Two-photon echo method for observing electron Zitterbewegung in carbon nanotubes

Tomasz M. Rusin,Wlodek Zawadzki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0268-1242/29/12/125010

2014-04-25

Abstract:The phenomenon of Zitterbewegung (ZB, trembling motion) of electrons is described in zigzag carbon nanotubes (CNT) excited by laser pulses. The tight binding approach is used for the band structure of CNT and the effect of light is introduced by the vector potential. Contrary to the common theoretical practice, no a priori assumptions are made concerning electron wave packet, the latter is determined as a result of illumination. In order to overcome the problem of various electron phases in ZB, a method of two-photon echo is considered and described using the density function formalism. The medium polarization of CNT is calculated by computing exact solutions of the time-dependent electron Hamiltonian. The signal of two-photon echo is extracted and it is shown that, using existing parameters of CNT and laser pulses, one should be able to observe the electron trembling motion. Effects of electron decoherence and relaxation are discussed.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to experimentally observe the Zitterbewegung (ZB) phenomenon of electrons in carbon nanotubes (CNT)**. Specifically, the author proposes and verifies a method using the **two - photon echo technique** to overcome the challenge of the difficulty in directly observing the ZB phenomenon.

### Background and Problem

1. **Historical background of the Zitterbewegung (ZB) phenomenon**:
- ZB was first proposed by Schrödinger in 1930, which describes the rapid oscillatory motion of a free electron in a vacuum due to the interference between positive and negative energy states.
- Although ZB has been widely studied theoretically, experimental observations in solid materials have not been achieved, mainly because:
- It is difficult to prepare electron wave packets with specific initial quasi - momenta in experiments.
- Electrons in crystals oscillate in different directions and phases, causing the oscillation signals to cancel each other out.

2. **Limitations of existing methods**:
- Traditional theoretical methods usually assume the form of electron wave packets, which is difficult to achieve experimentally.
- Directly observing the motion of a single electron is very difficult in practice.

### Solution

To overcome the above difficulties, the author proposes the following solutions:

1. **Application of the two - photon echo technique**:
- Inspired by the Bloch oscillation experiment, the author adopts the two - photon echo technique in nonlinear optics.
- Through the interference of two laser pulses, a signal in the background - free direction can be generated, so that the oscillation signals of individual electrons can be coherently superimposed, thereby enhancing the observable signal strength.

2. **No need to pre - assume the wave packet form**:
- The author does not assume the specific form of the electron wave packet but determines the characteristics of the wave packet after excitation by the laser pulse.
- This can be closer to the actual situation and avoids prior assumptions about the wave packet characteristics.

3. **Accurate calculation of medium polarization**:
- Calculate the medium polarization using the density matrix (DM) formalism, taking into account relaxation and decoherence effects.
- By solving the time - dependent Hamiltonian, an exact solution is obtained instead of using perturbation expansion.

### Results and Significance

Through the above methods, the author successfully simulated the ZB phenomenon and showed that under the existing carbon nanotube and laser pulse parameters, the trembling motion of electrons should be observable. This result provides a theoretical basis and technical path for future experimental verification of the ZB phenomenon.

### Formula Summary

- **Hamiltonian**:
\[
\hat{H}(t)=t_{AB}\begin{pmatrix}
0 & h(t)^*\\
h(t) & 0
\end{pmatrix},
\]
where \(h(t) = e^{iq(t)a/\sqrt{3}}+2e^{-iq(t)a/(2\sqrt{3})}\cos\left(\frac{m\pi}{N}\right)\) and \(q(t)=k - \frac{e}{\hbar}A(t)\).

- **Density matrix evolution equation**:
\[
\frac{d}{dt}\hat{\rho}=-\frac{i}{\hbar}[\hat{H},\hat{\rho}]-\hat{D}(\hat{\rho}),
\]
where \(\hat{D}(\hat{\rho})\) contains relaxation and decoherence processes.

- **Average velocity**:
\[
\langle v_{k,m}(t)\rangle=\text{Tr}\{\hat{\rho}(t)\hat{V}\},
\]
where \(\hat{V}\) is the representation of the velocity operator in the \(w_1\) and \(w_2\) bases.

- **Medium polarization**:
\[
P(t)= - |e|\int_0^t\langle v(t')\rangle dt'.
\]