Abstract:Discovery of microRNAs (miRNAs) relies on predictive models for characteristic features from miRNA precursors (pre-miRNAs). The short length of miRNA genes and the lack of pronounced sequence features complicate this task. To accommodate the peculiarities of plant and animal miRNAs systems, tools for both systems have evolved differently. However, these tools are biased towards the species for which they were primarily developed and, consequently, their predictive performance on data sets from other species of the same kingdom might be lower. While these biases are intrinsic to the species, the characterization of their occurrence can lead to computational approaches able to diminish their negative effect on the accuracy of pre-miRNAs predictive models. Here, we investigate in this study how 45 predictive models induced for data sets from 45 species, distributed in eight subphyla, perform when applied to a species different from the species used in its induction. Our computational experiments show that the separability of pre-miRNAs and pseudo pre-miRNAs instances is species-dependent and no feature set performs well for all species, even within the same subphylum. Mitigating this species dependency, we show that an ensemble of classifiers reduced the classification errors for all 45 species. As the ensemble members were obtained using meaningful, and yet computationally viable feature sets, the ensembles also have a lower computational cost than individual classifiers that rely on energy stability parameters, which are of prohibitive computational cost in large scale applications. In this study, the combination of multiple pre-miRNAs feature sets and multiple learning biases enhanced the predictive accuracy of pre-miRNAs classifiers of 45 species. This is certainly a promising approach to be incorporated in miRNA discovery tools towards more accurate and less species-dependent tools.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the accuracy of predicting precursor microRNAs (pre - miRNAs) among different species. Specifically, since existing prediction tools are usually biased towards the species for which they are mainly developed, the prediction performance may decline when applied to datasets of different species within the same kingdom. To overcome this problem, the authors studied the performance of 45 prediction models when applied to 45 different species, which are distributed in eight sub - phyla/classes. Through this method, they hope to find a way to reduce species - dependence and improve the accuracy of cross - species pre - miRNAs prediction models. ### Main research contents 1. **Species - dependence**: The study found that the separability of pre - miRNAs and pseudo - pre - miRNAs instances is species - dependent, and no feature set can perform well for all species, even within the same sub - phylum/class. 2. **Classifier integration**: Classifier ensembles constructed by using multiple feature sets and multiple learning algorithms can reduce classification errors and are applicable to all 45 species. These ensemble classifiers are not only computationally less costly than single classifiers relying on energy stability parameters, but also more feasible in large - scale applications. 3. **Feature importance analysis**: Through the feature importance measure obtained by the Random Forest algorithm, the authors indirectly compared the similarity between instances of different species, further explaining the reasons for species - dependence. ### Research methods - **Dataset construction**: All pre - miRNAs sequences were downloaded from miRBase version 20, and non - redundant sequences of 45 species were screened out from them to construct positive and negative example datasets. - **Feature extraction**: Eight groups of feature sets were extracted, which describe the sequence and structural aspects of pre - miRNAs sequences. - **Classifier training and testing**: Three learning algorithms, Support Vector Machine (SVM), Random Forest (RF) and J48, were used to train classifiers and evaluated on the test set. - **Statistical analysis**: The effects of feature sets, learning algorithms and species on the prediction accuracy of classifiers were studied by Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). ### Conclusions - **Species - dependence**: The classification complexity of pre - miRNAs is obviously species - dependent, and pre - miRNAs of different species have different features. - **Advantages of classifier integration**: By integrating multiple classifiers, the accuracy of cross - species pre - miRNAs prediction can be significantly improved while maintaining a low computational cost. - **Future directions**: This study provides new ideas for developing more accurate miRNA discovery tools with less species - dependence, especially having important significance in multi - species miRNA prediction. Through these studies, the authors provide an effective method for improving the accuracy of cross - species pre - miRNAs prediction, which is of great significance for the functional research and application of miRNA.

Automatic learning of pre-miRNAs from different species

PmliPred: a method based on hybrid model and fuzzy decision for plant miRNA-lncRNA interaction prediction.

PlantMiRNAPred: Efficient Classification of Real and Pseudo Plant Pre-Mirnas

The discriminant power of RNA features for pre-miRNA recognition

MaturePred: Efficient Identification of MicroRNAs Within Novel Plant Pre-miRNAs

Bioinformatics Analysis on Structural Features of Microrna Precursors in Insects

Mirinho: An efficient and general plant and animal pre-miRNA predictor for genomic and deep sequencing data

miRA: adaptable novel miRNA identification in plants using small RNA sequencing data

A Novel Method to Identify Pre-Microrna in Various Species Knowledge Base on Various Species

Improved Pre-miRNAs Identification Through Mutual Information of Pre-miRNA Sequences and Structures

A Brief Survey for MicroRNA Precursor Identification Using Machine Learning Methods

Pmirkb: A Plant Microrna Knowledge Base

BP Neural Network Could Help Improve Pre-miRNA Identification in Various Species.

The Prediction of the Porcine Pre-Micrornas in Genome-Wide Based on Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Homology Searching

An SVM-Based Approach to Discover MicroRNA Precursors in Plant Genomes.

Plantmirp: an Efficient Computational Program for the Prediction of Plant Pre-Mirna by Incorporating Knowledge-Based Energy Features

Machine learning for plant microRNA prediction: A systematic review

Deep Neural Network Based Precursor microRNA Prediction on Eleven Species

miRe2e: a full end-to-end deep model based on transformers for prediction of pre-miRNAs

Classification of Real and Pseudo Microrna Precursors Using Local Structure-Sequence Features and Support Vector Machine

Premli: a Pre-Trained Method to Uncover Microrna-Lncrna Potential Interactions.