Abstract:This study investigates the effects of visual mnemonics and the methods of presenting learning materials on learning visually similar characters for Chinese-as-second-language (CSL) learners. In supporting CSL learners to build robust orthographic representations in Chinese, addressing the challenges of visual similarity of characters (e.g., 理 and 埋) is an important issue. Based on prior research on perceptual learning, we tested three strategies that differ in the extent to which they promote interrelated attention to the form and meaning of characters: (1) Stroke Sequence, a form-emphasis strategy, (2) Key-images, a form + meaning strategy utilizing visual code, (3) Pithy Formulas with Key-images, a form + meaning strategy combining visual and verbal codes. A pretest–posttest equivalent-group design was adopted. The independent variables were the learning strategy, the method of presenting character pairs (visually similar vs. dissimilar), and testing time. The dependent variables were learners’ proportions of accurate responses to reading and writing Chinese characters through a posttest (immediately performed after learning) and a delayed posttest (1 week after learning); a learner experience survey was also administered to investigate learners’ opinions on each strategy. Sixty-six non-beginning learners of Chinese participated; they were randomly assigned to one of the two groups in which participants learned ten characters via the three strategies, respectively, differing between whether the characters were presented in similar pairs or dissimilar pairs. Data were analyzed via three-way ANCOVAs. The Pithy Formulas with Key-images and the Key-images generally yielded higher writing accuracy than Stroke Sequence immediately after learning. Notably, the advantage of the Pithy Formulas with Key-images (verbal and visual) over the Key-images (visual) on writing was specific to the participants that learned with visually similar pairs rather than those that learned with dissimilar pairs. All strategies were effective for reading, yet learners’ experience ratings favored the two form + meaning strategies over the strategy that focused primarily on form. Suggestions for future research and pedagogical implications on learning visually similar characters were offered.

How do figure-like orthographs modulate visual processing of Chinese words?

Recent Advances in Research on Reading and Processing of Chinese Characters with Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Orthographic and phonological processing of Chinese characters: an fMRI study

Functional interactions underlying visuospatial orthographic processes in Chinese reading

Phonological, not semantic, activation dominates Chinese character recognition: Evidence from a visual world eye-tracking study

Differential cerebral involvement in perceiving Chinese characters: Levels of processing approach

A meta-analysis of fMRI studies on Chinese orthographic, phonological, and semantic processing

Brain Activation in the Processing of Chinese Characters and Words: A Functional Mri Study

Orthographic and phonological processing in the left ventral occipitotemporal cortex during Chinese word reading

Effects of Phonological Consistency and Semantic Radical Combinability on N170 and P200 in the Reading of Chinese Phonograms

The role of orthographic and phonological processing during reading Chinese sentences: Evidence from eye movements

The Processing of Visual and Phonological Configurations of Chinese One- and Two-Character Words in a Priming Task of Semantic Categorization

Early Electrophysiological Basis Of Experience-Associated Holistic Processing Of Chinese Characters

Functional connectivity during orthographic, phonological, and semantic processing of Chinese characters identifies distinct visuospatial and phonosemantic networks

P200 Can Be Modulated by Orthography Alone in Reading Chinese Words

Decoding the neural impact of radical complexity in Chinese characters during working memory task

The Time Course Of Speech Production Revisited: No Early Orthographic Effect, Even In Mandarin Chinese

The Neural System Underlying Chinese Logograph Reading

How the brain encodes morphological constraints during Chinese word reading: An EEG-fNIRS study

Neural correlates of phonology-to-orthography mapping consistency effects on Chinese spoken word recognition

The Effect of Visual Mnemonics and the Presentation of Character Pairs on Learning Visually Similar Characters for Chinese-As-Second-Language Learners