Quantifying the performance enhancement facilitated by fractional-order implementation of classical control strategies for nanopositioning
Tiecheng Wang,Andres San-Millan,Sumeet S. Aphale
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isatra.2024.01.033
IF: 7.3
2024-02-01
ISA Transactions
Abstract:Highlights • Fractional-order versions of classical control schemes, including IRC, PPF, PVPF, and PAVPF, are proposed and analyzed for nanopositioning systems to improve closed-loop bandwidth and tracking accuracy. • Fractional-order controllers offer additional design parameters compared to their classical integer-order counterparts, leading to increased achievable bandwidth and positioning accuracy. • Detailed simulations validate the efficacy, stability, and robustness of the proposed fractional-order control schemes and show an enhancement of the overall closed-loop performance, even in the presence of unmodeled nonlinear effects such as hysteresis. • The achievable bandwidth is increased by up to 17% and the positioning accuracy is significantly improved (ISE reduced by up to 35%) compared to the classical integer-order implementations. • The findings highlight the untapped potential of fractional-order control schemes in delivering significant closed-loop performance improvements for high-speed, precise nanopositioning systems in emerging applications. For most nanopositioning systems, maximising positioning bandwidth to accurately track periodic and aperiodic reference signals is the primary performance goal. Closed-loop control schemes are employed to overcome the inherent performance limitations such as mechanical resonance, hysteresis and creep. Most reported control schemes are integer-order and combine both damping and tracking actions. In this work, fractional-order controllers from the positive position feedback family namely: the Fractional-Order Integral Resonant Control (FOIRC), the Fractional-Order Positive Position Feedback (FOPPF) controller, the Fractional-Order Positive Velocity and Position Feedback (FOPVPF) controller and the Fractional-Order Positive, Acceleration, Velocity and Position Feedback (FOPAVPF) controller are designed and analyzed. Compared with their classical integer-order implementation, the fractional-order damping and tracking controllers furnish additional design (tuning) parameters, facilitating superior closed-loop bandwidth and tracking accuracy. Detailed simulated experiments are performed on recorded frequency-response data to validate the efficacy, stability and robustness of the proposed control schemes. The results show that the fractional-order versions deliver the best overall performance.
automation & control systems,instruments & instrumentation,engineering, multidisciplinary