Abstract:The combination of a time reversible Markov process with a 'hidden' mixture of gamma distributed relative site rates plus invariant sites have become the most favoured options for likelihood and other probabilistic models of nucleotide evolution (e.g., tr4gi which approximates a gamma with four rate classes). However, these models assume a homogeneous and stationary distribution of nucleotide (character or base) frequencies. Here, we explore the potential benefits and pitfalls of allowing each rate category (rate class) of a 4gi mixture model to have its own base frequencies. This is achieved by starting each of the five rate classes, at the tree's root, with its own free choice of nucleotide frequencies to create a 4gi5rf model or a 5rf model in shorthand We assess the practical identifiability of this approach with a BEAST 2 implementation, aiming to determine if it can accurately estimate credibility intervals and expected values for a wide range of plausible parameter values. Practical identifiability, as distinguished from mathematical identifiability, gauges the model's ability to identify parameters in real-world scenarios, as opposed to theoretically with infinite data. One of the most common types of phylogenetic data is mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) protein coding sequence. It is often assumed current models analyse robustly such data and that higher likelihood/posterior probability models do better. However, this abstract shows that vertebrate mtDNA remains a very difficult type of data to fully model, and that dramatically higher likelihoods do not mean a model is measurably more accurate with respect to recovering key parameters of biological interest (e.g., monophyletic groups, their support and their ages). The 4gi5rf model considerably improves marginal likelihoods and seems to reverse some apparent errors exacerbated by the 4gi model, while introducing others. Problems appear to be linked to non-stationary DNA repair processes that alter the mutation/substitution spectra across lineages and time. We also show such problems are not unique to mtDNA and are encountered in analysing nuclear sequences. Non-stationarity of DNA repair processes mutation/substitution spectra thus pose an active challenge to obtaining reliable inferences of relationships and divergence times near the root of placental mammals, for example. An open source implementation is available under the LGPL 3.0 license in the beastbooster package for BEAST 2, available from https://github.com/rbouckaert/beastbooster.

A new hierarchy of phylogenetic models consistent with heterogeneous substitution rates

Lie Markov models with purine/pyrimidine symmetry

Evaluation of the Models Handling Heterotachy in Phylogenetic Inference

An independent base composition of each rate class for improved likelihood-based phylogeny estimation: The 5rf model

Evaluation of Ancestral Sequence Reconstruction Methods to Infer Nonstationary Patterns of Nucleotide Substitution

Modeling Substitution Rate Evolution across Lineages and Relaxing the Molecular Clock

Statistical tests of models of DNA substitution

Random-effects substitution models for phylogenetics via scalable gradient approximations

Evolutionary Shortcuts via Multinucleotide Substitutions and Their Impact on Natural Selection Analyses

MODELTEST: testing the model of DNA substitution

A dirichlet process covarion mixture model and its assessments using posterior predictive discrepancy tests.

Infinite Mixture Models for Improved Modeling of Across-Site Evolutionary Variation

Bayesian inference of phylogenetic distances: revisiting the eigenvalue approach

Dynamic Programming Procedure for Searching Optimal Models to Estimate Substitution Rates Based on the Maximum-Likelihood Method

Complex Models of Sequence Evolution Improve Fit, but not Gene Tree Discordance, for Tetrapod Mitogenomes

Genetic Distance for a General Non-Stationary Markov Substitution Process

PhyloAcc-GT: A Bayesian method for inferring patterns of substitution rate shifts on targeted lineages accounting for gene tree discordance

Site-specific structure and stability constrained substitution models improve phylogenetic inference

bModelTest: Bayesian phylogenetic site model averaging and model comparison

The Prevalence and Impact of Model Violations in Phylogenetic Analysis

A new formulation of protein evolutionary models that account for structural constraints