Abstract:Scaling laws are powerful summaries of the variations of urban attributes with city size. However, the validity of their universal meaning for cities is hampered by the observation that different scaling regimes can be encountered for the same territory, time and attribute, depending on the criteria used to delineate cities. The aim of this paper is to present new insights concerning this variation, coupled with a sensitivity analysis of urban scaling in France, for several socio-economic and infrastructural attributes from data collected exhaustively at the local level. The sensitivity analysis considers different aggregations of local units for which data are given by the Population Census. We produce a large variety of definitions of cities (approximatively 5000) by aggregating local Census units corresponding to the systematic combination of three definitional criteria: density, commuting flows and population cutoffs. We then measure the magnitude of scaling estimations and their sensitivity to city definitions for several urban indicators, showing for example that simple population cutoffs impact dramatically on the results obtained for a given system and attribute. Variations are interpreted with respect to the meaning of the attributes (socio-economic descriptors as well as infrastructure) and the urban definitions used (understood as the combination of the three criteria). Because of the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem and of the heterogeneous morphologies and social landscapes in the cities internal space, scaling estimations are subject to large variations, distorting many of the conclusions on which generative models are based. We conclude that examining scaling variations might be an opportunity to understand better the inner composition of cities with regard to their size, i.e. to link the scales of the city-system with the system of cities.

How congestion shapes cities: from mobility patterns to scaling

From global scaling to the dynamics of individual cities

Scaling law of real traffic jams under varying travel demand

Growth, innovation, scaling, and the pace of life in cities

Understanding the mesoscopic scaling patterns within cities

Geometry of commutes in the universality of percolating traffic flows

The scaling of human interactions with city size

Scaling laws for the movement of people between locations in a large city

Critical factors for mitigating car traffic in cities

The universality in urban commuting across and within cities

Scaling of Multiple Functional Facilities Covering Comprehensive Processes in Cities

Traffic congestion and its urban scale factors: Empirical evidence from American urban areas

The hypothesis of urban scaling: formalization, implications and challenges

Analyzing urban scaling laws in the United States over 115 years

The statistical physics of Cities

Paradoxical Interpretations of Urban Scaling Laws

Revisiting the coupling between accessibility and population growth

The growth equation of cities

Evolution of road infrastructures in large urban areas

Analysing macroscopic traffic rhythms and city size in affluent cities: insights from a global panel data of 25 cities

Understanding congested travel in urban areas