Detections of trans-Neptunian ice in protoplanetary disks

M. K. McClure,C. Espaillat,N. Calvet,E. Bergin,P. D'Alessio,D. M. Watson,P. Manoj,B. Sargent,L. I. Cleeves

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/799/2/162

2014-11-27

Abstract:We present Herschel Space Observatory PACS spectra of T Tauri stars, in which we detect amorphous and crystalline water ice features. Using irradiated accretion disk models, we determine the disk structure and ice abundance in each of the systems. Combining a model-independent comparison of the ice feature strength and disk size with a detailed analysis of the model ice location, we estimate that the ice emitting region is at disk radii >30AU, consistent with a proto-Kuiper belt. Vertically, the ice emits most below the photodesorption zone, consistent with Herschel observations of cold water vapor. The presence of crystallized water ice at a disk location a) colder than its crystallization temperature and b) where it should have been re-amorphized in ~1 Myr suggests that localized generation is occurring; the most likely cause appears to be micrometeorite impact or planetesimal collisions. Based on simple tests with UV models and different ice distributions, we suggest that the SED shape from 20 to 50 micron may probe the location of the water ice snow line in the disk upper layers. This project represents one of the first extra-solar probes of the spatial structure of the cometary ice reservoir thought to deliver water to terrestrial planets.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the distribution and properties of water ice in regions similar to the Kuiper Belt outside the solar system by studying the characteristics of water ice in protoplanetary disks. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Location of Water Ice in Protoplanetary Disks**:
- Determine the radial and vertical distribution of water ice in protoplanetary disks.
- Estimate whether the water ice emission region is located in areas greater than 30 astronomical units (AU), consistent with the location of the original Kuiper Belt.

2. **Crystalline State of Water Ice**:
- Investigate why crystalline water ice is detected in some disks where the temperature is below its crystallization temperature and theoretically should have reverted to an amorphous state.
- Analyze possible mechanisms, such as micrometeoroid impacts or asteroid collisions, to explain the presence of crystalline water ice.

3. **Photodesorption Effects on Water Ice**:
- Evaluate the photodesorption effect of far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation on water ice and how this effect influences the distribution of water ice.
- Explore the regeneration mechanisms of water ice below the photodesorption layer.

4. **Location of the Water Ice Snow Line**:
- Determine the specific location of the water ice snow line in the upper layers of the disk by analyzing the spectral energy distribution (SED) in the 20 to 50-micron range.

### Main Methods and Findings

- **Observational Data**:
- Using the PACS instrument on the Herschel Space Observatory, observations were made of protoplanetary disks around T Tauri stars.
- Characteristics of both amorphous and crystalline water ice were detected.

- **Model Analysis**:
- Utilizing irradiated accretion disk models to determine the structure of the disk and the abundance of water ice.
- By comparing the intensity of ice features and the size of the disk, combined with detailed model analysis, the location of the water ice emission region was estimated.

- **Main Findings**:
- The water ice emission region is primarily located in areas with a disk radius greater than 30 AU, consistent with the expected location of the original Kuiper Belt.
- Crystalline water ice exists in regions with temperatures below its crystallization temperature, indicating possible local generation mechanisms such as micrometeoroid impacts or asteroid collisions.
- The shape of the SED in the 20 to 50-micron range may be used to detect the location of the water ice snow line in the upper layers of the disk.

Through these studies, the paper provides important clues for understanding the origin and distribution of water on terrestrial planets outside the solar system.