Abstract:Historian Herbert Mehrtens sought to portray the history of turn-of-the-century mathematics as a struggle of modern vs countermodern, led respectively by David Hilbert and Felix Klein. Some of Mehrtens' conclusions have been picked up by both historians (Jeremy Gray) and mathematicians (Frank Quinn). We argue that Klein and Hilbert, both at Goettingen, were not adversaries but rather modernist allies in a bid to broaden the scope of mathematics beyond a narrow focus on arithmetized analysis as practiced by the Berlin school. Klein's Goettingen lecture and other texts shed light on Klein's modernism. Hilbert's views on intuition are closer to Klein's views than Mehrtens is willing to allow. Klein and Hilbert were equally interested in the axiomatisation of physics. Among Klein's credits is helping launch the career of Abraham Fraenkel, and advancing the careers of Sophus Lie, Emmy Noether, and Ernst Zermelo, all four surely of impeccable modernist credentials. Mehrtens' unsourced claim that Hilbert was interested in production rather than meaning appears to stem from Mehrtens' marxist leanings. Mehrtens' claim that [the future SS-Brigadefuehrer] "Theodor Vahlen ... cited Klein's racist distinctions within mathematics, and sharpened them into open antisemitism" fabricates a spurious continuity between the two figures mentioned and is thus an odious misrepresentation of Klein's position. Keywords: arithmetized analysis; axiomatisation of geometry; axiomatisation of physics; formalism; intuition; mathematical realism; modernism; Felix Klein; David Hilbert; Karl Weierstrass

On the origin of Hilbert Geometry

Hilbert, logicism, and mathematical existence

On incomplete lattice homomorphisms in subspaces of geometries: "half" a problem of Hartmanis from 1959

On Hilbert's gravitational repulsion (A historical Note)

A Survey of the Development of Geometry up to 1870

Hilbert's Program Then and Now

Geometry of Singular Space

On the Hilbert Geometry of Convex Polytopes

Einstein on Involutions in Projective Geometry

Geometry in the twentieth century: A return to Euclid -- The work of Herbert Busemann

Dynamics of Hilbert nonexpansive maps

An elementary proof of Hilbert's theorem on ternary quartics: Some complements

On the Hilbert matrix operator: a brief survey

A specific model of Hilbert geometry on the unit disc

Finitude géométrique en géométrie de Hilbert + an erratum/addendum

Hilbert Schemes, Donaldson-Thomas Theory, Vafa-Witten and Seiberg Witten theories

How Logic Interacts with Geometry: Infinitesimal Curvature of Categorical Spaces

The geometry of double nested Hilbert schemes of points on curves

Around Hilbert's theorem: the center of a circle is not constructible by straightedge alone

Kleinian singularities: some geometry, combinatorics and representation theory

Klein vs Mehrtens: restoring the reputation of a great modern