A Comprehensive Perspective on Pilot-Job Systems

Matteo Turilli,Mark Santcroos,Shantenu Jha
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1508.04180
2016-03-05
Abstract:Pilot-Job systems play an important role in supporting distributed scientific computing. They are used to consume more than 700 million CPU hours a year by the Open Science Grid communities, and by processing up to 1 million jobs a day for the ATLAS experiment on the Worldwide LHC Computing Grid. With the increasing importance of task-level parallelism in high-performance computing, Pilot-Job systems are also witnessing an adoption beyond traditional domains. Notwithstanding the growing impact on scientific research, there is no agreement upon a definition of Pilot-Job system and no clear understanding of the underlying abstraction and paradigm. Pilot-Job implementations have proliferated with no shared best practices or open interfaces and little interoperability. Ultimately, this is hindering the realization of the full impact of Pilot-Jobs by limiting their robustness, portability, and maintainability. This paper offers a comprehensive analysis of Pilot-Job systems critically assessing their motivations, evolution, properties, and implementation. The three main contributions of this paper are: (i) an analysis of the motivations and evolution of Pilot-Job systems; (ii) an outline of the Pilot abstraction, its distinguishing logical components and functionalities, its terminology, and its architecture pattern; and (iii) the description of core and auxiliary properties of Pilot-Jobs systems and the analysis of seven exemplar Pilot-Job implementations. Together, these contributions illustrate the Pilot paradigm, its generality, and how it helps to address some challenges in distributed scientific computing.
Distributed, Parallel, and Cluster Computing,Software Engineering
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to solve the problems of inconsistent definitions, lack of abstractions and lack of consensus on paradigms faced by the Pilot - Job system in distributed scientific computing. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Lack of definition and understanding**: Although the Pilot - Job system plays an important role in supporting distributed scientific computing and consumes more than 700 million CPU hours annually and processes up to 1 million tasks per day in the ATLAS experiment, there is currently no unified understanding of the definition, underlying abstractions and paradigms of the Pilot - Job system. 2. **Fragmented software landscape**: Due to the lack of shared best practices, open interfaces and interoperability, a large number of Pilot - Job systems with similar functions have emerged. These systems often serve specific usage scenarios and target resources, limiting their universality, portability and maintainability. 3. **Technical limitations**: The existing Pilot - Job system development is not based on in - depth analysis of its underlying abstractions, architectural patterns or computing paradigms, resulting in its properties and functions mainly depending on the requirements of specific software systems or immediate development use cases. 4. **Requirements for future high - performance computing**: As task - level parallelism and dynamic resource management are becoming increasingly important in high - performance computing, most of the existing high - performance system software and middleware are designed to support the execution and optimization of a single task. Although the Pilot - Job system has the potential to support this requirement, the current technical limitations prevent it from fully playing its role. ### Main contributions To solve the above problems, the paper makes the following three main contributions: 1. **Analysis of motivation and evolution**: It analyzes in detail the motivation and development process of the Pilot - Job system and explains how it has developed from an early concept to a modern complex system. 2. **Description of Pilot abstractions**: It clarifies the logical components and functions of the Pilot - Job system, including terms, architectural patterns and their distinctive logical components and functions. 3. **Description of core and auxiliary properties**: It describes the core and auxiliary properties of seven representative implementations of the Pilot - Job system and compares and analyzes these implementations through Pilot abstractions and architectural patterns. Through these contributions, the paper shows the generality of the Pilot paradigm and its application in distributed scientific computing and emphasizes its importance and potential impact in future high - performance computing. ### Formula representation The technical content involved in this paper is mainly concentrated in the field of computer science, especially in distributed computing and resource management. Therefore, although it does not directly involve mathematical formulas, when discussing task scheduling and resource allocation, pseudo - code or algorithm representations can be used to enhance understanding. For example: ```markdown Algorithm 1: Task Dispatching Algorithm Input: Workload W, Resource Placeholder P Output: Scheduled Tasks T 1. Initialize empty list T for scheduled tasks 2. For each task t in workload W: 3. If P has available resources: 4. Schedule t on P 5. Add t to T 6. Return T ``` The above is a summary of the main problems the paper attempts to solve and its contributions. If you need a more detailed interpretation or other parts of the content, please feel free to let us know.