On Pareto theory of circulation of elites

Ricardo Pérez-Marco

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1412.4695

2014-12-16

Abstract:We prove that Pareto theory of circulation of elites results from our wealth evolution model, Kelly criterion for optimal betting and Keynes' observation of "animal spirits" that drive the economy and cause that human financial decisions are prone to excess risk-taking.

General Finance,General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Kinetics of Wealth and the Origin of the Pareto Law

Bruce M. Boghosian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.89.042804

2013-08-20

Abstract:An important class of economic models involve agents whose wealth changes due to transactions with other agents. Several authors have pointed out an analogy with kinetic theory, which describes molecules whose momentum and energy changes due to interactions with other molecules. We pursue this analogy and derive a Boltzmann equation for the time evolution of the wealth distribution of a population of agents for the so-called Yard-Sale Model of wealth exchange. We examine the solutions to this equation by a combination of analytical and numerical methods, and investigate its long-time limit. We study an important limit of this equation for small transaction sizes, and derive a partial integrodifferential equation governing the evolution of the wealth distribution in a closed economy. We then describe how this model may be extended to include features such as inflation, production and taxation. In particular, we show that the model with taxation is capable of explaining the basic features of the Pareto law, namely a lower cutoff to the wealth density at small values of wealth, and approximate power-law behavior at large values of wealth.

Physics and Society,General Finance
Wealth condensation in a simple model of economy

Jean-Philippe Bouchaud,Marc Mezard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0002374

2000-02-24

Abstract:We introduce a simple model of economy, where the time evolution is described by an equation capturing both exchange between individuals and random speculative trading, in such a way that the fundamental symmetry of the economy under an arbitrary change of monetary units is insured. We investigate a mean-field limit of this equation and show that the distribution of wealth is of the Pareto (power-law) type. The Pareto behaviour of the tails of this distribution appears to be robust for finite range models, as shown using both a mapping to the random `directed polymer' problem, as well as numerical simulations. In this context, a transition between an economy dominated by a few individuals from a situation where the wealth is more evenly spread out, is found. An interesting outcome is that the distribution of wealth tends to be very broadly distributed when exchanges are limited, either in amplitude or topologically. Favoring exchanges (and, less surprisingly, increasing taxes) seems to be an efficient way to reduce inequalities.

Condensed Matter
Dynamics of Wealth Inequality

Zdzislaw Burda,Pawel Wojcieszak,Konrad Zuchniak

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crhy.2019.05.011

2019-06-05

Abstract:We study an agent-based model of evolution of wealth distribution in a macro-economic system. The evolution is driven by multiplicative stochastic fluctuations governed by the law of proportionate growth and interactions between agents. We are mainly interested in interactions increasing wealth inequality that is in a local implementation of the accumulated advantage principle. Such interactions destabilise the system. They are confronted in the model with a global regulatory mechanism which reduces wealth inequality. There are different scenarios emerging as a net effect of these two competing mechanisms. When the effect of the global regulation (economic interventionism) is too weak the system is unstable and it never reaches equilibrium. When the effect is sufficiently strong the system evolves towards a limiting stationary distribution with a Pareto tail. In between there is a critical phase. In this phase the system may evolve towards a steady state with a multimodal wealth distribution. The corresponding cumulative density function has a characteristic stairway pattern which reflects the effect of economic stratification. The stairs represent wealth levels of economic classes separated by wealth gaps. As we show, the pattern is typical for macro-economic systems with a limited economic freedom. One can find such a multimodal pattern in empirical data, for instance, in the highest percentile of wealth distribution for the population in urban areas of China.

Physics and Society,Statistical Mechanics,General Finance
Kinetic models for optimal control of wealth inequalities

Bertram Düring,Lorenzo Pareschi,Giuseppe Toscani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjb/e2018-90138-1

2018-07-27

Abstract:We introduce and discuss optimal control strategies for kinetic models for wealth distribution in a simple market economy, acting to minimize the variance of the wealth density among the population. Our analysis is based on a finite time horizon approximation, or model predictive control, of the corresponding control problem for the microscopic agents' dynamic and results in an alternative theoretical approach to the taxation and redistribution policy at a global level. It is shown that in general the control is able to modify the Pareto index of the stationary solution of the corresponding Boltzmann kinetic equation, and that this modification can be exactly quantified. Connections between previous Fokker-Planck based models and taxation-redistribution policies and the present approach are also discussed.

Physics and Society,General Economics,Optimization and Control,General Finance
How the rich get richer

Anita Mehta,A. S. Majumdar,J. M. Luck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0504121

2005-04-18

Abstract:In our model, $n$ traders interact with each other and with a central bank; they are taxed on the money they make, some of which is dissipated away by corruption. A generic feature of our model is that the richest trader always wins by 'consuming' all the others: another is the existence of a threshold wealth, below which all traders go bankrupt. The two-trader case is examined in detail,in the socialist and capitalist limits, which generalise easily to $n>2$. In its mean-field incarnation, our model exhibits a two-time-scale glassy dynamics, as well as an astonishing <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://universality.When" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> preference is given to local interactions in finite neighbourhoods,a novel feature emerges: instead of at most one overall winner in the system,finite numbers of winners emerge, each one the overlord of a particular <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://region.The" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> patterns formed by such winners (metastable states) are very much a consequence of initial conditions, so that the fate of the marketplace is ruled by its past history; hysteresis is thus also manifested.

Physics and Society,General Finance
A stylized model for wealth distribution

Bertram Düring,Nicos Georgiou,Enrico Scalas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1609.08978

2016-09-28

Probability

Abstract:The recent book by T. Piketty (Capital in the Twenty-First Century) promoted the important issue of wealth inequality. In the last twenty years, physicists and mathematicians developed models to derive the wealth distribution using discrete and continuous stochastic processes (random exchange models) as well as related Boltzmann-type kinetic equations. In this literature, the usual concept of equilibrium in Economics is either replaced or completed by statistical equilibrium. In order to illustrate this activity with a concrete example, we present a stylised random exchange model for the distribution of wealth. We first discuss a fully discrete version (a Markov chain with finite state space). We then study its discrete-time continuous-state-space version and we prove the existence of the equilibrium distribution. Finally, we discuss the connection of these models with Boltzmann-like kinetic equations for the marginal distribution of wealth. This paper shows in practice how it is possible to start from a finitary description and connect it to continuous models following Boltzmann's original research program.
Kinetic Models of Wealth Distribution Having Extreme Inequality: Numerical Study of Their Stability Against Random Exchanges

Asim Ghosh,Suchismita Banerjee,Sanchari Goswami,Manipushpak Mitra,Bikas K. Chakrabarti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e25071105

2023-07-24

Abstract:In view of some persistent recent reports on a singular kind of growth of the world wealth inequality, where a finite (often handful) number of people tend to possess more than the wealth of the planet's 50\% population, we explore here if the kinetic exchange models of the market can ever capture such features where a significant fraction of wealth can concentrate in the hands of a countable few when the market size $N$ tends to infinity. One already existing example of such a kinetic exchange model is the Chakraborti or Yard-Sale model, where (in absence of tax redistribution etc) the entire wealth condenses in the hand of one (for any value of $N$), and the market dynamics stops. With tax redistribution etc, its steady state dynamics have been shown to have remarkable applicability in many cases of our extremely unequal world. We show here that another kinetic exchange model (called here the Banerjee model) has intriguing intrinsic dynamics, by which only ten rich traders or agents possess about 99.98\% of the total wealth in the steady state (without any tax etc like external manipulation) for any large value of $N$. We will discuss in some detail the statistical features of this model using Monte Carlo simulations. We will also show, if the traders each have a non-vanishing probability $f$ of following random exchanges, then these condensations of wealth (100\% in the hand of one agent in the Chakraborti model, or about 99.98\% in the hands ten agents in the Banerjee model) disappear in the large $N$ limit. We will also see that due to the built-in possibility of random exchange dynamics in the earlier proposed Goswami-Sen model, where the exchange probability decreases with an inverse power of the wealth difference of the pair of traders, one did not see any wealth condensation phenomena.

Physics and Society
Left and right: a tale of two tails of the wealth distribution

Marcello D’Amato,Christian Di Pietro,Marco M. Sorge

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00199-024-01581-w

2024-06-16

Economic Theory

Abstract:We study a model of wealth accumulation in altruistic lineages, in which households face uninsurable risk, investment indivisibilities and borrowing constraints. A thick upper tail of the stationary distribution of wealth is shown to emerge as a robust prediction, irrespective of (1) the presence of multidimensional (wealth and ability) heterogeneity and non-convexities in human capital formation, and (2) the nature of parental bequest motives (joy-of-giving vs. paternalism). Additionally, (3) we identify conditions under which the unique, ergodic wealth distribution exhibits a mass point at the bottom of its support, where credit market imperfections continue to affect, along the convergence process, the structure of wealth transitions at the lineage level. Motivated by these results, we then analyze the sensitivity of the left tail to various frictions and fiscal instruments that affect bequest strategies and the ensuing transmission of wealth across generations. In particular, capital income or bequest taxes with no redistribution may reinforce economic mechanisms underpinning mobility traps in the left tail, thereby increasing the persistence of households in the lowest tiers of the wealth distribution.

economics
Inequalities of wealth distribution in a conservative economy

S. Pianegonda,J.R. Iglesias

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2004.04.078

2003-11-06

Abstract:We analyze a conservative market model for the competition among economic agents in a close society. A minimum dynamics ensures that the poorest agent has a chance to improve its economic welfare. After a transient, the system self-organizes into a critical state where the wealth distribution have a minimum threshold, with almost no agent below this poverty line, also, very few extremely rich agents are stable in time. Above the poverty line the distribution follows an exponential behavior. The local solution exhibits a low Gini index, while the mean field solution of the model generates a wealth distribution similar to welfare states like Sweden.

Statistical Mechanics,General Finance
Equal opportunities lead to maximum wealth inequality

Ben-Hur Francisco Cardoso,Sebastián Gonçalves,José Roberto Iglesias

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2201.05118

2022-01-20

Abstract:If wealthier people have advantages in having higher returns than poor, inequality will unequivocally increase, but is equal opportunity enough to prevent it? According to several models in economics and econophysics, no. They all display wealth concentration as a peculiar feature of its dynamics, even though no individual can have repeating gains advantage. Here, generalizing these particular models, we present a rigorous analytical demonstration, using master equation formalism, that any fair market that gives each agent the same expected return conducts the system to maximum inequality.

Statistical Mechanics
Piketty's second fundamental law of capitalism as an emergent property in a kinetic wealth-exchange model of economic growth

D. S. Quevedo,C. J. Quimbay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1903.00952

2019-03-06

Abstract:We propose in this work a kinetic wealth-exchange model of economic growth by introducing saving as a non consumed fraction of production. In this new model, which starts also from microeconomic arguments, it is found that economic transactions between pairs of agents leads the system to a macroscopic behavior where total wealth is not conserved and it is possible to have an economic growth which is assumed as the increasing of total production in time. This last macroeconomic result, that we find both numerically through a Monte Carlo based simulation method and analytically in the framework of a mean field approximation, corresponds to the economic growth scenario described by the well known Solow model developed in the economic neoclassical theory. If additionally to the income related with production due to return on individual capital, it is also included the individual labor income in the model, then the Thomas Piketty's second fundamental law of capitalism is found as a emergent property of the system. We consider that the results obtained in this paper shows how Econophysics can help to understand the connection between macroeconomics and microeconomics.

General Finance,Physics and Society
Emergent Statistical Wealth Distributions in Simple Monetary Exchange Models: A Critical Review

Thomas Lux

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cs/0506092

2005-06-25

Abstract:This paper reviews recent attempts at modelling inequality of wealth as an emergent phenomenon of interacting-agent processes. We point out that recent models of wealth condensation which draw their inspiration from molecular dynamics have, in fact, reinvented a process introduced quite some time ago by Angle (1986) in the sociological literature. We emphasize some problematic aspects of simple wealth exchange models and contrast them with a monetary model based on economic principles of market mediated exchange. The paper also reports new results on the influence of market power on the wealth distribution in statistical equilibrium. As it turns out, inequality increases but market power alone is not sufficient for changing the exponential tails of simple exchange models into Pareto tails.

Multiagent Systems
Wealth disparities and economic flow: Assessment using an asset exchange model with the surplus stock of the wealthy

Takeshi Kato,Yoshinori Hiroi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259323

2021-11-05

Abstract:How can we limit wealth disparities while stimulating economic flows in sustainable societies? To examine the link between these concepts, we propose an econophysics asset exchange model with the surplus stock of the wealthy. The wealthy are one of the two exchange agents and have more assets than the poor. Our simulation model converts the surplus contribution rate of the wealthy to a new variable parameter alongside the saving rate and introduces the total exchange (flow) and rank correlation coefficient (metabolism) as new evaluation indexes, adding to the Gini index (disparities), thereby assessing both wealth distribution and the relationships among the disparities, flow, and metabolism. We show that these result in a gamma-like wealth distribution, and our model reveals a trade-off between limiting disparities and vitalizing the market. To limit disparities and increase flow and metabolism, we also find the need to restrain savings and use the wealthy surplus stock. This relationship is explicitly expressed in the new equation introduced herein. The insights gained by uncovering the root of disparities may present a persuasive case for investments in social security measures or social businesses involving stock redistribution or sharing.

General Economics,Physics and Society
Capital risk, fiscal policy, and the distribution of wealth

Andrea Modena,Luca Regis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11579-024-00359-x

2024-03-23

Mathematics and Financial Economics

Abstract:We develop a dynamic model economy where self-employed entrepreneurs allocate their net worth to their firm capital and risk-less government bonds, facing borrowing constraints, uninsurable labour endowment and capital depreciation risk. We derive a numerical approximation of the model's equilibrium and compare it with a benchmark economy with no capital risk. Unlike labour endowment risk, capital risk reduces aggregate capital accumulation and wages and generates a positive risk premium. Low- (high-) net-worth entrepreneurs, whose consumption depends primarily on labour (financial) income, hold higher (lower) capital risk exposure. These patterns exacerbate inequality by increasing the share of financially constrained individuals and fattening the tails of the net worth distribution. Fiscal policy affects these outcomes by redistributing resources and affecting the risk premium. Capital tax cuts benefit more low- or high-net-worth entrepreneurs, depending on whether taxes on bonds or labour income finance them.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,business, finance
Optimal sharing, equilibria, and welfare without risk aversion

Jean-Gabriel Lauzier,Liyuan Lin,Ruodu Wang

2024-12-10

Abstract:We analyze Pareto optimality and competitive equilibria in a risk-exchange economy, where either all agents are risk seeking in an expected utility model, or they exhibit local risk-seeking behaviour in a rank-dependent utility model. A novel mathematical tool, the counter-monotonic improvement theorem, states that for any nonnegative allocation of the aggregate random payoff, there exists a counter-monotonic random vector, called a jackpot allocation, that is componentwise riskier than the original allocation, and thus preferred by risk-seeking agents. This result allows us to characterize Pareto optimality, the utility possibility frontier, and competitive equilibria with risk-seeking expected utility agents, and prove the first and second fundamental theorems of welfare economics in this setting. For rank-dependent utility agents that are neither risk averse or risk seeking, we show that jackpot allocations can be Pareto optimal for small-scale payoffs, but for large-scale payoffs they are dominated by proportional allocations, thus explaining the often-observed small-stake gambling behaviour in a risk sharing context. Such jackpot allocations are also equilibrium allocations for small-scale payoffs when there is no aggregate uncertainty.

Theoretical Economics,Risk Management
Wealth Inequality in a Low Rate Environment

Matthieu Gomez,Émilien Gouin‐Bonenfant,Émilien Gouin-Bonenfant

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3982/ecta19092

IF: 6.1

2024-01-31

Econometrica

Abstract:We study the effect of interest rates on wealth inequality. While lower rates decrease the growth rate of rentiers, they also increase the growth rate of entrepreneurs by making it cheaper to raise capital. To understand which effect dominates, we derive a sufficient statistic for the effect of interest rates on the Pareto exponent of the wealth distribution: it depends on the lifetime equity and debt issuance rate of individuals in the right tail of the wealth distribution. We estimate this sufficient statistic using new data on the trajectory of top fortunes in the U.S. Overall, we find that the secular decline in interest rates (or more generally of required rates of returns) can account for about 40% of the rise in Pareto inequality; that is, the degree to which the super rich pulled ahead relative to the rich.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,statistics & probability
A Chaotic Approach to Market Dynamics

Carmen Pellicer-Lostao,Ricardo Lopez-Ruiz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1008.0758

2010-08-04

Chaotic Dynamics

Abstract:Economy is demanding new models, able to understand and predict the evolution of markets. To this respect, Econophysics is offering models of markets as complex systems, such as the gas-like model, able to predict money distributions observed in real economies. However, this model reveals some technical hitches to explain the power law (Pareto) distribution, observed in individuals with high incomes. Here, non linear dynamics is introduced in the gas-like model. The results obtained demonstrate that a chaotic gas-like model can reproduce the two money distributions observed in real economies (Exponential and Pareto). Moreover, it is able to control the transition between them. This may give some insight of the micro-level causes that originate unfair distributions of money in a global society. Ultimately, the chaotic model makes obvious the inherent instability of asymmetric scenarios, where sinks of wealth appear in the market and doom it to complete inequality.
A family-network model for wealth distribution in societies

Ricardo Coelho,Zoltán Néda,José J. Ramasco,Maria Augusta Santos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2005.01.037

2005-08-01

Abstract:A model based on first-degree family relations network is used to describe the wealth distribution in societies. The network structure is not a priori introduced in the model, it is generated in parallel with the wealth values through simple and realistic dynamical rules. The model has two main parameters, governing the wealth exchange in the network. Choosing their values realistically, leads to wealth distributions in good agreement with measured data. The cumulative wealth distribution function has an exponential behavior in the low and medium wealth limit, and shows the Pareto-like power-law tail for the upper 5% of the society. The obtained Pareto indexes are in good agreement with the measured ones. The generated family networks also converge to a statistically stable topology with a simple Poissonian degree distribution. On this family network many interesting correlations are studied, and the main factors leading to wealth diversification and the formation of the Pareto law are identified.
Inequality reversal: effects of the savings propensity and correlated returns

Anindya S. Chakrabarti,Bikas K. Chakrabarti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2010.04.038

2010-05-20

Abstract:In the last decade, a large body of literature has been developed to explain the universal features of inequality in terms of income and wealth. By now, it is established that the distributions of income and wealth in various economies show a number of statistical regularities. There are several models to explain such static features of inequality in an unifying framework and the kinetic exchange models, in particular, provide one such framework. Here we focus on the dynamic features of inequality. In the process of development and growth, inequality in an economy in terms of income and wealth follows a particular pattern of rising in the initial stage followed by an eventual fall. This inverted U-shaped curve is known as the Kuznets Curve. We examine the possibilities of such behavior of an economy in the context of a generalized kinetic exchange model. It is shown that under some specific conditions, our model economy indeed shows inequality reversal.

General Finance
A Statistical Model of Inequality

Ricardo T. Fernholz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1601.04093

2016-01-15

ECONOMICS

Abstract:This paper develops a nonparametric statistical model of wealth distribution that imposes little structure on the fluctuations of household wealth. In this setting, we use new techniques to obtain a closed-form household-by-household characterization of the stable distribution of wealth and show that this distribution is shaped entirely by two factors - the reversion rates (a measure of cross-sectional mean reversion) and idiosyncratic volatilities of wealth across different ranked households. By estimating these factors, our model can exactly match the U.S. wealth distribution. This provides information about the current trajectory of inequality as well as estimates of the distributional effects of progressive capital taxes. We find evidence that the U.S. wealth distribution might be on a temporarily unstable trajectory, thus suggesting that further increases in top wealth shares are likely in the near future. For capital taxes, we find that a small tax levied on just 1% of households substantially reshapes the distribution of wealth and reduces inequality.

On Pareto theory of circulation of elites

The Kinetics of Wealth and the Origin of the Pareto Law

Wealth condensation in a simple model of economy

Dynamics of Wealth Inequality

Kinetic models for optimal control of wealth inequalities

How the rich get richer

A stylized model for wealth distribution

Kinetic Models of Wealth Distribution Having Extreme Inequality: Numerical Study of Their Stability Against Random Exchanges

Left and right: a tale of two tails of the wealth distribution

Inequalities of wealth distribution in a conservative economy

Equal opportunities lead to maximum wealth inequality

Piketty's second fundamental law of capitalism as an emergent property in a kinetic wealth-exchange model of economic growth

Emergent Statistical Wealth Distributions in Simple Monetary Exchange Models: A Critical Review

Wealth disparities and economic flow: Assessment using an asset exchange model with the surplus stock of the wealthy

Capital risk, fiscal policy, and the distribution of wealth

Optimal sharing, equilibria, and welfare without risk aversion

Wealth Inequality in a Low Rate Environment

A Chaotic Approach to Market Dynamics

A family-network model for wealth distribution in societies

Inequality reversal: effects of the savings propensity and correlated returns

A Statistical Model of Inequality