Uniqueness of photon spheres in static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes

Carla Cederbaum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1406.5475

2014-09-04

Abstract:Adapting Israel's proof of static black hole uniqueness, we show that the Schwarzschild spacetime is the only static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetime that possesses a suitably defined photon sphere.

Differential Geometry,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Analysis of PDEs

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Uniqueness of the static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes with massive particle spheres

Kirill Kobialko,Igor Bogush,Dmitri Gal'tsov

2024-06-21

Abstract:In this paper, we establish that a four-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetime containing a massive particle sphere is isometric to the Schwarzschild spacetime. Our results expand upon existing uniqueness theorems for static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes, which focus on scenarios featuring event horizons or photon spheres. Similarly to the uniqueness theorems concerning photon spheres or event horizons, only a single massive particle sphere is sufficient to obtain a unique solution. However, in contrast to previous theorems, our result leads to the existence of an entire spacetime foliation sliced by a set of massive particle spheres spanning various energies.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Uniqueness of photon sphere for Reissner-Nordström electric-magnetic system

Marek Rogatko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.109.024056

2024-01-25

Abstract:Uniqueness of static, asymptotically flat, non-extremal {\it photon sphere} in Einstein-Maxwell spacetime with electric and magnetic charges has been proved. Using conformal positive energy theorem, as well as, the positive mass theorem and adequate conformal transformations, we envisage the two alternative ways of proving that the exterior region of a certain radius of the studied static {\it photon sphere}, is characterized by ADM mass, electric and magnetic charges.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Uniqueness of equipotential photon surfaces in 4-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes for positive, negative, and zero mass -- and a new partial proof of the Willmore inequality

Carla Cederbaum,Albachiara Cogo,Axel Fehrenbach

2024-10-07

Abstract:We present different proofs of the uniqueness of 4-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes containing a connected equipotential photon surface or in particular a connected photon sphere. We do not assume that the equipotential photon surface is outward directed or non-degenerate and hence cover not only the positive but also the negative and the zero mass case which has not yet been treated in the literature. Our results partially reproduce and extend beyond results by Cederbaum and by Cederbaum and Galloway. In the positive and negative mass cases, we give three proofs which are based on the approaches to proving black hole uniqueness by Israel, Robinson, and Agostiniani--Mazzieri, respectively. In the zero mass case, we give four proofs. One is based on the positive mass theorem, the second one is inspired by Israel's approach and in particular leads to a new proof of the Willmore inequality in $(\mathbb{R}^3, \delta)$, under a technical assumption. The remaining two proofs are inspired by proofs of the Willmore inequality by Cederbaum and Miehe and by Agostiniani and Mazzieri, respectively. In particular, this suggests to view the Willmore inequality and its rigidity case as a zero mass version of equipotential photon surface uniqueness.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Differential Geometry
Black Hole and Equipotential Photon Surface Uniqueness in 4-dimensional Asymptotically Flat Electrostatic Electro-Vacuum Spacetimes

Stefano Borghini,Carla Cederbaum,Albachiara Cogo

2024-01-11

Abstract:We study 4-dimensional asymptotically flat electrostatic electro-vacuum spacetimes with a connected black hole, photon sphere, or equipotential photon surface inner boundary. Our analysis, inspired by the potential theory approach by Agostiniani-Mazzieri, allows to give self-contained proofs of known uniqueness theorems of the sub-extremal, extremal and super-extremal Reissner-Nordström spacetimes. We also obtain new results for connected photon spheres and for connected photon surfaces in the extremal case. Finally, we provide, up to a restriction on the range of their radii, the uniqueness result for connected (both non-degenerate and degenerate) photon surfaces in the super-extremal case, not yet treated in the literature.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Differential Geometry
Photon surfaces as pure tension shells: Uniqueness of thin shell wormholes

Yasutaka Koga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.101.104022

2020-06-26

Abstract:Thin shell wormholes are constructed by joining two asymptotically flat spacetimes along their inner boundaries. The junction conditions imposed on the spacetimes specify the equation of state of the matter called thin shell distributed along the joined boundaries. Barcelo and Visser (2000) reported that spherically symmetric thin shell wormholes have their shells, namely the wormhole throats, on the photon spheres if the wormholes are $Z_2$-symmetric across the throats and the shells are of pure tension. In this paper, first, we consider general joined spacetimes (JSTs) and show that any $Z_2$-symmetric pure-tensional JST (Z2PTJST) of $\Lambda$-vacuum has its shell on a photon surface, a generalized object of photon spheres, without assuming any other symmetries. The class of Z2PTJSTs also includes, for example, brane world models with the shells being the branes we live in. Second, we investigate the shell stability of Z2PTJSTs by analyzing the stability of the corresponding photon surfaces. Finally, applying the uniqueness theorem of photon spheres by Cederbaum (2015), we establish the uniqueness theorem of static wormholes of Z2PTJST.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,High Energy Physics - Theory
The Existence and Distribution of Photon Spheres Near Spherically Symmetric Black Holes -- A Geometric Analysis

Chen-Kai Qiao

2024-08-02

Abstract:Photon sphere has attracted significant attention since the discovery of black hole shadow images by Event Horizon Telescope. Recently, a number of studies have highlighted that the number of photon spheres and their distributions near black holes are strongly constrained by black hole properties. Specifically, for black holes with event horizons and proper asymptotic behaviors, the number of stable and unstable photon spheres satisfies the relation $n_{\text{stable}} - n_{\text{unstable}} = -1$. In this study, we provide a novel proof on this relation using a completely new geometric approach, in which the stable and unstable photon spheres are determined by Gaussian curvature and geodesic curvature in the optical geometry of black hole spacetimes. Firstly, we demonstrated the existence of photon spheres near black holes with proper asymptotic behaviors (asymptotically flat black holes, asymptotically de-Sitter and anti-de-Sitter black holes). Subsequently, we proved that the stable and unstable photon spheres near black holes must be one-to-one alternatively separated from each other, such that each unstable photon sphere is sandwiched between two stable photon spheres (and each stable photon sphere is sandwiched between two unstable photon spheres). Our analysis in this study is limited to the spherically symmetric black hole spacetime (with the spacetime metric $ds^{2}=g_{tt}dt^{2}+g_{rr}dr^{2}+g_{\theta\theta}d\theta^{2}+g_{\phi\phi}d\phi^{2}$).

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Mathematical Physics
On equipotential photon surfaces in (electro-)static spacetimes of arbitrary dimension

Carla Cederbaum,Sophia Jahns,Olivia Vičánek Martínez

2023-11-29

Abstract:We study timelike, totally umbilic hypersurfaces -- called photon surfaces -- in $n+1$-dimensional static, asymptotically flat spacetimes, for $n+1\geq4$. First, we give a complete characterization of photon surfaces in a class of spherically symmetric spacetimes containing the (exterior) subextremal Reissner--Nordström spacetimes, and hence in particular the (exterior) positive mass Schwarzschild spacetimes. Next, we give new insights into the spacetime geometry near equipotential photon surfaces and provide a new characterization of photon spheres (not appealing to any field equations). We furthermore show that any asymptotically flat electrostatic electro-vacuum spacetime with inner boundary consisting of equipotential, (quasi-locally) subextremal photon surfaces and/or non-degenerate black hole horizons must be isometric to a suitable piece of the necessarily subextremal Reissner--Norström spacetime of the same mass and charge. Our uniqueness result applies work by Jahns and extends and complements several existing uniqueness theorems. Its proof fundamentally relies on the lower regularity rigidity case of the Riemannian Positive Mass Theorem.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Differential Geometry
Uniqueness of the extremal Schwarzschild de Sitter spacetime

David Katona,James Lucietti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11005-023-01761-0

2024-01-19

Abstract:We prove that any analytic vacuum spacetime with a positive cosmological constant in four and higher dimensions, that contains a static extremal Killing horizon with a maximally symmetric compact cross-section, must be locally isometric to either the extremal Schwarzschild de Sitter solution or its near-horizon geometry (the Nariai solution). In four-dimensions, this implies these solutions are the only analytic vacuum spacetimes that contain a static extremal horizon with compact cross-sections (up to identifications). We also consider the analogous uniqueness problem for the four-dimensional extremal hyperbolic Schwarzschild anti-de Sitter solution and show that it reduces to a spectral problem for the laplacian on compact hyperbolic surfaces, if a cohomological obstruction to the uniqueness of infinitesimal transverse deformations of the horizon is absent.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory,Differential Geometry
Uniqueness of static vacuum asymptotically flat black holes and equipotential photon surfaces in $n+1$ dimensions à la Robinson

Carla Cederbaum,Albachiara Cogo,Benedito Leandro,João Paulo dos Santos

2024-03-21

Abstract:In this paper, we generalize to higher dimensions Robinson's approach to proving the uniqueness of connected $(3+1)$-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat black hole spacetimes. In consequence, we prove geometric inequalities for connected $(n+1)$-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat black holes, recovering results by Agostiniani and Mazzieri. We also obtain similar geometric inequalities for connected $(n+1)$-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat equipotential photon surfaces and in particular photon spheres. Assuming a natural upper bound on the total scalar curvature, we recover the well-known uniqueness results for such black holes and equipotential photon surfaces. We also extend the known equipotential photon surface uniqueness results to spacetimes with negative mass. In order to replace the role of the Cotton tensor in Robinson's proof, we introduce techniques inspired by the analysis of Ricci solitons.

Differential Geometry,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Uniqueness of the AdS Spacetime among Static Vacua with prescribed Null infinity

Oussama Hijazi,Sebastián Montiel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1211.5651

2012-11-24

Abstract:We prove that an $(n+1)$-dimensional spin static vacuum with negative cosmological constant whose null infinity has a boundary admitting a non-trivial Killing spinor field is the AdS spacetime. As a consequence, we generalize previous uniqueness results by X. Wang \cite{Wa2} and by Chru{ś}ciel-Herzlich \cite{CH} and introduce, for this class of spin static vacua, some Lorentzian manifolds which are prohibited as null infinities.

Differential Geometry
Black holes with multiple photon spheres

Guangzhou Guo,Yuhang Lu,Peng Wang,Houwen Wu,Haitang Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.107.124037

IF: 5.407

2023-06-17

Physical Review D

Abstract:Recently, asymptotically flat black holes with multiple photon spheres have been discovered and found to produce distinctive observational signatures. In this paper, we focus on whether these black hole solutions are physically viable, e.g., satisfying energy conditions of interest. Intriguingly, black hole and naked singularity solutions with two photon spheres and one antiphoton sphere are shown to exist in physically reasonable models, which satisfy the null, weak, dominant and strong energy conditions. Our findings reveal that black holes with multiple photon spheres may not be frequent, but they are not exotic. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.107.124037 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields
Dynamical photon spheres in charged black holes and naked singularities

Vertogradov, Vitalii

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-024-12945-w

IF: 4.991

2024-06-07

The European Physical Journal C

Abstract:To understand the nature of a black hole shadow in dynamical spacetimes, we construct an analytical model of a dynamical photon sphere in the context of the Bonnor–Vaidya spacetime. Comparing the resulting photon sphere radius with the one in Vaidya spacetime, we find that the charge always decreases the radius of the photon sphere. We also prove that a naked singularity in Bonnor–Vaidya spacetime, unlike the static Reissner–Nordstrom naked singularity, may cast a shadow, and as a result, it cannot be distinguished from a black hole through its shadow.

physics, particles & fields
Black hole horizons must be veiled by photon spheres

Raúl Carballo-Rubio,Astrid Eichhorn

2024-05-15

Abstract:Horizons and bound photon orbits are defining features of black holes that translate into key features of black hole images. We present a purely geometric proof that spherically symmetric, isolated objects with horizons in gravity theories with null-geodesic propagation of light must display bound photon orbits forming a photon sphere. Identifying the key elements of the proof, we articulate a simpler argument that carries over to more general situations with modified light propagation and implies the existence of equatorial spherical photon orbits in axisymmetric spacetimes with reflection symmetry. We conclude that the \emph{non-}observation of photon rings with very-large-baseline interferometry would be a very strong indication against a horizon, irrespective of whether or not the image shows a central brightness depression.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
Photon sphere and quasinormal modes in AdS/CFT

Koji Hashimoto,Kakeru Sugiura,Katsuyuki Sugiyama,Takuya Yoda

2023-07-01

Abstract:Photon spheres are the characteristic of general black holes, thus are a suitable touchstone for the emergence of gravitational spacetime in the AdS/CFT correspondence. We provide a spectral analysis of an AdS Schwarzschild black hole near its photon sphere. We find that quasinormal modes near the photon sphere reflect the AdS boundary, resulting in a peculiar spectral pattern. Our large angular momentum analysis owes to an analogue to solvable Schrödinger equations such as an inverted harmonic oscillator and the Pöschl-Teller model, with a Dirichlet boundary condition. Through the AdS/CFT dictionary, it predicts the existence of a peculiar subsector in the large angular momentum spectrum of thermal holographic CFTs on a sphere.

High Energy Physics - Theory
Static spheres around spherically symmetric black hole spacetime

Shao-Wen Wei,Yu-Peng Zhang,Yu-Xiao Liu,Robert B. Mann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.043050

2023-10-23

Abstract:Unique features of particle orbits produce novel signatures of gravitational observable phenomena, and are quite useful in testing compact astrophysical objects in general relativity or modified theories of gravity. Here we observe a representative example that a static, spherically symmetric black hole solution with nonlinear electrodynamics admits static points at finite radial distance. Each static point thus produces a static sphere, on which a massive test particle can remain at rest at arbitrary latitudes with respect to an asymptotic static observer. As a result, the well-known static Dyson spheres can be implemented by such orbits. More interestingly, employing a topological argument, we disclose that stable and unstable static spheres (if they exist) always come in pairs in an asymptotically flat spacetime. In contrast to this, the counterpart naked singularity has one more stable static sphere than the unstable one. Our results have potential applications in testing black holes in standard Maxwell and nonlinear electrodynamics, as well as in uncovering the underlying astronomical observation effects in other gravitational theories beyond general relativity.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Uniqueness of dark matter magnetized static black hole spacetime

Marek Rogatko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.108.064026

2023-09-15

Abstract:Uniqueness problem of static axially symmetric black hole in magnetic Universe filled with {\it dark matter} component has been considered. The {\it dark matter} model comprises the additional $U(1)$-gauge field ({\it dark photon}) interacting with Maxwell one by the kinetic mixing term. We show that all the solutions of Einstein-Maxwell {\it dark photon} gravity subject to the same boundary and regularity conditions authorize the only static axially symmetric black hole solutions with non-vanishing time and azimuthal components of Maxwell and {\it hidden} sector gauge fields, say Schwarzschild-like black hole immersed in {\it dark matter} Melvin Universe.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
A generalization of photon sphere based on escape/capture cone

Masaya Amo,Keisuke Izumi,Hirotaka Yoshino,Yoshimune Tomikawa,Tetsuya Shiromizu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-024-12954-9

2024-06-27

Abstract:In asymptotically flat spacetimes, bearing the null geodesics reaching the future null infinity in mind, we propose new concepts, the "dark horizons" as generalizations of the photon sphere. They are defined in terms of the structure of escape/capture cones of photons with respect to a unit timelike vector field. More specifically, considering a two-sphere that represents a set of emission directions of photons, the dark horizons are located at positions where a hemisphere is marginally included in the capture and escape cones, respectively. We show that both of them are absent in the Minkowski spacetime, while they exist in spacetimes with black hole(s) under a certain condition. We derive the general properties of the dark horizons in spherically symmetric spacetimes and explicitly calculate the locations of the dark horizons in the Vaidya spacetime and the Kerr spacetime.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,High Energy Physics - Theory

Uniqueness of photon spheres in static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes

Uniqueness of the static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes with massive particle spheres

Uniqueness of photon sphere for Reissner-Nordström electric-magnetic system

Uniqueness of equipotential photon surfaces in 4-dimensional static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes for positive, negative, and zero mass -- and a new partial proof of the Willmore inequality

Black Hole and Equipotential Photon Surface Uniqueness in 4-dimensional Asymptotically Flat Electrostatic Electro-Vacuum Spacetimes

Photon surfaces as pure tension shells: Uniqueness of thin shell wormholes

The Existence and Distribution of Photon Spheres Near Spherically Symmetric Black Holes -- A Geometric Analysis

On equipotential photon surfaces in (electro-)static spacetimes of arbitrary dimension

Uniqueness of the extremal Schwarzschild de Sitter spacetime

Uniqueness of static vacuum asymptotically flat black holes and equipotential photon surfaces in $n+1$ dimensions à la Robinson

Uniqueness of the AdS Spacetime among Static Vacua with prescribed Null infinity

Black holes with multiple photon spheres

Dynamical photon spheres in charged black holes and naked singularities

Black hole horizons must be veiled by photon spheres

Photon sphere and quasinormal modes in AdS/CFT

Static spheres around spherically symmetric black hole spacetime

Uniqueness of dark matter magnetized static black hole spacetime

A generalization of photon sphere based on escape/capture cone