Encouraging Breastfeeding Without Guilt: A Qualitative Study of Breastfeeding Promotion in the Singapore Healthcare Setting
Grace Tan,Chompoonut Topothai,Yvette van der Eijk
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ijwh.s465209
2024-09-01
International Journal of Women s Health
Abstract:Grace Ping Ping Tan, 1 Chompoonut Topothai, 1, 2 Yvette van der Eijk 1 1 Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore; 2 International Health Policy Program, Ministry of Public Health, Nonthaburi, Thailand Correspondence: Grace Ping Ping Tan, Email Introduction: In Singapore, the healthcare system strongly encourages mothers to breastfeed and breastfeeding initiation is near-universal. However, sustained breastfeeding rates remain low. Little is currently known about how breastfeeding information disseminated in the healthcare setting influences women's breastfeeding experiences. This study explored breastfeeding promotion and educational resources from the perspective of Singaporean mothers and healthcare workers. Methods: Semi-structured interviews with 14 mothers of infants aged 1– 5 months and who had used obstetric, maternity, and/or paediatric services in Singapore, and 20 health workers with experience in general, obstetric, maternal, or paediatric care recruited using purposive sampling methods. Interview transcripts were coded using an inductive method. Results: Breastfeeding communications were viewed as too moralized and too focused on nudging women to breastfeed, with relatively little emphasis on timely, practical information or solutions for mothers unable to latch. Hence mothers tended to rely on alternative resources such as blogs. They lacked in-depth knowledge of the benefits of breastfeeding and viewed it as detrimental to maternal mental wellbeing due to the perceived stress and guilt when experiencing difficulties, notably with milk supply and latching, and from the inability to meet breastfeeding expectations. Husbands, older family members, confinement nannies, and employers were considered influential individuals to encourage breastfeeding, but they commonly discouraged breastfeeding due to social and cultural factors which led to supplementation with formula. Conclusion: For better breastfeeding outcomes, future informational sources on breastfeeding should be morally neutral, practical, set realistic expectations for the demands of breastfeeding, and target influential individuals such as family members, confinement nannies and employers. Keywords: breastfeeding, communications, community health, health promotion, lactation, maternal health Singapore is a high-income city-state with majority ethnic groups of Chinese (76%), Malays (15%), and Indians (8%). 1,2 The median age of first-time mothers is 31, 3 and more than three-quarters of mothers balance infant care with employment following a 16-week maternity leave. 4 In 2013, Singapore adopted the Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative (BFHI), 5 which promotes and normalises breastfeeding within BFHI-accredited maternity settings, 6 and launched initiatives for nursing-friendly workplaces. 7,8 The healthcare system promotes breastfeeding with antenatal classes, informational resources and support groups, while government and hospital websites emphasize the benefits of breastfeeding, address common misperceptions, and provide practical tips and contact details for lactation support. 9–16 Beyond this, Singaporean mothers also turn to family, friends, and the media for breastfeeding advice. 17,18 According to the latest national breastfeeding data (from 2011), virtually all Singaporean mothers (99%) initiate breastfeeding after delivery, but exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) rates quickly drop to 50% at hospital discharge and 28% at two months. 19 In a more recent study, the EBF rate at six months was 38% among 258 Singaporean women who brought their infants for routine immunisations at the public primary care clinics. 20 This suggests that breastfeeding promotion efforts since 2011 have had positive impacts but the six-month EBF rate still lies far below the global target of 70%. 21 It is unclear why, despite national campaigns to promote breastfeeding, EBF is not sustained in Singapore. Other high-income countries (HICs), notably the UK and USA, have reported similar issues. 22,23 In Singapore, lower breastfeeding rates were observed in mothers who were younger in age, 18,19 less educated, 18,24 employed, 19 and had lower awareness of breastfeeding benefits, 18 no prior breastfeeding experience, 18,20,25,26 and who were overweight, of Chinese ethnicity, low income, and had poor postpartum health, 26,27 high postpartum anxiety levels or birthing difficulties. 28 Studies from other HICs report similar findings linking lower breastfeeding rates with age, education l -Abstract Truncated-
obstetrics & gynecology