Abstract:Managed populations of the European honey bee (Apis mellifera) support the production of a global food supply. This important role in modern agriculture has rendered honey bees vulnerable to the noxious effects of anthropogenic stressors such as pesticides. Although the deleterious outcomes of lethal pesticide exposure on honey bee health and performance are apparent, the ominous role of sublethal pesticide exposure is an emerging concern as well. Here, we use a data harvesting approach to better understand the toxicological effects of pesticide exposure across the honey bee life cycle. Through compiling adult- and larval-specific median lethal dose (LD50) values from 93 published data sources, LD50 estimates for insecticides, herbicides, acaricides, and fungicides are highly variable across studies, especially for herbicides and fungicides, which are underrepresented in the meta-data set. Alongside major discrepancies in these reported values, further examination of the compiled data suggested that LD50 may not be an ideal metric for honey bee risk assessment. We also discuss how sublethal effects of pesticide exposure, which are not typically measured in LD50 studies, can diminish honey bee reproduction, immunity, cognition, and overall physiological functioning, leading to suboptimal honey bee performance and population reduction. In consideration of actionable solutions to mitigate the effects of sublethal pesticide exposure, we have identified the potential for probiotic supplementation as a promising strategy that can be easily incorporated alongside current agricultural infrastructure and apicultural management practices. Probiotic supplementation is regularly employed in apiculture but the potential for evidence-based targeted approaches has not yet been fully explored within a formal toxicological context. We discuss the benefits, practical considerations, and limitations for the use and delivery of probiotics to hives. Ultimately, by subverting the sublethal effects of pesticides we can help improve the long-term survival of these critical pollinators.

Honey bee stressor networks are complex and dependent on crop and region

Bee Stressors from an Immunological Perspective and Strategies to Improve Bee Health

Low Levels of Hive Stress Are Associated with Decreased Honey Activity and Changes to the Gut Microbiome of Resident Honey Bees

Pollen foraging mediates exposure to dichotomous stressor syndromes in honey bees

Bee colony health indicators: synthesis and future directions.

Stress-induced loss of social resilience in honeybee colonies and its implications on fitness

Bee Health and Productivity in Apis mellifera, a Consequence of Multiple Factors

Stress drives premature hive exiting behavior that leads to death in young honey bee (Apis mellifera) workers

Honey bee colonies can buffer short-term stressor effects of pollen restriction and fungicide exposure on colony development and the microbiome

Honey bee pathology: current threats to honey bees and beekeeping

Stress decreases pollen foraging performance in honeybees

Bee declines driven by combined stress from parasites, pesticides, and lack of flowers

Nutritive and immunological benefits derived from the honey bee gut microbiome are threatened by anthropogenic stressors

Interactive effects of chlorothalonil and Varroa destructor on Apis mellifera during adult stage

Factors Associated with Honey Bee Colony Losses: A Mini-Review

Mechanisms of pathogen and pesticide resistance in honey bees

Interaction of acetamiprid, Varroa destructor, and Nosema ceranae in honey bees

Brood indicators are an early warning signal of honey bee colony loss-a simulation-based study

Honey bees (Apis mellifera) modify plant-pollinator network structure, but do not alter wild species' interactions

Understanding the Effects of Sublethal Pesticide Exposure on Honey Bees: A Role for Probiotics as Mediators of Environmental Stress

Metabolomics-based biomarker discovery for bee health monitoring: A proof of concept study concerning nutritional stress in Bombus terrestris