Abstract:INTRODUCTION As of 2019, women comprise 52.4% of medical school matriculants, make up more than one-third of the active physician workforce, and nearly half of residents and fellows. Although the number of women physicians continues to increase, many surgical subspecialities, including orthopaedic surgery, have not seen a substantial increase in the percentage of women physicians. This may be due to a lack of mentorship. Efforts within the medical community to decrease the burden of gender bias on women include attempts to increase access to mentorship opportunities. Effective mentoring is a critical aspect of any resident physician's training. The purpose of this study was to analyze the most important aspects of mentorship in the academic advancement of female surgical subspecialists. METHODS A systematic review of the literature was performed according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines in July 2022 using the electronic databases PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Database, Scopus, and Web of Science. 10 Search terms can be found in Appendix 1. An initial abstract screen of each article was conducted by 3 authors. Studies were included if they focused on mentorship of women in academic surgery, were published from 2000-2023, were peer-reviewed articles in the English language, and conducted in the United States. Two reviewers screened each article based on the criteria; the remaining studies were then reviewed in full text. After the full text screen, the eligible articles underwent data extraction and quality assessment using AXIS tool or CASP checklist. The results were then analyzed and synthesized. Additionally, risk of bias was assessed using the 2018 version of the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). RESULTS Several common themes among the 10 studies were identified. Six (60%) studies discussed the impact of mentorship on career success. One of the most important ways that mentors assist mentees is by serving as positive role models. Two (20%) studies noted that goal-setting assistance is one of the most helpful ways mentors can provide guidance. Guidance with academic politics (such as funding and research priorities) was identified as a major contribution by mentors in two (20%) studies. The second most common theme was female mentors (6; 60%). Most studies (9; 90%) agree that it's important for women surgeons to have female mentors. The importance of multiple mentors was explored in 4 (40%) papers. Three (30%) studies addressed the issue of balancing work and life responsibilities among female surgeons. CONCLUSION This review suggests that female surgical subspecialists value mentorship in regard to career development, managing work-life balance, and academic productivity. Although many studies found that female physicians were more likely to express the desire for a same-sex mentor, these female subspecialists were also more likely to report not only a lack of mentorship but a lack of available female mentors. Effective mentoring from multiple mentors, preferably some of whom identify as female, may improve career advancement in female surgical subspecialists and promote gender equality in these fields. More research is needed to establish a baseline of knowledge on how mentoring specifically affects quantitative aspects of career development, such as research productivity and promotions, to continue to equilibrate these historically male-dominated subspecialities.

Looking for mentor replacement therapy? A coach may be the answer

Finding the Right Mentor

Physician Coaching: An Intervention to Address the Burnout Gender Gap Among Physicians

Women in Anesthesiology and the Mid-Career Stall: Why They Are Not Advancing Into Senior Leadership

Do Resident Coaching Programs Benefit their Coaches? Impact of a Professional Development Coaching Program on The Coaches

The Impact of Mentoring on Academic Career Success in Surgical Subspecialties: A Systematic Review

Competencies for Those Who Coach Physicians: A Modified Delphi Study

Challenges of work-life balance for women physicians/mothers working in leadership positions

Lifelong development in medicine: a thematic analysis of coaching goals throughout medical careers

Perspectives From Students and Faculty on How Women Achieve Leadership Roles in Academic Medicine: An Exploratory Qualitative Study

Pediatric Emergency Medicine and Mentoring

Mentorship for Non-academic, Mid-Career Hospitalist Physicians: The Journey Taken Less Often

A Novel Approach to Mentorship in Pediatric Cardiology: A Group for Women

"A lifelong journey:" a phenomenological exploration of faculty perceptions about coach training at an academic medical center

Leadership Development in Early Career Scientists: Themes and Feedback from Executive Coaching and Mindful Leadership Training

Alternative Approaches to Mentoring

Evaluating the Impact of Coaching Through the Transition to Residency

How to undertake an effective coaching session

Women in Leadership: Why So Few and What to Do About It

Charting a professional course: a review of mentorship in medicine

Innovative Wellness Models to Support Advancement and Retention Among Women Physicians.