Stability of 41 metal - boron systems at 0 GPa and 30 GPa from first principles

A.G. Van Der Geest,A.N. Kolmogorov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2014.03.005
2014-10-03
Abstract:A multitude of observed boron-based materials have outstanding superconducting, mechanical, and refractory properties. Yet, the structure, the composition, and the very existence of some reported metal boride (M-B) compounds have been a subject of extensive debate. This density functional theory work seeks to set a baseline for current understanding of known metal boride phases as well as to identify new synthesizable candidates. We have generated a database of over 12,000 binary M-B entries for pressures of 0 and 30 GPa producing the largest scan of compositions and systems in this materials class. The 175 selected crystal structures include both observed prototypes and new ones found with our evolutionary ground state search. The metals considered are: Al, Ag, Au, Ba, Be, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cs, Cu, Fe, Hf, Hg, Ir, K, La, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Nb, Ni, Os, Pd, Pt, Rb, Re, Rh, Ru, Sc, Sr, Ta, Tc, Ti, V, W, Y, Zn, and Zr. Based on the formation energy calculated at zero pressure and temperature 4 new M-B phases or structures have been predicted, while a number of previously reported compounds have been shown to be unstable. At 30 GPa, changes in the convex hulls are expected to occur in 18 out of 41 M-B systems, which is used to indicate regions of the periodic table (for metal borides) that require further investigation from the community. Analysis of the collected information has revealed a nearly linear relationship between the magnetic moment per atom and the metal content for all the Fe-B, Co-B, and Ni-B structures within 0.15 eV/atom of the stability tie line. Both GGA-PBE and LDA-PW functionals were used to provide an understanding of the systematic error introduced by the choice of the exchange-correlation functional.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve This paper aims to systematically study the stability and structure of 41 metal-boron (M-B) systems through first-principles calculations, in order to address the following key issues: 1. **Stability of Known Metal Borides**: - Confirm the stability of known metal borides, including their forms at ambient pressure (0 GPa) and high pressure (30 GPa). - Verify whether some reported metal borides are truly stable or if there are false reports. 2. **Prediction of New Metal Borides**: - Predict new synthesizable metal borides through large-scale computational screening. - Generate a database containing over 12,000 binary M-B entries, covering various compositions and systems under ambient and high-pressure conditions. 3. **Effect of Pressure on Metal Borides**: - Analyze phase transitions and stability changes of metal borides under different pressure conditions (especially 30 GPa). - Identify which metal borides become more stable or unstable under high pressure. 4. **Trend Analysis of Material Properties**: - Establish trends in metal boride systems and compositions to better understand the properties of these materials. - Reveal the relationship between metal content and magnetic moment by calculating parameters such as formation energy and magnetic moment, providing theoretical guidance for material design. 5. **Evaluation of Computational Methods**: - Compare the effects of different exchange-correlation functionals (e.g., GGA-PBE and LDA-PW) on the results to assess systematic errors in computational methods. - Validate the reliability and accuracy of computational methods by comparing with experimental data. ### Specific Goals - **Confirm the Stability of Known Compounds**: Verify the stability of known metal borides under different pressure conditions through calculations. - **Predict New Compounds**: Predict new stable metal borides using evolutionary algorithms and high-throughput calculations. - **Analyze Pressure Effects**: Study phase transitions and stability changes of metal borides under different pressure conditions. - **Establish Trends**: Establish stability trends of metal borides through data analysis to provide references for material design. - **Evaluate Computational Methods**: Compare results from different computational methods to assess their reliability and applicability. ### Summary This paper systematically studies the stability and structure of 41 metal-boron systems through large-scale first-principles calculations. It aims to confirm the stability of known compounds, predict new synthesizable compounds, and analyze phase transitions and stability changes under different pressure conditions. Additionally, through trend analysis and evaluation of computational methods, it provides an important theoretical foundation for the study of metal borides.