Memory Predictions are Influenced by Perceptual Information: Evidence for Metacognitive Illusions

Matthew G. Rhodes,A. Castel

Abstract:Although perceptual information can capture attention and is utilized when judging size or depth, little work has investigated whether such information is used to make memory predictions. The present study examined how the font size of to-be-remembered words influences predicted memory performance. Participants studied words for a later free recall test that varied in font size and made judgments of learning (JOLs) for each item. JOLs were influenced by font size, with larger font sizes given higher JOLs, whereas little relationship was evident between font size and recall. The effect was modified when other, more valid, sources of information (e.g., associative strength) were available when making JOLs, and persisted despite experience with multiple study-test sessions, using a forgetting scale to assess predictions, and explicitly warning participants that font size has little effect on memory performance. When ease of reading was manipulated, such that large font size words were made less fluent, the effect was eliminated. Thus, highly accessible perceptual cues can strongly influence JOLs, likely via encoding fluency, leading to metacognitive illusions.