Abstract:Notions of community quality underlie network clustering. While studies surrounding network clustering are increasingly common, a precise understanding of the realtionship between different cluster quality metrics is unknown. In this paper, we examine the relationship between stand-alone cluster quality metrics and information recovery metrics through a rigorous analysis of four widely-used network clustering algorithms -- Louvain, Infomap, label propagation, and smart local moving. We consider the stand-alone quality metrics of modularity, conductance, and coverage, and we consider the information recovery metrics of adjusted Rand score, normalized mutual information, and a variant of normalized mutual information used in previous work. Our study includes both synthetic graphs and empirical data sets of sizes varying from 1,000 to 1,000,000 nodes. We find significant differences among the results of the different cluster quality metrics. For example, clustering algorithms can return a value of 0.4 out of 1 on modularity but score 0 out of 1 on information recovery. We find conductance, though imperfect, to be the stand-alone quality metric that best indicates performance on information recovery metrics. Our study shows that the variant of normalized mutual information used in previous work cannot be assumed to differ only slightly from traditional normalized mutual information. Smart local moving is the best performing algorithm in our study, but discrepancies between cluster evaluation metrics prevent us from declaring it absolutely superior. Louvain performed better than Infomap in nearly all the tests in our study, contradicting the results of previous work in which Infomap was superior to Louvain. We find that although label propagation performs poorly when clusters are less clearly defined, it scales efficiently and accurately to large graphs with well-defined clusters.

Generalization of Clustering Agreements and Distances for Overlapping Clusters and Network Communities

Geometrical inspired pre-weighting enhances Markov clustering community detection in complex networks

An empirical comparison of connectivity-based distances on a graph and their computational scalability

Analysis of Network Clustering Algorithms and Cluster Quality Metrics at Scale

Distributed Information Theoretic Clustering

An Investigation into Distance Measures in Cluster Analysis

A Novel Clustering Oriented Closeness Measure Based on Neighborhood Chain

A New Measurement of Similarity and Related Clustering Algorithm

Automatic Recommendation of a Distance Measure for Clustering Algorithms

Hierarchical Clustering Given Confidence Intervals of Metric Distances

Measuring the Clustering Strength of a Network via the Normalized Clustering Coefficient

A Statistical Information-Based Clustering Approach in Distance Space

Distributed Clustering Algorithm in Sensor Networks Via Normalized Information Measures

Overlapping communities detection based on cluster-ability optimization

Quantifying Distances Between Clusters with Elliptical or Non-Elliptical Shapes

On Clustering Time Series Using Euclidean Distance and Pearson Correlation

Measuring Unequal Knowledge Distance by Network Embedding and Multiple Relationships

Data Clustering: Integrating Different Distance Measures with Modified k-Means Algorithm

Clustering Based on Pairwise Distances When the Data is of Mixed Dimensions

A Clustering-Oriented Closeness Measure Based on Neighborhood Chain and Its Application in the Clustering Ensemble Framework Based on the Fusion of Different Closeness Measures.

Adjusting for Chance Clustering Comparison Measures