Toward the Circular Economy in the Aquaculture Sector: Bibliometric, Network and Content Analyses

Margherita Masi,Felice Adinolfi,Yari Vecchio,Giulio Paolo Agnusdei,Benedetta Coluccia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16135405

IF: 3.9

2024-06-26

Sustainability

Abstract:This paper offers an overview of circular economy strategies applied to the aquaculture sector. The growing challenges imposed on the sector by the strategies of the Green Deal impose new growth strategies in the name of sustainability. The scalability of these strategies is increasingly hampered by regulatory voids and by the absence of a universally accepted assessment method for measuring the impacts of current aquaculture systems. More than ever, a review of knowledge in the circular economy field is required to comprehend where the aquaculture sector is heading, and in order to make the required transition. The present review proposes a bibliometric analysis, a network analysis and a content analysis, which highlight a very new and expanding field of research. The studies were firstly analyzed from a micro (animal metabolism) to a macro perspective (policies, markets and society), emphasizing where research is still lacking. Furthermore, a second level of classification concerns the type of circularity approach proposed for the aquaculture system, which can be divided into open-loop or closed-loop strategies. Regarding the open-loop-related studies, the focus of the evaluation is devoted to the different bioeconomic values of the circularity strategies proposed for the biological flows entering and exiting the aquaculture system. The literature review offered insights into the identification of research threads that are developing around the aquaculture sector.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the application of circular economy strategies in the field of aquaculture and reviews existing research through bibliometric analysis, network analysis, and content analysis. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Assessing the overall impact of existing aquaculture systems**: Identifying the most effective areas for implementing circular economy practices. There are challenges in current research regarding the comprehensive assessment of existing systems, particularly in terms of socio-economic and environmental impacts.

2. **Systematically promoting the transition of the aquaculture industry towards a circular economy**: Most literature focuses on single practice cases for specific species, lacking research on the systematic transformation of the entire industry. The paper attempts to fill this research gap.

3. **Multi-level analysis of circular economy strategies**: Exploring the application of circular economy strategies from three levels: micro (animal metabolism), meso (material and energy exchanges between farms and the environment), and macro (how markets, society, and policies promote the dissemination of circular practices).

4. **Distinguishing between open-loop and closed-loop strategies**: The paper differentiates between closed-loop strategies directly applied within aquaculture systems and open-loop strategies that interact with other economic sectors. These strategies aim to enhance the circularity and sustainability of input and output flows.

5. **Quantifying the bioeconomic value**: For open-loop strategies, the paper also evaluates their bioeconomic value, which helps to understand the position of different strategies in the value chain and their potential economic benefits.

In summary, the goal of this paper is to provide theoretical basis and support for the development of the aquaculture industry towards a more sustainable and circular direction through an in-depth analysis of existing literature.