wedge c[\mathrm{false}] )$, where $c$ denotes an arbitrary formula with possibly multiple occurrences of a "hole", called a context, and $c[\varphi]$ denotes the result of "filling" all holes of $c$ with the formula $\varphi$. Another example is the unfolding rule $\mu X. c[X] \equiv c[\mu X. c[X]]$ of the modal $\mu$-calculus. We consider the modal $\mu$-calculus as overarching temporal logic and, as usual, reduce the problem whether $\varphi_1 \equiv \varphi_2$ holds for contextual formulas $\varphi_1, \varphi_2$ to the problem whether $\varphi_1 \leftrightarrow \varphi_2$ is valid . We show that the problem whether a contextual formula of the $\mu$-calculus is valid for all contexts can be reduced to validity of ordinary formulas. Our first result constructs a canonical context such that a formula is valid for all contexts if{}f it is valid for this particular one. However, the ordinary formula is exponential in the nesting-depth of the context variables. In a second result we solve this problem, thus proving that validity of contextual formulas is EXP-complete, as for ordinary equivalences. We also prove that both results hold for CTL and LTL as well. We conclude the paper with some experimental results. In particular, we use our implementation to automatically prove the correctness of a set of six contextual equivalences of LTL recently introduced by Esparza et al. for the normalization of LTL formulas. While Esparza et al. need several pages of manual proof, our tool only needs milliseconds to do the job and to compute counterexamples for incorrect variants of the equivalences.

Formalization of the pumping lemma for context-free languages

Pumping lemmas for linear and nonlinear context-free languages

A Proof of the Pumping Lemma for Context-Free Languages Through Pushdown Automata

A short survey around the pumping lemma for context-free languages

Pumping lemma and Ogden lemma for displacement context-free grammars

Pumping lemmas for classes of languages generated by folding systems

Pumping Lemmas Can be "Harmful"

Swapping Lemmas for Regular and Context-Free Languages

A Generalized Pumping Lemma for Weighted Recognizable Languages

An Educational Tool for Exploring the Pumping Lemma Property for Regular Languages

Closure and Commutation of Fuzzy Regular Languages.

On Minimal Pumping Constants for Regular Languages

Formal Verification of Cp Systems Using Coq

Pumping Lemma for Higher-order Languages

Verifying correct usage of context-free API protocols

$O_2$ is a multiple context-free grammar: an implementation-, formalisation-friendly proof

Lemma Functions for Frama-C: C Programs as Proofs

Pumping Lemma for Quantum Automata

On the Relation between Context-Free Grammars and Parsing Expression Grammars

Analysis of Valid Closure Property of Formal Language

Validity of contextual formulas (extended version)