Abstract:Variance-based sensitivity indices have established themselves as a reference among practitioners of sensitivity analysis of model outputs. A variance-based sensitivity analysis typically produces the first-order sensitivity indices $S_j$ and the so-called total-effect sensitivity indices $T_j$ for the uncertain factors of the mathematical model under analysis. The cost of the analysis depends upon the number of model evaluations needed to obtain stable and accurate values of the estimates. While efficient estimation procedures are available for $S_j$, this availability is less the case for $T_j$. When estimating these indices, one can either use a sample-based approach whose computational cost depends on the number of factors or use approaches based on meta modelling/emulators. The present work focuses on sample-based estimation procedures for $T_j$ and tests different avenues to achieve an algorithmic improvement over the existing best practices. To improve the exploration of the space of the input factors (design) and the formula to compute the indices (estimator), we propose strategies based on the concepts of economy and explorativity. We then discuss how several existing estimators perform along these characteristics. We conclude that: a) sample-based approaches based on the use of multiple matrices to enhance the economy are outperformed by designs using fewer matrices but with better explorativity; b) among the latter, asymmetric designs perform the best and outperform symmetric designs having corrective terms for spurious correlations; c) improving on the existing best practices is fraught with difficulties; and d) ameliorating the results comes at the cost of introducing extra design parameters.

On the consistency of Sobol indices with respect to stochastic ordering of model parameters

Hessian and increasing-Hessian orderings of scale-shape mixtures of multivariate skew-normal distributions and applications

Robustness of the Sobol' indices to marginal distribution uncertainty

Risk of estimators for Sobol' sensitivity indices based on metamodels

Stochastic ordering of variability measure estimators

Regularizing nested Monte Carlo Sobol' index estimators to balance the trade-off between explorations and repetitions in global sensitivity analysis of stochastic models

Test comparison for Sobol Indices over nested sets of variables

Variance components and generalized Sobol' indices

Sobol' indices for problems defined in non-rectangular domains

Computing Sobol indices in probabilistic graphical models

Calculations of Sobol indices for the Gaussian process metamodel

Global sensitivity analysis using derivative-based sparse Poincaré chaos expansions

A comparison between Sobol's indices and Shapley's effect for global sensitivity analysis of systems with independent input variables

Variance-based sensitivity analysis: The quest for better estimators and designs between explorativity and economy

Information Order in Monotone Decision Problems under Uncertainty

On partial stochastic comparisons based on tail values at risk

A note on the Sobol' indices and interactive criteria

Reliability-oriented global sensitivity analysis using subset simulation and space partition

Stochastic Somparisons of Order Statistics from Scaled and Interdependent Random Variables

Derivative based global sensitivity analysis and its entropic link

Asymptotic normality of a Sobol index estimator in Gaussian process regression framework