Autocatalysis in Reaction Networks

Abhishek Deshpande,Manoj Gopalkrishnan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11538-014-0024-x

2014-08-06

Abstract:The persistence conjecture is a long-standing open problem in chemical reaction network theory. It concerns the behavior of solutions to coupled ODE systems that arise from applying mass-action kinetics to a network of chemical reactions. The idea is that if all reactions are reversible in a weak sense, then no species can go extinct. A notion that has been found useful in thinking about persistence is that of "critical siphon." We explore the combinatorics of critical siphons, with a view towards the persistence conjecture. We introduce the notions of "drainable" and "self-replicable" (or autocatalytic) siphons. We show that: every minimal critical siphon is either drainable or self-replicable; reaction networks without drainable siphons are persistent; and non-autocatalytic weakly-reversible networks are persistent. Our results clarify that the difficulties in proving the persistence conjecture are essentially due to competition between drainable and self-replicable siphons.

Dynamical Systems,Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science,Molecular Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

The paper aims to address a long-standing unsolved problem in the theory of chemical reaction networks—the **persistence conjecture**. This problem concerns the behavior of solutions to a series of chemical reaction networks when the law of mass action is applied. Specifically, if all reactions are reversible in some weak sense, then no species will go extinct.

#### Main Contributions

1. **Concept of Critical Siphons**:
- The paper explores the combinatorial properties of "critical siphons" and relates them to the persistence conjecture. Critical siphons refer to a set of species that can lead to a reduction in the number of species under certain conditions.
- Introduces the concepts of "drainable" and "self-replicable" (or autocatalytic) siphons.
- Proves that every minimal critical siphon is either drainable or self-replicable.

2. **Persistence Results**:
- Proves that reaction networks without drainable siphons are persistent.
- Proves that weakly reversible networks that are not self-replicable are also persistent.

3. **Difficulty Analysis**:
- Points out that the main difficulty in proving the persistence conjecture lies in the competition between drainable siphons and self-replicable siphons.

4. **Biological Dynamics Background**:
- The biological motivation comes from synthetic biology, particularly the DNA molecule programming community, where reaction networks are viewed as a programming language for the desired synthetic behavior. The research aims to find a programming language that naturally matches the dynamics of chemical reactions, allowing for meaningful testing and combination of different subsystems.

5. **Mathematical Tools**:
- Introduces the concept of "critical sets" and defines critical siphons as a set of species that are both critical sets and siphons.
- Proposes the Convex Rank-Nullity theorem, which is a result concerning matrices with specific sign patterns.

Through these theoretical and technical means, the paper provides new perspectives and methods for solving the persistence conjecture.