Abstract:The field of metamaterial research revolves around the idea of creating artificial media that interact with light in a way unknown from naturally occurring materials. This is commonly achieved by creating sub-wavelength lattices of electronic or plasmonic structures, so-called meta-atoms, that determine the interaction between light and metamaterial. One of the ultimate goals for these tailored media is the ability to control their properties in-situ which has led to a whole new branch of tunable and switchable metamaterials. Many of the present realizations rely on introducing microelectromechanical actuators or semiconductor elements into their meta-atom structures. Here we show that superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs) can be used as fast, intrinsically switchable meta-atoms. We found that their intrinsic nonlinearity leads to simultaneously stable dynamic states, each of which is associated with a different value and sign of the magnetic susceptibility in the microwave domain. Moreover, we demonstrate that it is possible to switch between these states by applying a nanosecond long pulse in addition to the microwave probe signal. Apart from potential applications such as, for example, an all-optical metamaterial switch, these results suggest that multi-stability, which is a common feature in many nonlinear systems, can be utilized to create new types of meta-atoms.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how to use superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs) as switchable meta - atoms to achieve rapid, in - situ control of the properties of metamaterials. Specifically, the authors focus on the fact that when operating non - hysteretic single - junction SQUIDs in the medium - power range, these devices can exhibit multi - stability, that is, multiple stable dynamic states exist simultaneously. Each stable state corresponds to a different value of magnetic susceptibility, so that SQUIDs can switch between different states, thereby changing their interaction characteristics with electromagnetic waves. ### Core problems of the paper 1. **Multi - stable state phenomenon**: Research on the multi - stable state phenomenon exhibited by SQUIDs under specific parameter conditions. The existence of these stable states means that SQUIDs can switch between different values of magnetic susceptibility, including large positive and negative values of magnetic susceptibility and small positive values close to zero. 2. **Fast - switching mechanism**: Verify that reliable switching between these stable states can be achieved by applying nanosecond - level microwave pulses. This switching depends on the intrinsic nonlinear characteristics of SQUIDs, rather than external mechanical or semiconductor components. 3. **Theoretical model construction**: Develop an analytical model to describe and predict the multi - stable behavior of SQUIDs under different driving conditions, and verify the validity of this model through experiments. ### Specific implementation methods - **Experimental design**: Conduct experiments using a one - dimensional SQUID array loaded with a coplanar waveguide (CPW). Observe the changes in transmission characteristics by changing the input power and applying short pulses. - **Theoretical model**: Based on the rotating - wave approximation (RWA), an analytical model describing the dynamic behavior of SQUIDs is established. The nonlinear effects of Josephson junctions are considered in the model, and stable and metastable solutions are obtained by solving the equations of motion. - **Data analysis**: Verify the existence of the multi - stable state phenomenon by measuring the changes in transmission phase and amplitude, and show the changes in magnetic susceptibility in different states. ### Main conclusions - SQUIDs exhibit multi - stable state phenomena in the medium - power range and can quickly switch states through short pulses. - The analytical model can well explain the experimental results, especially the effect is most significant near the LC resonance frequency. - Propose the possibility of using SQUIDs as switchable meta - atoms, providing theoretical and technical support for the development of new metamaterials. In general, this paper shows how to use the nonlinear characteristics of SQUIDs to achieve rapid and controllable switching of metamaterial properties, which provides new ideas for future optoelectronic devices and communication technologies.

A multi-stable switchable metamaterial

Spin-dependent switchable metasurfaces using phase change materials.

Micromachined Switchable Metamaterial with Dual Resonance

Switchable Magnetic Metamaterials Using Micromachining Processes

Reconfigurable All-Dielectric Antenna-Based Metasurface Driven by Multipolar Resonances.

Implementation of a Quantum Metamaterial

Switching the Electric and Magnetic Responses in a Metamaterial

Metamaterial all-optical switching based on resonance mode coupling in dielectric meta-atoms

Stable and Bistable Squid Metamaterials

Superconducting Complementary Metamaterial-Based Switchable Device for Terahertz Wave Manipulation

Optical Switching Of A Metamaterial By Temperature Controlling

Topological transformability and reprogrammability of multistable mechanical metamaterials

Multistable Topological Mechanical Metamaterials

Multistate Switching of Photonic Angular Momentum Coupling in Phase‐Change Metadevices

Plasmonic Metasurfaces for Switchable Photonic Spin-Orbit Interactions Based on Phase Change Materials

Electrically Terahertz Switchable Device Based on Superconducting Composite Structure Metamaterial

Polarization-modulating switchable and selectable image display through an ultrathin quasi-bound-state-in-the-continuum metasurface

Bifunctional Spatiotemporal Metasurfaces for Incident Angle-Tunable and Ultrafast Optically Switchable Electromagnetically Induced Transparency

Electro-Optical Switching in a Nonlinear Metasurface

Optical bistability with film-coupled metasurfaces

Optically Reconfigurable THz Metamaterial with Switchable Wideband Absorption and Transmission