Abstract:A configuration space approach is developed to uncover generic stability peculiarities for the lowest energy neutral and charged exciton complexes (biexciton and trion) in quasi-one-dimensional semiconductors. Trions are shown to be more stable than biexcitons in strongly confined structures with small reduced electron-hole masses. Biexcitons are more stable in less confined structures with large reduced electron-hole masses. In semiconducting carbon nanotubes, in particular, the trion binding energy is shown to be greater than that of the biexciton by a factor ~1.4 decreasing with diameter, thus revealing the general physical principles that underlie recent experimental observations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in quasi - one - dimensional (quasi - 1D) semiconductors, the relative stability of different types of exciton complexes (especially biexcitons and trions) and the differences in their binding energies. Specifically, the author studies the stability characteristics of these complexes in confined structures through the configuration - space method and explains the experimentally observed phenomena.
### Main problems and background
1. **Comparison of the stability of biexcitons and trions**:
- In strongly confined quasi - one - dimensional structures, especially carbon nanotubes (CNs) with small diameters, the binding energy of trions is usually greater than that of biexcitons.
- In weakly confined quasi - one - dimensional structures, biexcitons are more stable.
2. **Theoretical explanation of experimental phenomena**:
- The latest nonlinear optical experiments show that in carbon nanotubes with small diameters (<∼1 nm), the binding energy of trions significantly exceeds that of biexcitons.
- For example, Colombier et al. [32] and Yuma et al. [33] reported that in (9,7) and (6,5) carbon nanotubes respectively, the trion binding energies are 150 meV and 190 meV, while the corresponding biexciton binding energies are 106 meV and 130 meV respectively.
### Research methods
The author uses a configuration - space approach. By analyzing the behavior of two interacting ground - state one - dimensional excitons in carbon nanotubes, the form of the Hamiltonian describing these systems is derived. The specific steps include:
1. **Construction of the Hamiltonian**:
- Using the cylindrical coordinate system, the longitudinal motion of each exciton is converted into the center - of - mass coordinates.
- Construct a Hamiltonian that includes the electron - hole Coulomb interaction.
2. **Calculation of the binding energy**:
- The biexciton binding energy \( E_{XX} \) is defined as:
\[
E_{XX}=E_g - 2E_X
\]
where \( E_g \) is the lowest eigenvalue of equation (1), \( E_X = -\frac{Ry^*}{\nu_0^2} \) is the binding energy of a single exciton, and \( \nu_0 \) is the lowest bound - state quantum number of the one - dimensional exciton.
- The trion binding energy \( E_X^* \) can be obtained by modifying the Hamiltonian and solving the Schrödinger equation:
\[
E_X^* = -\frac{|E_X|}{e^{22}\sqrt{\frac{Ry^*}{|E_X|}}}
\]
3. **Calculation of the binding - energy ratio**:
- The ratio of the trion to biexciton binding energy is:
\[
\frac{E_X^*}{E_{XX}} = 3\left(\frac{3}{2e}\right)^2\sqrt{\frac{Ry^*}{|E_X|}}
\]
### Conclusions
Through calculations of different sizes and material parameters, the author draws the following conclusions:
- In strongly confined quasi - one - dimensional structures (such as small - diameter carbon nanotubes), due to the smaller effective mass, the trion has a larger binding energy.
- In weakly confined quasi - one - dimensional structures, the larger effective mass makes biexcitons more stable.
- For carbon nanotubes with diameters less than about 1 nm, the theoretical prediction is that the trion binding energy is approximately 1.4 times that of the biexciton, which is consistent with the latest experimental results.
### Experimental verification
The author also verifies the validity of the theoretical model by comparing experimental data, especially in small - diameter carbon nanotubes, the theoretically predicted binding - energy ratio is consistent with the experimentally measured results.
In summary, this paper reveals the stability laws of exciton complexes in quasi - one - dimensional semiconductors through a theoretical model and explains the experimentally observed phenomena.