Model Risk Analysis via Investment Structuring

Andrei N. Soklakov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1507.07216

2015-07-29

Abstract:"What are the origins of risks?" and "How material are they?" -- these are the two most fundamental questions of any risk analysis. Quantitative Structuring -- a technology for building financial products -- provides economically meaningful answers for both of these questions. It does so by considering risk as an investment opportunity. The structure of the investment reveals the precise sources of risk and its expected performance measures materiality. We demonstrate these capabilities of Quantitative Structuring using a concrete practical example -- model risk in options on vol-targeted indices.

General Finance,Mathematical Finance,Risk Management

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper attempts to address the issue of model risk in the design of financial products, specifically in the pricing of options on volatility-targeted indices. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following two core issues:

1. **Model Selection**: How to choose an appropriate model for pricing options on volatility-targeted indices?
2. **Model Risk Analysis**: How to assess and decompose the model risk arising from different model choices?

### Background and Motivation

The success of financial products directly impacts the success of companies and the entire industry. Therefore, one important way to improve the financial industry is to optimize the design of financial products. The paper introduces "Quantitative Structuring" technology, viewing risk management as an investment opportunity, thereby revealing the precise sources of risk and their significance.

### Specific Issues

- **Model Selection**: The paper explores different model selection schemes, including the constant volatility model (Black-Scholes model), local volatility model (Local Volatility model), and stochastic local volatility model (Stochastic Local Volatility model). The choice of these models significantly affects the accuracy of option pricing.
- **Model Risk Analysis**: By comparing the probability distribution perceived by investors with the market-implied probability distribution, the paper proposes a method to quantify and decompose model risk. Specifically, the paper uses Relative Entropy to measure model risk and evaluates the importance of model risk through the Expected Rate of Return.

### Case Study

The paper takes options on volatility-targeted indices as an example to analyze the model risk under different model choices in detail. The results show that using a simple constant volatility model leads to significant model risk (up to 8.31% per year), while using a local volatility model can significantly reduce model risk. Further analysis shows that the main sources of model risk are the failure to accurately capture forward volatility and skew risk.

### Conclusion

Through quantitative structuring technology, the paper provides a systematic method to assess and decompose model risk. This not only aids in the design of financial products but can also be applied to other types of financial products and risk management scenarios. Overall, the paper emphasizes the importance of choosing an appropriate model in the design of financial products and provides a practical tool for evaluating model risk.