Abstract:In 1861, Maxwell derived two of his equations of electromagnetism by modelling a magnetic line of force as a `molecular vortex' in a fluid-like medium. Later, in 1980, Berry and colleagues conducted experiments on a `phase vortex', a wave geometry in a fluid which is analogous to a magnetic line of force and also exhibits behaviour corresponding to the quantisation of magnetic flux. Here we unify these approaches by writing down a solution to the equations of motion for a compressible fluid which behaves in the same way as a magnetic line of force. We then revisit Maxwell's historical inspiration, namely Faraday's 1846 model of light as disturbances in lines of force. Using our unified model, we show that such disturbances resemble photons: they are polarised, absorbed discretely, obey Maxwell's full equations of electromagnetism to first order, and quantitatively reproduce the correlation that is observed in the Bell tests.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to propose a hydrodynamic model that can explain the behavior of photons and the results of Bell tests by updating Maxwell's 1861 fluid model of magnetic lines of force and combining the modern understanding of polarized waves and quantized magnetic flux experiments. Specifically, the goals of the paper include:
1. **Unifying Electromagnetic Theory and Fluid Mechanics**: The paper attempts to explain electromagnetic phenomena through a fluid mechanics model, especially by introducing the concept of "phase vortex", which exhibits behavior similar to magnetic lines of force in the fluid.
2. **Explaining the Properties of Light**: Based on Faraday's 1846 model of light as a perturbation in lines of force, the paper shows how these perturbations are similar to photons, that is, they are polarized, discretely absorbed, obey Maxwell's equations, and can quantitatively reproduce the correlations observed in Bell tests.
3. **Solving the Problem of Polarized Wave Propagation in Fluids**: The paper corrects the misunderstanding of 19th - century scientists that polarized waves cannot exist in fluids, and proves the existence and propagation mechanism of polarized waves in fluids through modern experiments and theoretical analysis.
4. **Providing a Physical Explanation for the Violation of Bell's Inequality**: The paper proposes a model based on fluid mechanics that can explain why the results observed in Bell tests are consistent with the predictions of quantum mechanics but contradict the classical local realism hypothesis. This model challenges the CHSH (Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt) hypothesis that polarization information can only be carried by photons and localized within them.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
- **Theoretical Innovation**: By introducing the concept of "phase vortex", the paper provides a new fluid - mechanics perspective for electromagnetic theory, which can not only explain the behavior of photons but also non - local phenomena in quantum mechanics.
- **Experimental Verification**: The paper cites multiple experimental results, such as the experiments of Deaver and Fairbank on magnetic flux quantization in superconductors and the experiments of Berry et al. on phase vortices in water waves, which support the theoretical assumptions in the paper.
- **Inter - disciplinary Integration**: The paper combines knowledge from multiple fields such as fluid mechanics, electromagnetism, and quantum mechanics, showing a unified theoretical framework and providing a new perspective for understanding natural phenomena.
### Conclusion
By updating and expanding the early models of Maxwell and Faraday, the paper successfully links fluid mechanics with electromagnetic theory and quantum mechanics, providing a physical model that can explain the behavior of photons and the results of Bell tests. This model not only challenges the traditional local realism hypothesis but also provides a new, physically intuitive method for understanding quantum phenomena.