Abstract:Do the spacetime manifolds which feature in our best scientific theories reflect anything metaphysically weighty in the world (e.g., any fundamental substances or relations)? Should we extend our notions of space and time beyond the epistemological roles they play in helping us codify the dynamical behavior of matter? Kant famously answered ``No'' to both of these questions, contra Newton and Leibniz. This paper introduces novel technical and philosophical support for such a (Neo-)Kantian perspective on the metaphysics of space and time. To begin, I will make an explicit analogy between broadly Humean views of laws (e.g., Lewis, Demarest, etc.) and dynamics-first views of geometry (e.g., Brown). I will then continue this line of analogous views beyond the metaphysics of laws debate and the dynamical vs geometric spacetime debate by extending it into the context of spacetime topology. Namely, I will put forward a dynamics-first view of topology (in answer to Norton's problem of pre-geometry). This dynamics-first view of topology is supported by some powerful new techniques for topological redescription which I have recently developed in Grimmer (2023a) and Grimmer (2023b), namely the ISE Method. These new techniques allow us to remove and replace the topological underpinnings of our spacetime theories just as easily as we can switch between different coordinate systems. For instance, a theory set on a Möbius strip might be redescribed as being set on the Euclidean plane and vice versa. Indeed, as Grimmer (2023b) has proved, the ISE Method gives us access to effectively every possible spacetime framing of a given theory's kinematical and dynamical content. Given this overabundance of candidate spacetime framings, it is then conceivable that one can pick out a theory's topological structure via something analogous to a Best Systems Analysis.

Problem of Time: Temporal Relationalism Compatibility of Other Local Classical Facets Completed

Problem of Time and Background Independence: the Individual Facets

The problem with `The Problem of Time'

Time Remains

Reversible time travel with freedom of choice

From Humean Laws to a Neo-Kantian Spacetime: A Dynamics-First View of Topology

Time is Order

Emergent Time and Time Travel in Quantum Physics

A cognitive basis for physical time

Reversible dynamics with closed time-like curves and freedom of choice

Relational Quadrilateralland. I. The Classical Theory

Space-time Constructivism vs. Modal Provincialism: Or, How Special Relativistic Theories Needn't Show Minkowski Chronogeometry

Why manifold substantivalism is probably not a consequence of classical mechanics

Disappearing Without a Trace: The Arrows of Time in Kent's Solution to the Lorentzian Quantum Reality Problem

Leibniz--Mach foundations for GR and fundamental physics

Efficient Recursion Method for Inverting Overlap Matrix

Relativistic Constraints for a Naturalistic Metaphysics of Time

Buckets of Water and Waves of Space: Why Spacetime is Probably A Substance

On the nature of discrete space-time: The atomic theory of space-time and its effects on Pythagoras's theorem, time versus duration, inertial anomalies of astronomical bodies, and special relativity at the Planck scale