Abstract:Science advances by pushing the boundaries of the adjacent possible. While the global scientific enterprise grows at an exponential pace, at the mesoscopic level the exploration and exploitation of research ideas are reflected through the rise and fall of research fields. The empirical literature has largely studied such dynamics on a case-by-case basis, with a focus on explaining how and why communities of knowledge production evolve. Although fields rise and fall on different temporal and population scales, they are generally argued to pass through a common set of evolutionary stages. To understand the social processes that drive these stages beyond case studies, we need a way to quantify and compare different fields on the same terms. In this paper we develop techniques for identifying common patterns in the evolution of scientific fields and demonstrate their usefulness using 1.5 million preprints from the arXiv repository covering 175 research fields spanning Physics, Mathematics, Computer Science, Quantitative Biology and Quantitative Finance. We show that fields consistently follow a rise and fall pattern captured by a two parameters right-tailed Gumbel temporal distribution. We introduce a field-specific re-scaled time and explore the generic properties shared by articles and authors at the creation, adoption, peak, and decay evolutionary phases. We find that the early phase of a field is characterized by disruptive works mixing of cognitively distant fields written by small teams of interdisciplinary authors, while late phases exhibit the role of specialized, large teams building on the previous works in the field. This method provides foundations to quantitatively explore the generic patterns underlying the evolution of research fields in science, with general implications in innovation studies.

A simple interpretation of the growth of scientific/technological research impact leading to hype-type evolution curves

The role of expectation in innovation evolution: Exploring hype cycles

Technological Growth and Asset Pricing

Growth rates of modern science: a latent piecewise growth curve approach to model publication numbers from established and new literature databases

The Rise and Fall of Ideas' Popularity

The Schumpeterian Growth Theory:A Survey

A Growth Model with Endogenous Technological Revolutions and Cycles

Innovation or imitation: The diffusion of citations.

Innovation and imitation

Evolutionary Model of the Growth and Size of Firms

Modelling the growth of the network value

Data-Driven Investment Decision-Making: Applying Moore's Law and S-Curves to Business Strategies

Navigating the hype wave: a generalized economic-mathematical model for managing socio-economic processes in the neural-network economy

An Empirical Model of Growth Through Product Innovation

Modeling of technological performance trends using design theory

Physical modelling of global macrosystems evolution

Quantifying the rise and fall of scientific fields.

Dynamics of technology emergence in innovation networks

Chain reaction of ideas: Can radioactive decay predict technological innovation?

Understanding the Diffusion of Mobile Digital Content: a Growth Curve Modelling Approach

Model-based evaluation of scientific impact indicators