Self-Averaging Property of Minimal Investment Risk of Mean-Variance Model

Takashi Shinzato
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0133846
2014-04-22
Abstract:In portfolio optimization problems, the minimum expected investment risk is not always smaller than the expected minimal investment risk. That is, using a well-known approach from operations research, it is possible to derive a strategy that minimizes the expected investment risk, but this strategy does not always result in the best rate of return on assets. Prior to making investment decisions, it is important to an investor to know the potential minimal investment risk (or the expected minimal investment risk) and to determine the strategy that will maximize the return on assets. We use the self-averaging property to analyze the potential minimal investment risk and the concentrated investment level for the strategy that gives the best rate of return. We compare the results from our method with the results obtained by the operations research approach and with those obtained by a numerical simulation using the optimal portfolio. The results of our method and the numerical simulation are in agreement, but they differ from that of the operations research approach.
Portfolio Management,Optimization and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the difference between the minimum expected investment risk and the actual minimum investment risk in portfolio optimization. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to use the self - averaging property to analyze the potential minimum investment risk and the level of concentrated investment in the portfolio optimization problem, and whether these indicators can effectively evaluate the optimal solution. By comparing their method with the results of operations research methods and numerical simulations, the author explores the importance of understanding the potential minimum investment risk before making investment decisions and verifies the effectiveness of the self - averaging property. ### Background of the Paper and Problem Description 1. **Portfolio Optimization Problem**: In financial investment, investors usually hope to find a strategy that can both minimize investment risk and maximize asset return. However, the minimum expected investment risk obtained by using traditional operations research methods is not always equal to the actual minimum investment risk. 2. **Self - Averaging Property**: The self - averaging property refers to the property that some statistics will approach their expected values under a large number of samples. The paper uses this property to analyze the potential minimum investment risk and the level of concentrated investment in the portfolio optimization problem, hoping to provide more accurate risk assessment. ### Research Methods 1. **Theoretical Framework**: - **Markowitz Mean - Variance Model**: This is one of the most commonly used asset allocation models, which reduces risk by minimizing the variance of portfolio returns. - **Self - Averaging Property**: By introducing the self - averaging property, analyze the potential minimum investment risk and the level of concentrated investment of the portfolio. 2. **Method Comparison**: - **Operations Research Methods**: Traditional operations research methods solve the optimal investment strategy by first averaging the risk function and then minimizing the averaged risk function. - **Numerical Simulation**: Through the numerical simulation method, verify the effectiveness of the self - averaging property in actual investment. ### Main Contributions 1. **Mathematical Proof**: Provide a mathematical proof of the self - averaging property and verify the effectiveness of this property in the portfolio optimization problem. 2. **Strategy Evaluation**: By comparing the results of different methods, verify the advantages of the self - averaging property in evaluating the optimal investment strategy. 3. **Practical Application**: Propose a framework based on the self - averaging property for evaluating the potential minimum investment risk and the level of concentrated investment in actual investment decisions. ### Conclusion By introducing the self - averaging property, the paper provides a new method to evaluate the potential minimum investment risk and the level of concentrated investment in the portfolio optimization problem. Compared with traditional operations research methods, this method can more accurately reflect the risk situation in actual investment, thus providing more valuable decision - making support for investors.