Red phosphor SrWO4:Eu3+ for potential application in white LED
Zhenghua Ju,Ruiping Wei,Xiuping Gao,Weisheng Liu,Chaoran Pang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.optmat.2011.01.025
IF: 3.754
2011-01-01
Optical Materials
Abstract:Research highlights ► We prepared Eu 3+ doped and Eu 3+ , M + (M = Li, Na, K) co-doped SrWO 4 phosphors. ► The phosphors can be effectively excited by the light of 394 and 465 nm. ► Charge compensators can improve the fluorescent intensities and quantum yields. ► The phosphors have small thermal-quenching properties. ► The phosphors show good suitability for applied in white LEDs. Abstract A series of red light emissive phosphors Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10) and Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , M 0.08 + (M = Li, Na, K) were prepared through solid-state reactions, and their luminescent properties were studied. The influences of contents of Eu 3+ and charge compensators on the luminescent properties were discussed. Both the fluorescent intensities and quantum yields are greatly improved through adding charge compensators. The phosphors can be effectively excited by the light of 394 and 465 nm, and show bright red emissions. The decay curves are well fitted with single exponential decay models. Furthermore, the temperature-dependent luminescence indicates the phosphors exhibit small thermal-quenching properties. So the phosphors are able to be applied to white light-emitting diodes. Keywords SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ Phosphor LED Charge compensation Thermal stability 1 Introduction White light-emitting diodes (LEDs) provide great superiorities such as low electric consumption, environment-friendly, high brightness, long lifetime, good reliability, fast response [1,2] , and extensively applied in solid-state lightings [3] . A white-light LED with a blue InGaN chip in combination with a yellow phosphor (YAG:Ce 3+ ) has been commercially available [4] . However, such a combination exhibits a poor color rendering index (<80) due to the lack of a red light component (above 600 nm) [5] . So, some red phosphors are needed to introduce in this combination [6] . One approach to producing white light is the combination of blue LED with green- and red-emitting phosphor materials [7] , the other combination is blue LED with green-, yellow- and red-emitting phosphor materials [8] . Another method to assemble white LEDs is to use red, green and blue light-emitting phosphors coated on a near ultraviolet LED chip to generate white light that will yield high quality LED [9,10] . All these applications require red-emitting phosphors; however, commercially red phosphor for white LEDs used Y 2 O 2 S:Eu 3+ shows lower efficiency under near-UV or blue light excitations and instability [11] . Therefore, it is important to research red phosphors can applied to white LEDs. Eu 3+ has been extensively studied as an activator ion because of its particular spectral characters and has been used in most commercial red phosphors [12] . Eu 3+ ions activated tungstates have received considerable attention due to the special properties of WO 4 2 - group [13–21] . These phosphors show excellent thermal and hydrolytic stability, and have strong absorption in the near ultraviolet region. Therefore, tungstates are good choice as host materials for white LEDs. For all that, little attention has been paid to the luminescent properties of Eu 3+ -doped SrWO 4 . So we prepared SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ and studied the luminescent properties. Very recently, we reported a novel phosphor SrWO 4 :Sm 3+ [22] . The phosphor SrWO 4 :Sm 3+ was synthesized by high temperature solid-state reaction in air atmosphere, with same prepared method of SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ . In the emission spectrum of SrWO 4 :Sm 3+ , three peaks locate at 562 nm, 596 nm and 642 nm, corresponding to CIE chromaticity coordinates of x = 0.54 and y = 0.46, which indicates the orange light emitting; for SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ , the emission spectrum is consist of strong peaks around 612 and 615 nm and weak peaks around 590, 654 and 700 nm, it has CIE chromaticity coordinates of ( x = 0.65, y = 0.35), and shows red light emission. The phosphor SrWO 4 :Sm 3+ can be efficiently excited by ultraviolet; while the excitation bands of SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ are matched well with the characteristic emission from near-UV and blue LED. The temperature-dependent luminescence indicate both the phosphors SrWO 4 :Sm 3+ and SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ exhibit small thermal-quenching properties. In this paper, the luminescent properties Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10) and Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , M 0.08 + (M = Li, Na, K) were investigated. The chromaticity coordinates were compared with that of commercial red phosphor Y 2 O 2 S:Eu 3+ , and the results show that the chromaticity coordinates of our phosphors closer to the standard of NTSC ( x = 0.67, y = 0.33) than the commercial red phosphor Y 2 O 2 S:Eu 3+ . Since the ability to withstand high temperature is a basic requirement for phosphor applied in LEDs, the thermally stable properties of the phosphor were investigated, and it turned out to be excellent. So the phosphor is a potential red component for white light-emitting diodes. 2 Experimental A series of Eu 3+ doped and Eu 3+ , M + co-doped SrWO 4 phosphors were prepared by solid-state reaction method from SrCO 3 (A.R.), WO 3 (A.R.) and Eu 2 O 3 (99.99%) as the starting materials [22] using Li 2 CO 3 (A.R.), Na 2 CO 3 (A.R.) and K 2 CO 3 (A.R.) as the other materials. The molar concentration of the activator Eu 3+ ions varied from 2% to 10%. The synthesized products were characterized by X-ray diffraction (XRD) using a RigakuD/MAX-2400 X-ray diffractometer. The chromaticity coordinates calculated by the CIE system. Temperature-dependent luminescence of phosphor was measured on a Hitachi F-4500 fluorescence spectrophotometer. More details see reference [22] . Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) data were collected on a Nicolet 5700 infrared spectrotometer in the range of 400–1500 cm −1 using KBr pellets. The photoluminescent (PL) spectra, fluorescent quantum yield and fluorescent lifetime measurements were carried out on an Edinburgh FLS 920 combined fluorescence lifetime and steady state spectrometer. The FLS 920 spectrometer is equipped with a 450 W xenon lamp for photoluminescent (PL) spectra and an optical parametric oscillator for lifetime measurements. The excitation spectra were obtained scanning from 240 to 480 nm monitored at 615 nm. The emission spectra were scanned from 580 to 710 nm while excited at 394 and 465 nm, respectively. The fluorescent quantum yields were measured using an integrating sphere. Excitaition light source: 450 W xenon lamp; surface coating of the intergating sphere: barium sulfate; data acquiring technology: single photo counting mode; excitation wavelength: 394 and 465 nm, respectively. All measurements were carried out at room temperature except for the temperature-dependent luminescence. 3 Results and discussion Fig. 1 shows the X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of the standard pattern JCPDS No. 08-0490 and sample Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10). All the strong peaks of the samples can be assigned to the tetragonal phase SrWO 4 ( a = 5.416 Å and c = 11.95 Å) reported in the literature (JCPDS 08-0490). It can be considered that the as-obtained samples have good crystallinities and no other impurities were observed in the products. The crystal structure of strontium tungstate (SrWO 4 ) is shown in Fig. 2 . The strontium tungstate (SrWO 4 ) belongs to sheelite structure [23] , and W 6+ occupies the tetrahedral sites constructed by O 2− in this structure; composing WO 4 2 - anion complex. Sr 2+ is eight-coordinated by O 2− , thus formed a distorted cube. The radius of Sr 2+ is 1.16 Å (when coordination number CN = 8) and Eu 3+ is 1.07 Å (when coordination number CN = 8), it is presumed that Sr 2+ can be occupied by the Eu 3+ ions. The FT-IR spectra of the samples provide an accessorial explanation to the products’ structures. The FT-IR spectra of Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + with different contents of Eu 3+ are shown in Fig. 3 . Vibration wave numbers (cm −1 ) and assignments for Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10) are listed in Table 1 . It can be seen from Fig. 3 that a strong absorption band at 815 cm −1 which related to O–W–O stretches of the WO 4 tetrahedron. Because the AWO 4 -type sheelite oxides having S 4 site symmetry for WO 4 2 - groups, which show the main absorption bands in the region 400–1000 cm −1 centered around 911, 833 and 405 cm −1 corresponding to the ν 1 , ν 3 and ν 2 modes of WO 4 2 - groups, respectively [18] . For the same reason, around 411 cm −1 band is attributed to the ν 2 stretching vibration of W–O. The absorption peaks appearing in the range of 400–1000 cm −1 are the typical FT-IR absorption peaks of WO 4 2 - with scheelite tetragonal structure. The FT-IR peaks of all products are approximately identical; that is to say, although the contents of Eu 3+ are different, the structure of the crystals belongs to the same type. The results are in agreement with the analysis of XRD. The typical excitation and emission spectra of SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ are shown in Fig. 4 , respectively. From the excitation spectrum it can be seen that a broad band in the range of 240–330 nm, which is assigned to the combination of the charge-transfer transition of O 2− → W 6+ and O 2− → Eu 3+ . The strong excitation band around 394, 465 nm corresponding to 7 F 0 → 5 L 6 , 7 F 0 → 5 D 2 transitions of Eu 3+ ions, respectively. These excitation bands are attributed to Eu 3+ 4f levels and listed in Table 2 . The bands located at 394 and 465 nm are well matched with the characteristic emission from near-UV and blue LED. The emission spectum shows sharp lines which corresponding to typical 4f characteristics emission of Eu 3+ . The highest emission peaks around 612 and 615 nm are assigned to the Eu 3+ electric dipole transition of 5 D 0 → 7 F 2 . The weak emission peaks around 590, 654 and 700 nm come of the transitions of Eu 3+ ion from 5 D 0 to 7 F 1 , 7 F 3 and 7 F 4 levels, respectively. The result is benefit to obtain phosphor with good color purity. When Eu 3+ ion is local in a low symmetry site, it displays 5 D 0 → 7 F 2 electric dipole transition, which appears dominantly and highly sensitive to its local environment. In SrWO 4 :Eu, because there is lack of inversion symmetry and break of parity selection rules, it makes the 5 D 0 → 7 F 2 electric dipole transition strongest among all these transition [24] . From the recorded emission spectra of phosphors SrWO 4 :Eu, the emission spectra of Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10) excited by 465 nm show identical features with that excited by 394 nm, the fluorescent intensity depends on the concentrations of Eu 3+ . The emission intensity of Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( λ ex = 394 nm or 465 nm) with different concentrations of Eu 3+ is shown in Fig. 5 . The fluorescent intensity increase with the increasing concentration of Eu 3+ ion up to x = 0.08, then decreased above the concentration due to concentration quenching. This quenching process is usually attributed to energy migration among Eu 3+ ions, which bring the excitation energy to killer sites such as surface defects in powders [25] . In general, luminous color is represented by color coordinates and color ratios. The values of chromaticity coordinates of the phosphor Sr 0.92 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + have been calculated from the spectra using the CIE (Commission International de l’Eclairage, France) system. It has been found that the sample have chromaticity coordinates of x = 0.65 and y = 0.35 ( λ ex = 394 nm or 465 nm), which shows red light emission. The emission intensity of Eu 3+ activated SrWO 4 ( λ ex = 394 nm or 465 nm) doped with different charge compensators is shown in Fig. 6 . It is obvious that the emission intensities are significantly increased by the efficient charge compensation. Among them, the phosphor Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + has the best charge compensation effect. In the next place is phosphor Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , K 0.08 + , Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Na 0.08 + phosphor shows the lowest fluorescent intensity. The change of fluorescent intensity is due to differences of the ionic radii of alkali metal ions. In general, the doped Eu 3+ and alkaline ions are randomly distributed in the sites cation of the host. The cations with different radii in the host compound can result in some distortions of the sub-lattice structure around the luminescent center ions and produce different photoluminescent properties [26] . The ionic radius of Sr 2+ is 1.16 Å, while the ionic radius of Li + , Na + , K + for charge compensation are 0.70 Å, 0.98 Å and 1.37 Å, respectively. When alkali metal ions are co-doped into SrWO 4 , the distortion grade is different, which impact on the luminous properties and crystal structure. In addition, the ionic radius of Li + is the smallest, it easiest doped into the crystal, and exhibit the best charge compensate effect. The fluorescent intensity is enhanced greatly by adding charge compensators. It is necessary to keep charge balance when a trivalent metallic ion is incorporated into a host lattice and substitutes for a divalent metallic ion. In phosphor Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + , one Eu 3+ is expected to replace one Sr 2+ ion. If so, to keep charge balance in the phosphor would be a difficulty, therefore, the host has to capture O 2 in the air to solve the problem. Another way to keep charge balance is provided by a strontium vacancy ( V Sr ″ ), 3Sr Sr → 2 Eu Sr + V Sr ″ , thus, only parts of Eu 3+ go into the lattice and occupy Sr sites, in the phosphor may exist impurity phases Eu 2 O 3 or SrO which could restrain the growth of SrWO 4 grains during the sintering process, and results in the decrease of fluorescent intensity. When M + (M = Li, Na, K) codoped in the phosphor, M + play a role of charge compensation. Two Sr 2+ ions are replaced by one Eu 3+ and one M + , as express: 2 Sr Sr × → Eu Sr + M Sr ′ , Eu 3+ ions are able to be fully introduced into Sr sites, lead to Eu 2 O 3 and SrO are reacted with WO 3 to a large extent and enhanced the fluorescent intensities. The sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + has chromaticity coordinates of x = 0.66 and y = 0.34 ( λ ex = 394 nm or 465 nm), which closer to the standard of NTSC ( x = 0.67, y = 0.33) than the commercial red phosphor Y 2 O 2 S:Eu 3+ (0.622, 0.351) [27] . The results indicating that the phosphor can be used for white LEDs. At room temperature, for phosphor Sr 0.92 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + and Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , M 0.08 + (M = Li, Na, K), the fluorescent decay curves corresponding to the emissional line at 615 nm of the Eu 3+ ion with identical features. As an instance, the fluorescent decay curves of Sr 0.92 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + for 615 nm emissions and fitting curves are shown in Fig. 7 . The decay behavior can be expressed as follows: I = I 0 + A 1 exp - t τ 1 where I and I 0 are phosphorescence intensity, A 1 is constant and t is time, τ 1 is decay time for exponential component. They are well fitted with single-exponential function, under excited 410 nm, the fluorescent lifetime of the sample Sr 0.92 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + is measured to be τ 1 = 0.66 ms; under excited 465 nm, that is 0.62 ms. For Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , M 0.08 + (M = Li, Na, K), under excited 465 nm, the fluorescent lifetimes as follow: sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + , τ 1 = 0.80 ms; sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , K 0.08 + , τ 1 = 0.72 ms; Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Na 0.08 + , τ 1 = 0.68 ms. The results shows that the lifetimes are short enough for potential applications in white LEDs. The fluorescent quantum yield of Sr 0.92 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + is 33% when the phosphor under excitation of 394 nm, and that is 58% when it under excitation of 465 nm. Under excited 394 nm, the fluorescent quantum yields as follow: sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + , it is 61%; for sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , K 0.08 + , that is 70%; Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Na 0.08 + , it is 79%. Under excited 465 nm, they are: sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + , 96%; sample Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , K 0.08 + , 81%; Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Na 0.08 + , 98%. The thermal quenching property is an important technological parameter for phosphors applied in white LEDs [28] . The thermal-quenching properties of the phosphor Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + ( λ ex = 394 nm or 465 nm) were investigated in the temperature range from 20 to 180 °C. The obtained results were presented in Fig. 8 . By exciting of 394 nm light, the fluorescent intensity first decrease to 94% of its initial value at 20 °C and then decrease slightly during the temperature-increasing course to 100 °C, with increasing temperature up to 180 °C, it gradually decreased to 57% of that measured at the temperature of 20 °C. Under excited 465 nm, the fluorescent intensity first decrease to 93% of that measured at the temperature of 20 °C, and then decrease slightly in the range of 40–120 °C, it decrease to 64% of its initial value at 20 °C when the temperature was elevated to 180 °C. The results indicating that the phosphors SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ and SrWO 4 :Eu 3+ , M + (M = Li, Na, K) have small thermal-quenching properties and good suitability for applied in white LEDs. 4 Conclusions In summary, a series of red-emitting phosphors Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10) and Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , M 0.08 + (M = Li, Na, K) were prepared by solid state method. For phosphors Sr 1− x WO 4 : Eu x 3 + ( x = 0.02–0.10), the fluorescent intensity of the phosphors excited by 394 and 465 nm reach a maximum at x = 0.08. The bright red emission locate at about 615 nm originating from the electric dipole transition 5 D 0 → 7 F 2 excited by the light of 394 and 465 nm. Enhanced emission intensities are observed in the phosphors co-doped with efficient charge compensators. Sr 0.84 WO 4 : Eu 0.08 3 + , Li 0.08 + has the best charge compensation effect. The results of fitting the experimental data of fluorescent decay curves revealed that Eu 3+ -doped SrWO 4 phosphor in terms of a single exponential decay model. The fluorescent lifetimes of the phosphor are short enough for applications in white LEDs. In addition, the phosphors show small thermal quenching. Given good overall luminescent performances, this phosphor is a potential candidate as red-emitting component for white LED. Acknowledgements The authors thank the National Natural Science Foundation of China (20771048, 20931003, J0730425) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (lzujbky-2009-k06) for financial support. Appendix A Supplementary material Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.optmat.2011.01.025 . Appendix A Supplementary material Supplementary data 1 Fig. S1. Fluorescent decay curves of Sr 0.84 Eu 0.08 Li 0.08 WO 4 (excited by 465 nm, red line shows the fitting result); Fig. S2. Fluorescent decay curves of Sr 0.84 Eu 0.08 K 0.08 WO 4 (excited by 465 nm, red line shows the fitting result); Fig. S3. Fluorescent decay curves of Sr 0.84 Eu 0.08 Na 0.08 WO 4 (excited by 465 nm, red line shows the fitting result) . References [1] J.H. Yum S.Y. Seo S. Lee Y.E. Sung J. Electrochem. Soc. 150 2003 H47 [2] H. He R.L. Fu Y.G. Cao X.F. Song Z.W. Pan X.R. Zhao Q.B. Xiao R. Li Opt. Mater. 32 2010 632 [3] X.G. Zhang X.X. Wang J.Q. Huang J.X. Shi M.L. Gong Opt. Mater. 32 2009 75 [4] S. Nakamura G. Fasol The Blue Laser Diode 1997 Springer Berlin [5] F.A. Ponce D.P. Bour Nature 386 1997 351 [6] Y.S. Hu W.D. Zhuang H.Q. Ye D.H. Wang S.S. Zhang X.W. Huang J. Alloys Compd. 390 2005 226 [7] T. Nishida T. Ban N. Kobayashi Appl. Phys. Lett. 82 2003 3817 [8] M.P. Saradhi U.V. Varadaraju Chem. Mater. 18 2006 5267 [9] J.K. Park M.A. Lim C.H. Kim H.D. Park J.T. Park S.Y. Choi Appl. Phys. Lett. 82 2003 683 [10] Y.D. Huh J.H. Shim Y. Kim Y.R. Do J. Electrochem. Soc. 150 2003 H57 [11] S. Neeraj N. Kijima A.K. Cheetham Chem. Phys. Lett. 387 2004 2 [12] C.R. Ronda J. Lumin. 72–74 1997 49 [13] S.K. Shi X.R. Liu J. Gao J. Zhou Spectrochim. Acta, Part A 69 2008 396 [14] S.K. Shi J. Gao J. Zhou Opt. Mater. 30 2008 1616 [15] C.Q. Zhu S.G. Xiao J.W. Ding X.L. Yang R.F. Qiang Mater. Sci. Eng. B 150 2008 95 [16] G.H. Lee T.H. Kim C. Yoon S. Kang J. Lumin. 128 2008 1922 [17] X.M. Lou D.H. Chen Mater. Lett. 62 2008 1681 [18] F. Lei B. Yan J. Solid State Chem. 181 2008 855 [19] F.B. Cao Y.W. Tian Y.J. Chen L.J. Xiao Q. Wu J. Lumin. 129 2009 585 [20] X.L. Zhang Z.S. Li H.T. Zhang S.X. Ouyang Z.G. Zou J. Alloys Compd. 469 2009 L6 [21] Q.Y. Shao H.J. Li K.W. Wu Y. Dong J.Q. Jiang J. Lumin. 129 2009 879 [22] Z.H. Ju R.P. Wei J.X. Ma C.R. Pang W.S. Liu J. Alloys Compd. 507 2010 133 [23] E. Grmen E. Daniels J.S. King J. Chem. Phys. 55 1971 1093 [24] J.K. Tyminski C.M. Lawson R.C. Powell J. Chem. Phys. 77 1982 4318 [25] H.M. Yang J.X. Shi H.B. Liang M.L. Gong Mater. Sci. Eng. B 127 2006 276 [26] J.P.M. Van Vliet G. Blasse L.H. Brixner J. Solid State Chem. 76 1988 160 [27] J.S. Yoo S.H. Kim W.T. Yoo G.Y. Hong K.P. Kim J. Rowland P.H. Holloway J. Electrochem. Soc. 152 2005 G382 [28] J.H. Ryu Y.G. Park H.S. Won S.H. Kim H. Suzuki J.M. Lee C. Yoon M. Nazarov D.Y. Noh B. Tsukerblatc J. Electrochem. Soc. 155 2008 J99