Abstract:Multiple bases are presented for the conclusion that potentials are fundamental in electrodynamics, with electric and magnetic fields as quantities auxiliary to the scalar and vector potentials -- opposite to the conventional ordering. One foundation for the concept of basic potentials and auxiliary fields consists of examples where two sets of gauge-related fields are such that one is physical and the other is erroneous, with the information for the proper choice supplied by the potentials. A major consequence is that a change of gauge is not a unitary transformation in quantum mechanics; a principle heretofore unchallenged. The primacy of potentials over fields leads to the concept of a hierarchy of physical quantities, where potentials and energies are primary, while fields and forces are secondary. Secondary quantities provide less information than do primary quantities. Some criteria by which strong laser fields are judged are based on secondary quantities, making it possible to arrive at inappropriate conclusions. This is exemplified by several field-related misconceptions as diverse as the behavior of charged particles in very low frequency propagating fields, and the fundamental problem of pair production at very high intensities. In each case, an approach based on potentials gives appropriate results, free of ambiguities. The examples encompass classical and quantum phenomena, in relativistic and nonrelativistic conditions. This is a major extension of the quantum-only Aharonov-Bohm effect, both in supporting the primacy of potentials over fields, and also in showing how field-based conceptions can lead to errors in basic applications.

What Should be the Role of Field Energy in Introductory Physics Courses?

Applying the resources framework of teaching and learning to issues in middle school physics instruction on energy

Students' Views of Macroscopic and Microscopic Energy in Physics and Biology

Chemical energy in an introductory physics course for the life sciences

Effect of pressure on the superconducting transition temperature of doped and neutron-damaged MgB2

Understanding How Students Use Physical Ideas in Introductory Biology Courses

Inconsistencies and errors in traditional approaches to energy in our introductory courses

The role physics can play in a multi-disciplinary curriculum for non-physics scientists and engineers

The role of context and culture in teaching physics: The implication of disciplinary differences

Oersted Lecture 2013: How should we think about how our students think?

Negative Energy: Why Interdisciplinary Physics Requires Multiple Ontologies

Using disciplinary perspectives to refine conceptions of the "real world"

Alternative ideas about concepts of physics, a timelessly valuable tool for physics education

Entropy and spontaneity in an introductory physics course for life science students

Music of the Spheres: Teaching Quantum Field Theory at the Introductory Level

On the teaching and learning of physics: A Criticism and a Systemic Approach

Ascendancy of potentials over fields in electrodynamics

An equitable and effective approach to introductory mechanics

Reinventing college physics for biologists: Explicating an epistemological curriculum

Computational Thinking in Introductory Physics

Teaching and learning physics: A model for coordinating physics instruction, outreach, and research