Abstract:The occurrences of collective quantum states, such as superconductivity (SC) and charge- or spin-densitywaves (CDWs or SDWs), are among the most fascinating phenomena in solids. To date much effort has been made to explore the interplay between different orders, yet little is known about the relationship of multiple orders of the same type. Here we report optical spectroscopy study on CDWs in the rare-earth tri-telluride compounds RTe3 (R = rare earth elements). Besides the prior reported two CDW orders, the study reveals unexpectedly the presence of a third CDW order in the series which evolves systematically with the size of R element. With increased chemical pressure, the first and third CDW orders are both substantially suppressed and compete with the second one by depleting the low energy spectral weight. A complete phase diagram for the multiple CDW orders in this series is established.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to study the coexistence and competition of multiple charge density wave (CDW) states in rare-earth tri-telluride (RTe₃). Specifically: 1. **Background Issue**: The charge density wave (CDW) state is one of the most actively researched phenomena in condensed matter physics, particularly the CDW formation mechanism driven by Fermi surface (FS) nesting. RTe₃ compounds, due to their layered structure and two-dimensional electronic properties, have become an ideal model system for studying this nesting-driven CDW. 2. **Research Findings**: Through optical spectroscopy studies, the authors discovered three different CDW states in the RTe₃ series of compounds. In addition to the two previously known CDW states, they unexpectedly revealed the existence of a third CDW state. These three states exhibit systematic evolution with changes in the radius of the rare-earth elements, and the first and third CDW states cooperate with each other while jointly competing with the second CDW state for low-energy spectral weight. 3. **Core Contribution**: Through detailed experimental measurements and data analysis, the authors constructed a complete multi-CDW phase diagram, showing how these states evolve with chemical pressure changes, and proposed that the third CDW state may originate from bilayer splitting. In summary, this paper reveals the complex relationship between three CDW states through in-depth optical spectroscopy studies of the RTe₃ series of compounds, providing new perspectives for further understanding multiple CDW states in such materials.

Coexistence and competition of multiple charge-density-wave orders in rare-earth tri-telluride RTe3