Abstract:Introduction: Muscles play a critical role in supporting joints during activities of daily living, owing, in part, to the phenomenon of short-range stiffness. Briefly, when an active muscle is lengthened, bound cross-bridges are stretched, yielding forces greater than what is predicted from the force length relationship. For this reason, short-range stiffness has been proposed as an attractive mechanism for providing joint stability. However, there has yet to be a forward dynamic simulation employing a cross-bridge model, that demonstrates this stabilizing role. Therefore, the purpose of this investigation was to test whether Huxley-type muscle elements, which exhibit short-range stiffness, can stabilize a joint while at constant activation. Methods: We analyzed the stability of an inverted pendulum (moment of inertia: 2.7 kg m2) supported by Huxley-type muscle models that reproduce the short-range stiffness phenomenon. We calculated the muscle forces that would provide sufficient short-range stiffness to stabilize the system based in minimizing the potential energy. Simulations consisted of a 50 ms long, 5 Nm square-wave perturbation, with numerical simulations carried out in ArtiSynth. Results: Despite the initial analysis predicting shared activity of antagonist and agonist muscles to maintain stable equilibrium, the inverted pendulum model was not stable, and did not maintain an upright posture even with fully activated muscles. Discussion & conclusion: Our simulations suggested that short-range stiffness cannot be solely responsible for joint stability, even for modest perturbations. We argue that short-range stiffness cannot achieve stability because its dynamics do not behave like a typical spring. Instead, an alternative conceptual model for short-range stiffness is that of a Maxwell element (spring and damper in series), which can be obtained as a first-order approximation to the Huxley model. We postulate that the damping that results from short-range stiffness slows down the mechanical response and allows the central nervous system time to react and stabilize the joint. We speculate that other mechanisms, like reflexes or residual force enhancement/depression, may also play a role in joint stability. Joint stability is due to a combination of factors, and further research is needed to fully understand this complex system.

Muscle as a meta-material operating near a critical point

Muscle short-range stiffness behaves like a maxwell element, not a spring: Implications for joint stability

Active hydraulics and odd elasticity of muscle fibers

Phenomenological Muscle Constitutive Model With Actin-Titin Binding for Simulating Active Stretching

Biochemical and structural basis of the passive mechanical properties of whole skeletal muscle

Structural Changes of Active Skeletal Muscles: Modelling, Validation and Numerical Experiments

Multiscale Mechanical Modeling of Skeletal Muscle: A Systemic Review of the Literature

Cooperative folding of muscle myosins: I. Mechanical model

Designed Biomaterials to Mimic the Mechanical Properties of Muscles

Contractility of cardiac and skeletal muscle tissue increases with environmental stiffness

Modèle théorique de la contraction musculaire squelettique : ressorts entropiques, processus stochastiques et mécanique classique (A theoretical model of skeletal muscular contraction : entropic springs, stochastic processes and classical mechanics)

The energy of muscle contraction. I. Tissue force and deformation during isometric contractions

Modeling implications of the relationship between active and passive skeletal muscle mechanical properties

Beyond power limits: the kinetic energy capacity of skeletal muscle

Fully non-linear hyper-viscoelastic modeling of skeletal muscle in compression

Rheological basis of skeletal muscle work loops

Paramagnetic response of muscle-type systems

Along- and cross-muscle fiber shear moduli in skeletal muscle

A three filament mechanistic model of musculotendon force and impedance

Simulation of active skeletal muscle tissue with a transversely isotropic viscohyperelastic continuum material model